Welcome to Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds.
_____________
Tom M: At least it wasn’t a punter, but what’s the point in taking the QB in the 7th round who is likely practice squad at best? Why not take someone who can contribute on special teams and maybe be a contributor like Norwood did last year?
Brian: It’s certainly an odd thing, and beyond people asking me what I thought of the Kenny Pickett pick, that’s probably the question I’ve gotten most often from casual fans: Why did they draft another quarterback?
Based on some quick research, this is only the third time in the past 20 years that a team has drafted a quarterback in the first round, then another one later. Oddly enough, both of those were in 2012. The Colts took Andrew Luck first overall, then Chandler Harnish in the seventh round. The Commanders took Robert Griffin III second overall, then Kirk Cousins in the fourth.
At the time, the Commanders explained their double-down as adding a talented backup for Griffin. “You’re one or two plays away from being the starter ... and if I see that value out there on the third day of the draft, I’m going to take that,” coach Mike Shanahan said.
Read More
If you know anything about how everything played out in Washington, that move ended up looking pretty good, and Cousins even supplanted Griffin as the starter.
But the Colts’ situation was much more similar to the Steelers. Not only was Harnish a seventh-rounder, he was the very last pick of the draft.
“This person we took had tremendous success in the Mid-American Conference,” Colts general manager Ryan Grigson said then. “He’s got ability, and he was higher on our board than where we took him.”
And, like the 2022 Steelers, the Colts went into that draft with only two quarterbacks on the roster: Drew Stanton and the legendary Trevor Vittatoe. So, they took their franchise guy with their first pick, then filled out the depth chart with their last pick. I found an old Colts blog from that year in which the writer questioned the Harnish selection, writing, “Quality offensive-line prospects Mike Brewster, Matt Reynolds, James Brown and Ronald Leary all went undrafted and could’ve been taken at No. 253.”
To that author’s credit, Leary ended up starting 76 of 77 games over a seven-year career with the Broncos and Cowboys. So, yes, you’re inherently doing some nit-picking when you pan a seventh-round decision, but the goal is still to acquire the best player you can with any given resource.
Taking Chris Oladokun is not an indictment of Pickett or even Mitch Trubisky. It’s a guy the Steelers likely believe can be a good fit in their offense if they ever need to break that glass in case of emergency — or, if not, give them a developmental quarterback to stash on the practice squad if he doesn’t make the 53-man roster. If you’re curious about Harnish, he did not become the long-term backup to Luck. He spent most of his four-year career on practice squads and never appeared in a game.
_____________
Dev from NJ: Hi Brian - Hoping that Pickett turns out to be a great selection when this draft is assessed in a few years. I’m probably like (most?) Steeler fans who wished they went in a different direction. Two questions: 1. Which player would you have picked instead? And 2. Were there a lot of other teams that held Pickett in such high regard like Steelers and compared to the other QBs drafted in 3rd round? Thanks!
Brian: Looking at the board and who was available at the time, there’s not a prospect I was really high on. Jordan Davis all along was one of my favorite fits for the Steelers, and even six wide receivers were gone before No. 20. Short of trading down — which is always a risky proposition — provided his background was clean enough, Georgia defensive tackle Devonte Wyatt would’ve been the pick for me (he ended up going 28th to Green Bay). He’s more than two years older than DeMarvin Leal, but just a couple months older than Kenny Pickett.
Wyatt is probably a starter from Day 1 if Stephon Tuitt doesn’t return and the first backup in the rotation if he does. But he had at least one character concern, whereas Pickett has none, and it feels as if the Steelers are betting on his mentality, work ethic and intangibles just as much as what they’ve seen from him on the field. You can spin that as a positive or a negative, depending on your opinion.
To your second question, we’ll never know, but here’s what I can tell you. On a final pre-draft conference call with NFL Network’s Daniel Jeremiah, a former scout with plenty of contacts around the league, he said Pickett was his No. 1 quarterback and the one he thought was the best fit with the Steelers. Todd McShay of ESPN, another quarterback-centric analyst, said most NFL people he talked to had Pickett graded higher than Malik Willis, and that Pickett was “usually 1 or 2” a given team’s draft board.
Now, you can make a reasonable inference that just about everyone in the media who tries to forecast this stuff got it wrong. McShay thought each of the top five quarterbacks would go in the first two rounds. We know that didn’t happen. But you can’t assume that every other team liked Pickett that much less than the Steelers. All we can say for sure is that the 14 teams that picked before them prioritized other needs and players over Pickett, and none of the other 17 teams wanted him enough to trade up for him.
_____________
Ed in Carrick: What do you think the Steelers can get for a trade of Rudolph?
Brian: Right now? Not much. Later in the offseason or even during training camp when teams might be dealing with injuries? Maybe a little.
That’s how they managed to get a fifth-rounder for Josh Dobbs in 2019, when the Jaguars lost starter Nick Foles to a broken clavicle in Week 1. But more recently, Buffalo just sent a 2022 seventh-rounder to Cleveland for Case Keenum in March. Gardner Minshew was worth a conditional sixth-round pick to the Eagles last preseason as Jalen Hurts insurance. Last April, Teddy Bridgewater fetched a sixth-round pick around draft time.
So, that’s pretty much what you’re looking at for compensation for Rudolph, a pick in the last couple rounds, and that’s only if he’s valued in the Keenum/Minshew/Bridgewater territory. For all we know, NFL teams might not view him that highly, especially now that the Steelers have buried him on their own depth chart (though they will continue to say nice things about him, of course).
I don’t get the sense that Rudolph will cause a distraction or anything like that, but it’s hard to imagine him being content to backslide into a No. 3 role in his fifth season. No one could blame him if he quietly asked for a trade, at which point it would be up to the Steelers to find a partner in a world in which Baker Mayfield, Jimmy Garoppolo and Nick Foles all are available in some form or fashion.
Think you have better questions than these? Email bbatko@post-gazette.com or write him on Twitter @BrianBatko.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.