It’s no secret that the Steelers are seriously considering the selection of an NFL draft quarterback to help replace the retired Ben Roethlisberger. Here’s a look at how the top prospects stack up analytically, with an assist from Pro Football Focus’s grading system, which rates players based on how they perform on every snap of every game using a 0-100 scale. You can read more about the methodology here.

Kenny Pickett (92.2) — Only Ohio State’s C.J. Stroud had a higher overall grade than the Pitt signal caller in the college ranks last season, and only Coastal Carolina’s Grayson McCall had a higher passing grade. In fact, on the passing grade side, no one else under serious first-round consideration is really even close to Pickett. Cincinnati’s Desmond Ridder is closest at No. 22 in the rankings with a passing grade of 87.1. And so there’s a strong case to be made that Pickett is the best pure passer in this draft analytically, reinforced by some other strong underlying numbers. He ranked 13th among FBS QBs in big-time throws, graded as the best throws in a given week, with 27. His turnover-worthy throw percentage of 2.8 is low. Roethlisberger’s was 4.6 by comparison. And his NFL equivalent passer rating of 116.0 ranked eighth among QBs with at least 200 drop-backs and trailed none of his peers atop draft boards. So much for hand size, right?

Malik Willis (91.6) — The Liberty product has an erratic profile that reflects his reputation as the top QB most in need of some development. There is a lot of good here. His overall grade ranked sixth nationally last season, and his rush grade was No. 1 at 94.5. PFF also loved his arm when he was on, awarding him 40 big-time throws, a number that ranked second only to Western Kentucky’s Bailey Zappe. The bad news? He also ranked 11th nationally in turnover-worth throws with 18, which drove his passing grade down to 77.4. That ranked 70th nationally. And he was sacked 51 times. So while there’s no real question that he can make all of the throws, it’s also clear that he needs to learn to make some better decisions to thrive at the next level.

Sam Howell (91.1) — It’s a similar story for the North Carolina veteran. High overall score, boosted by a run score of 91.0. But his passing numbers leave something to be desired compared to his peers. His pass grade of 81.1 ranks 49th. And unlike Willis, he doesn’t have the benefit of a ton of big-time throws. His total of 23 is barely more than half that of Willis. He also took a ton of sacks with 49 — only Willis had more. The best you can say is that his turnover-worthy throw percentage was significantly lower at 2.2. Still, in almost every respect, he looks like a lesser version of Willis analytically.

Advertise with us

Desmond Ridder (90.7) — The big winner at Cincinnati profiles similarly to Pickett, just slightly less spectacular across the board. His overall grade ranks 16th. His passing grade of 87.1 ranks 22nd. And his run grade of 76.8 is good, but not great compared to Howell and Willis. Statistically, the big-time throws are right there — 26 compared to Pickett’s 27. And just 2.2% of his throws were rated turnover-worthy. About the only concern is an elevated sack percentage against pressure of 26.7, which when combined with his rush grade paints a less mobile picture than some of his pre-draft hype would suggest. He’s relying more on his impressive pre-draft workouts to vault his standing above others.

Carson Strong (89.1) — The former leader of Nevada is seen as a poor fit with the Steelers’ goal to add mobility to their QB room, and for good reason. His rush grade was 46.1 after posting an almost unbelievable minus-208 yards on the ground. So, yeah, pretty statuesque. But his passing numbers are probably better than you might think. Only Pickett had a better pass grade among top QBs in this draft. His 31 big-time throws rank second only to Willis within that cohort. And he was smart with the football, with a TWP percentage of 2.0. Bottom line, someone is going to add him as a fairly polished passer on Day 2 or Day 3. It just probably won’t be the Steelers.

Matt Corral (86.1) – Pitt fans well know that his counting numbers trailed Pickett’s significantly despite the SEC hype that propped up his Heisman candidacy until the final weeks of the college season. And the same is true of the Mississippi product’s underlying analytics here as we look forward to the draft. His overall grade ranked 29th in the nation. His passing grade of 82.1 ranked 41st. And his rush grade was a good-not-great 72.4. He had just 18 big-time throws, a number that ranked 50th. And his BTT percentage wasn’t great either at 4.3 compared to 11.0 for Willis, 6.5 for Ridder, 6.1 for Howell, 5.6 for Strong and 5.2 for Pickett. Simply put, there’s not really a place in his statistical profile where he’s particularly competitive with those guys and — analytically speaking — should probably be the last of these guys off the board.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.