Signing Patrick Peterson to replace Cam Sutton stabilizes the Steelers’ secondary in the short term, but the decision not to meet Sutton’s price in free agency does present some challenges for the front office and coaching staff.
While Peterson, who will turn 33 in July, enjoyed a resurgence in Minnesota the past two years, the details of the two-year, $14 million deal he will sign with the Steelers strongly suggests this is a one-year rental. He received $5.85 million in guarantees and his salary will be $1.3 million in 2023. In 2024, his compensation jumps to $3.8 million plus a $3 million roster bonus that is due in March of next year. His cap hit would rise to $9.75 million next year, as well.
In essence, the Steelers now have three corners entering the final year of their contracts. Ahkello Witherspoon and Levi Wallace both can become unrestricted free agents following the 2023 season. It also should be noted the Steelers can walk away from either without much penalty before the start of the regular season.
Witherspoon and Wallace are playing on identical contracts in 2023. Should the Steelers cut either, they would absorb just a $1.48 million dead-cap hit while saving the rest.
A trio of Peterson, Witherspoon and Wallace isn’t very diverse, either. All three are better-suited to play outside corner and not in the slot.
That’s an important distinction because Sutton’s versatility gave the coaching staff plenty of flexibility in the coverage schemes they called. Sutton played outside corner in the Steelers’ base defense the past two seasons, but he often moved inside to the slot in sub-packages when matchups dictated.
Read More
Last season, Sutton played 655 snaps on the outside and 185 in the slot. In addition to his age — he turned 28 in February — his diverse skill set is one of the reasons he was one of the top free agent corners this year. He signed for $33 million over three years, tripling his Steelers salary the past two years. He also received $22.5 million in guarantees, almost 16 million more than the Steelers guaranteed to Peterson.
Peterson has played the majority of his snaps on the outside and is most effective in that capacity. Wallace and Witherspoon have only played outside for the Steelers.
The lack of a diverse cornerback room could mean the Steelers plan on drafting two corners this spring — one outside corner Peterson can mentor, and a more versatile player who can play in the slot. Arthur Maulet started six games in the slot last season and played 45% of the snaps over the course of the season.
Maulet, who is under contract for 2023, has been a good early-down option in the slot, but he’s been replaced on passing downs by better cover corners.
The 2023 cornerback class is deep with outside and inside corners. If the Steelers are fortunate, one of the top three corners — Joey Porter Jr., Devon Witherspoon and Christian Gonzalez — will fall to them at No. 17. But if they are off the board by the time the Steelers select, it could bring into play a more versatile defensive back, although not likely in the first round.
Brian Branch of Alabama played in the slot in college, but he can also play in the box as a safety/run defender. He could be targeted with one of their two picks in the second round.
If the Steelers want to wait on a slot corner until later in the draft, they could take a closer look at some of the outside corners who are rising up draft boards after impressive performances at the combine. Deonte Banks of Maryland, Emmanuel Forbes of Mississippi and Kelee Ringo could be options at No. 17 or 32 — perhaps even No. 49, their second pick in the second round.
Either way, the likelihood of the Steelers drafting two corners went up significantly with the Peterson-Sutton swap.
Taking advantage of the deep pool of corners in this draft makes sense for the Steelers, but they would have to get the picks right.
Former general manager Kevin Colbert didn’t draft corners in the early rounds very often, and when he did, he didn’t have much success. In his 22 years in charge of the draft, he used first- or second-round picks on corners four times. Bryant McFadden developed into a good player who was a contributor on two Super Bowl-winning teams, but Ricardo Coclough, Senquez Golson and Artie Burns were disappointments.
New general manager Omar Khan made some changes in the Steelers personnel department with Andy Weidl, Mark Sadowski and Sheldon White at or near the top of the scouting department. The pressure is now squarely on them to identify the right corners who will be with the team beyond the 2023 season.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.