As far as November afternoons on the North Side go, the atmosphere at Acrisure Stadium last Sunday before the Steelers-Saints game didn’t figure to create many wow moments. It was cold and overcast, the weather matching the mood of two teams blazing toward completely forgettable seasons.
Then public address announcer Larry Richert announced T.J. Watt, who emerged from the tunnel and did his patented leap into the air. For a moment, the crowd was whipped into a frenzy as if they were about to take in a playoff game.
There are tangible statistics to cite when illustrating Watt’s importance to the Steelers. The most quoted Steelers statistic of 2022 is the team’s record without Watt in the lineup. They are 1-10 all-time when Watt doesn’t play and 53-24-2 with him, including a 2-0 record this season.
It’s not a stretch to say the Steelers are twice as good when Watt plays. The Steelers average 3.4 sacks, 6.9 quarterback hits and 5.7 tackles for loss when he is in the lineup. Without him, they average 1.5 sacks, 3.4 quarterback hits and 3.5 tackles for loss.
But there’s more to it than numbers. On the Saints’ first series, upon Watt’s encouragement, the 66,000-strong crowd caused an illegal procedure penalty before the first snap. Then he was in on the first two tackles. It was a three-and-out, and the Steelers scored a touchdown on their next drive.
There are some things in football that simply can’t be quantified.
Read More
“There’s an intangible quality to players like him,” Steelers coach Mike Tomlin said. “They bring more than their presence and their playmaking. They instill confidence in those around them. So that is a very real thing. You can’t necessarily measure it, but if somebody’s been in this business, I acknowledge that it is real.”
Tomlin said he has been around “a few” players like Watt during his time in the NFL. He was on the Tampa Bay coaching staff when Derrick Brooks won NFL Defensive Player of the Year honors in 2002. Fellow Hall of Famer John Lynch also was on those Buccaneers teams in the early 2000s. With the Steelers, Tomlin has coached three players who won defensive player of the year — Watt, Troy Polamlau and James Harrison.
Defensive coordinator Teryl Austin similarly said he’s also only been around select players like Watt during his 20 years in the NFL.
“There’s a few, and he’s right up in there,” Austin said. “I was lucky enough to be in the same room with Ed Reed and Ray Lewis. Those are guys like T.J., they affect the whole room — their football sense, their football IQ, their football knowledge — anything football-related, they affect it. Those guys are great for your team. You’re always a better team when they’re on the field.”
Watt, of course, is only one of a number of great players in franchise history, which begged the questions of who else was so consequential to the Steelers’ success.
There are 19 Steelers enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, including nine defenders, and their teams managed just fine when they were injured. In fact, the Steelers did not have a losing record without any of them.
Not Mean Joe Greene, who is widely regarded as the franchise’s most important player of all time.
The Steelers were 8-1 without him.
Not Polamalu.
The Steelers were 20-14 without him.
Not Rod Woodson, one of the greatest cornerbacks of all time. After Woodson suffered a knee injury in the 1995 season opener, the Steelers won 12 of their next 17 games to reach Super Bowl XXX.
Not even Terry Bradshaw and Ben Roethlisberger meant as much to the fortunes of the Steelers
They were 21-11-1 without Terry Bradshaw. They were 22-17-1 without Ben Roethlisberger.
Interestingly, the Steelers haven’t done well when their Hall of Fame centers missed time with injuries. Mike Webster only missed four games during his 15 seasons with the Steelers, but the Steelers lost three of those games. Dermontti Dawson missed 24 games during his 13 seasons, and the Steelers were 8-16 in those games.
Dawson tore his MCL as a rookie, and the Steelers were 1-7 when he was out. Dawson then played 170 consecutive games before he tore his hamstring in 1999 and missed the final nine games of the season. The Steelers were 3-6 without him and finished 6-10. He tore the same hamstring again in 2000 and decided to retire after the Steelers finished out of the playoffs for a third consecutive season.
“I never put two and two together,” Dawson said of how his absences affected the team. “But it is very interesting.”
Among non-Steelers in the Hall of Fame, Lawrence Taylor was hard to replace. Not even Bill Belichick could scheme things up to make up for the loss of Taylor, who like Watt was a pass-rushing outside linebacker. The Giants were 4-12 in games Taylor did not play.
Belichick, who was the defensive coordinator for the Giants before becoming a head coach, considers Taylor the greatest player he has ever coached.
“He’s heads and shoulders above whoever the next player would be,” Belichick said last year. “And I’ve been fortunate enough to coach a lot of great defensive players.”
Dawson played against Taylor only once, but it was memorable for Dawson.
“We played them on a Monday night at Three Rivers Stadium,” Dawson recalled. “L.T. ran around our tackle and then ran all the way back up the field to tackle the running back. I couldn’t believe it.
“L.T. was special. T.J. is the same way. You have to double-team him or run away from him.”
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.