Is Mike Tomlin seriously considering starting Mason Rudolph over Mitch Trubisky if rookie Kenny Pickett is unable to play Sunday in Carolina?
Would he consider benching Trubisky a second time this season if Pickett fails to clear concussion protocol, especially after Tomlin conceded Trubisky “moved the ball fluidly continually” in Sunday’s 16-14 loss to the Baltimore Ravens?
Tomlin left open the possibility Tuesday at his weekly press conference when he didn’t directly answer a question about which quarterback would be the starter if Pickett is not cleared to play against the Panthers.
“I'm going to work both guys this week (in practice) if (Pickett) is not able to participate,” Tomlin said. “I'm taking it day-by-day from a quarterback decision making standpoint. I'm not even looking toward the end of the week, I'm really kind of just looking at what tomorrow looks like and playing it by ear from that perspective.”
Pickett was placed in concussion protocol after he was whipped to the ground on a sack by Ravens linebacker Roquan Smith on the opening series of the game. After being cleared to return to the game and telling his teammates he was fine, Pickett played one more three-play series and developed concussion-like symptoms without being hit. He was removed from the game.
Tomlin said he will follow the advice of his medical staff and if Pickett “is able to work, we'll work him. If he’s unable to work, we’ll divvy those reps between Mitch and Mason."
Read More
This is the second time in eight weeks Pickett has been in concussion protocol.
He cleared the five-step process and was allowed to return to practice in four days the previous time he sustained a concussion Oct 16 against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. He started that week in Miami. However, according to several UPMC neurosurgeons and neuropsychologists, who are considered the leaders in sports brain injury research and treatment, how a player recovers from one concussion has no correlation to how he will recover from another.
What’s more, according to those experts, just because a player suffers one concussion — or even two, as is the case with Pickett — doesn’t make it any more likely a player will sustain another.
Tomlin said the Steelers do not have to proceed any more cautiously this time with Pickett than they did two months ago.
“Not at all. I'm really comfortable with where we are,” he said. “As I've mentioned in the past, when we've had injuries of this nature, I’ve got nothing but great admiration and respect for our medical experts. People come from all over the world to visit with our guys and from other sports, as well. So, I'll let them do what it is they do.”
Maybe Tomlin is trying to be fair to Rudolph, who has been treated anything but since he wasn’t given an opportunity in training camp to compete for the starting position, despite proclamations it would be an open competition. Tomlin referred to Trubisky and Rudolph as “2 and 2A,” but Rudolph has been inactive for every game this season and doesn’t take any meaningful reps with the first- or second-team offense in practice.
Or, with the possibility of a playoff spot all but gone with four games remaining, maybe Tomlin is finally willing to try something different at quarterback in an attempt to win a game.
Or maybe he simply will bench Trubisky for throwing three interceptions in Ravens territory on Sunday — “point-swinging plays,” he called them — even though that didn’t stop him from doing the same when Pickett threw three interceptions in the second half against the New York Jets in his NFL debut.
“All three guys are sharp guys.” Tomlin said. “All three guys have been participants in our game planning, particularly of late, and all are very capable of playing the position and playing the position at a high level within what we're doing right now. So, we'll take it day to day and play it by ear.”
One thing is certain: If such a move occurs, it is not as though it will have any bearing on what will happen with the quarterback room next season.
Rudolph is an unrestricted free agent after the season and will look to play elsewhere in 2023. And Trubisky, who has a year remaining on his contract, will not want to come back after the way he believes he was treated this season. Plus, the Steelers would save $8 million in salary next season if they release or trade him.
Whatever Tomlin decides, if Pickett is unable to play, it will be the most interesting decision of the week.
“When you’ve got veteran backups, guys with a cumulative body of work, particularly in Mason's case, having been exposed to us and having been here and the receivers potentially that he would work with ... often times, when you're talking about a guy ascending within that position, you're calling on past experiences as a catalyst for how you move forward,” Tomlin said.
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.