Tony Villiotti’s obsession with the NFL draft began in 1969 when the Steelers selected “Mean” Joe Greene with the No. 4 overall pick. His interest turned into a hobby and eventually a side hustle when he began to research the draft and publish and sell the data he collected.
His first paper “The NFL Draft: A Historical Perspective” was published in 1987. A dozen NFL teams purchased his research. It was never lucrative enough for Villiotti to quit his day job as a chief financial officer at a subsidiary of Duquesne Light, but he made enough money from his first project that it paid for a trip for his family to go to Disney World.
Upon retirement, Villiotti, 75, has continued to quench his thirst for NFL draft knowledge with two more published works. His second study titled “Draftmetrics: A Study of the NFL Draft from 1990-2009” was published in 2010. His latest, “Draftmetrics 2022: A study of the NFL draft from 2012-2019,” is available now.
“It’s a fascination of mine.” said Villiotti, a resident of Scott and a longtime Steelers season ticket holder. (The Steelers have never purchased his works.)
Villiotti’s latest draft installment comes four years after undergoing a liver transplant, as he had NASH disease (non-alcoholic Steato-Hepatitis). He’s in good health now and raises awareness for the disease through a nonprofit he founded.
When he’s not working part-time at his nonprofit. he’s thinking about ways to break down the draft by the numbers.
Read More
“My wife thinks I’m nuts,” Villiotti said with a laugh. “It’s just one of those things where I’m semi-retired and I enjoy doing it. I’m interested in the results myself, so I’d do it even if I didn’t make any money off it.”
There are some interesting differences with Villiotti’s research since his last study, including some notable findings with the Steelers.
From 1990-2009, the Steelers received the highest grade for drafting, according to Villiotti’s algorithm. During the 20-year stretch of his research, Tom Donahoe ran the Steelers’ drafts from 1990-99 and Kevin Colbert from 2000-09.
The Steelers won two Super Bowls and played in seven AFC championship games in that 20-year span.
For his latest study, Villiotti assigned each of the 32 teams a letter grade for their draft performance from 2012-19 using a similar algorithm. The one major difference this time was his usage of snap counts as his metric of choice when evaluating a player, rather than games started. (The NFL first started making snap counts available in 2012.)
The Steelers took a big step back. They received a “C” and were squarely in the middle of the NFL pack during the second half of Colbert’s tenure as GM.
“Draft performance mirrored on-field performance — consistent but not spectacular,” Villiotti said.
During that eight-year span, the Steelers played in one AFC title game (2016) and did not make it to a Super Bowl. Villiotti notes the Steelers were most successful in the first and second rounds of the draft and not as successful in the middle and later rounds in his latest analysis.
The highest status a player can achieve is “major contributor”, which is any player who plays at least three NFL seasons and 60% or more of the snaps. A “significant contributor” is anyone who plays three or more seasons and between 40-59% of the snaps.
Using the snap-count metric, Villiotti graded Colbert’s 2014 and 2017 drafts as his best in that eight-year period, with two significant and two major contributors. The 2012 and 2019 drafts were their two worst using the same metric.
For his research, Villiotti breaks down the draft by round segments rather than by round. For instance, he divides the first round into four segments (1-5, 6-10, 11-20 and 21-32). The Steelers pick at No. 20 this year.
Seventy-five percent of the players drafted between 11 and 20 became major contributors. For draft slots 21-32, the percentage drops all the way to 49%.
The Steelers rarely trade down, but if Colbert or any other general manager wanted to trade back, he should be cognizant of the drop in success rate. Interestingly, picks in the first half of the second round (52%) outperformed the players who were selected between 21 and 32 (49%).
The Steelers have traded away a number of draft picks in recent years to acquire players, moves that are applauded by Villiotti. Colbert traded away a fifth-round pick for Ahkello Witherspoon and a sixth-round pick to acquire Joe Schobert last summer.
Villiotti said any time a general manager can acquire a veteran who will start or make significant contributions, it’s smart to trade away later-round picks. Schobert played 921 snaps and Witherspoon 368 snaps, giving the Steelers two starting-caliber players in exchange for future assets that don’t have a high probability of equaling that type of success.
Players in the first half of the fifth round, for example, have a 19% chance of becoming a major contributor while a player in the second half of the fifth round has just an 11% chance of becoming a major contributor. The percentages drop even more for sixth-round picks with only 6% becoming major contributors.
Of course, in turn, it didn’t make a lot of sense to let Melvin Ingram go for a sixth-round choice.
When it comes to quarterbacks, Villiotti said the importance of the position leads to the best prospects being selected earlier than where they might be evaluated, which lends more credence to the likelihood the Steelers will have to move up in the draft to get one of the top quarterbacks in this draft.
And forget about taking a flyer on a late-round quarterback. No quarterbacks selected after the fourth round became major contributors between 2012 and 2019. And yes, Villiotti knows all about Tom Brady. He’s merely pointing out Brady was the exception many years ago rather than the rule.
“If you need a quarterback, go get him in the first round,” Villiotti said.
Some other notable takeaways from Draftmetric 2022:
- Former Steelers cornerback Senquez Golson, at No. 56 overall in the 2015 draft, is the highest-drafted player during the 2012-19 span to have never played in a game. Golson landed on injured reserve in his only two years in the NFL and was cut before the 2017 season.
- Quarterbacks and running backs are the riskiest picks, while offensive linemen and defensive backs are the safest picks. Villiotti goes as far as to say draft only offensive linemen and defensive backs in the sixth and seventh round.
- Forty of the 46 offensive linemen drafted in the first round from 2012-19 became major contributors. The hit rate on offensive linemen in the later rounds is higher than any other position, too.
- Don’t expect to get quality defensive linemen later in the draft.
- Alabama had 70 players drafted during the eight-year period, 17 more than the next-closest school. Ohio State had 53.
Villiotti said it took him roughly 200 hours to research his latest project. One NFL team has already purchased it, but anyone looking for some NFL draft knowledge in advance can purchase a copy for $35 at draftmetrics@gmail.com.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.