When the Steelers started the 2019 season with three consecutive losses and faced the reality of playing without Ben Roethlisberger after he had season-ending elbow surgery, many among the team’s fan base didn’t want the losing to stop. They wanted the Steelers to tank to get the No. 1 pick in the draft so they could find the next great franchise quarterback.

The Steelers did the opposite. They traded their first-round pick the same week they lost Roethlisberger in exchange for Minkah Fitzpatrick in an attempt to remain competitive. They ripped off eight victories in a 10-game span with Mason Rudolph and Devlin Hodges at quarterback and were not eliminated from playoff contention until the final week of the season.

Every fan base wants a No. 1 overall pick, but there are no guarantees that player will lead their team to glory. The team that’s visiting Heinz Field on Sunday afternoon knows this all too well.

The Detroit Lions have had a No. 1 overall pick playing quarterback for them since 2009 and have nothing to show for it — not one playoff win in that span, only three playoff appearances and eight losing seasons.

Advertise with us

Matthew Stafford was the “can’t-miss” quarterback prospect of the 2009 draft class. He was No. 1 overall pick of the Lions after they went winless in 2008. But in 12 years with the Lions, Stafford was 74-90-1 as a starter. In his final three seasons in Detroit, he had a losing season before the Lions decided to trade him to the Los Angeles Rams in January.

In return for Stafford, the Lions received two first-round picks, a third-round pick and quarterback Jared Goff, who, like Stafford, was a No. 1 overall pick.

Unlike Stafford, Goff only lasted five seasons with the Rams. He was the top pick of the 2016 draft, but fell out of favor with Rams coach Sean McVay, who decided Goff wasn’t the answer at quarterback despite leading the team to four consecutive winning seasons, including an appearance in Super Bowl LIII.

In his new home, Goff is winless in eight starts and already has been publicly criticized by rookie head coach Dan Campbell following a loss to the Bengals last month.

“When you draft at the top, you’re drafting there for a reason,” said former Steelers and Lions quarterback Charlie Batch. “Owners have to be patient. A lot of times these owners are giving a coach two years to turn things around. Then they fire a guy and the quarterback is starting over with a new head coach and a new coordinator. They don’t have patience. Quarterbacks that have success have the same coordinator for three or four years at least.

Advertise with us

“It starts with stability. You want your quarterback to grow with your coach and your offensive coordinator. If you look at Russell Wilson, he’s had Pete Carroll for his entire career. Look at Aaron Rodgers. He had Mike McCarthy for the longest time. It was the same way with Ben. Even though there was a head coaching change, the terminology didn’t change when Bruce Arians became his offensive coordinator.”

Stafford had three head coaches — Jim Schwartz for five years, Jim Caldwell for four and Matt Patricia for three. Caldwell made the playoffs twice and was fired after leading the Lions to a 9-7 record in his final season in 2017.

The Lions are the only winless team in the NFL at the midway point of the season and have the inside track on landing the No. 1 overall pick again. But it’s not just the Lions who have taken big swings and misses on quarterbacks with the first pick in the draft.

Since 2000, 16 teams have selected quarterbacks with the No. 1 overall pick. None of them won a Super Bowl. Only one No. 1 overall pick, Eli Manning, delivered a Lombardi Trophy. He did it twice — in 2007 and 2011 — after being acquired by the Giants in a draft-day trade in 2004 with the Chargers, the team that made him the top pick in the draft.

The only other No. 1 overall pick this century that made a Super Bowl in addition to Goff was Cam Newton, who led the Panthers to Super Bowl 50 and lost to a Peyton Manning-led Broncos team.

Advertise with us

Andrew Luck, Alex Smith, Michael Vick and Carson Palmer were above-average starters and each made multiple Pro Bowls, but none of them made it past a conference championship game. Like Stafford, Palmer never won a playoff game with the team that drafted him.

And there have been some outright busts in the past 20 years, too. David Carr, Jamarcus Russell and Sam Bradford definitely qualify for that designation, while the jury remains out on Jameis Winston, Baker Mayfield, Kyler Murray, Joe Burrow and Trevor Lawrence.

Winston, the top pick in the 2015 draft, did not sign a second contract with the Buccaneers and now plays for the New Orleans Saints.

“The vast majority of the time, these kids are talented,” said Daniel Jeremiah, a former NFL scout with the Ravens, Eagles and Browns who now works as a draft analyst for NFL Network. “Who’s to blame? I think most of the time it’s the situation, not the player.”

Jeremiah said young quarterbacks drafted into the NFL need the three Ps to be successful — the right play-caller, pass protection and playmakers.

Advertise with us

“And when you’re picking at the top of the draft, you’re lucky to have one of those three and it’s sometimes none of those three,” Jeremiah said.

It’s not just No. 1 overall picks that fail to deliver. The bust rate on quarterbacks selected in the first round is higher than any other position in recent years. Remember the “Tank for Tua” slogan two years ago around this time? Well, Burrow ended up going No. 1 overall in 2020, but Tua Tagovailoa was the fifth pick, and the Dolphins already appear to be ready to move on from him.

Speaking of first-round whiffs, how about the Arizona Cardinals moving on from Josh Rosen after one year? Or Washington moving on from Dwayne Haskins after only two seasons? Or the Jets moving on from Sam Darnold after three years?

For Jeremiah, it’s all about where the quarterback lands in the draft.

“The example I’m using now is Tua and Mac Jones,” Jeremiah said. “If they switched spots I think the opposite would be happening with those players. I think Tua would be having success in New England and Mac would be struggling in Miami.”

Advertise with us

The list of quarterbacks busting is a long one and should serve as a cautionary tale for the Steelers, who face the daunting task of replacing Ben Roethlisberger in the coming years.

Mason Rudolph appears to be in line to get first crack as Roethlisberger’s successor, but he’s under contract only until the end of the 2022 season. The Steelers took on Haskins as a reclamation project, and he’s currently the No. 3 quarterback.

Evaluating quarterbacks is the most important job a general manager and head coach have. Drafting the wrong one in the first round can set the franchise back for years. Drafting the right one can lead to Lombardi trophies.

And it’s especially important now with the way the NFL salary structure is devised. Drafting a quarterback in the first round once meant paying him a high salary right away, but those days are gone. The rookie wage scale was introduced in 2011 as part of the collective bargaining agreement, giving owners the ability to evaluate quarterbacks before deciding whether they were going to dole out big money to them in second contracts.

That was a financial win for owners, but the byproduct has been playing quarterbacks early, sometimes before they are ready.

Advertise with us

“The model now is drafting the quarterback in the first round, play them early and try to compete for Super Bowls when he’s on his rookie contract,” said Batch, who serves an analyst for Steelers pregame on KDKA-TV. “Because you’re not going to win when the big money kicks in on those second contracts when those guys are making $30, $35, $40 million a year.

“Seattle won a Super Bowl and went to another when Wilson was on his rookie contract. They haven’t been back since. The Packers haven’t been back since Rodgers has been making big money.”

The Steelers made it to Super Bowl XLV when Roethlisberger was playing on his first big-money contract, but they haven’t been back in the past decade.

Batch, who was an executive member of the NFLPA during his playing career, said owners had a chance during the most recent collective bargaining negotiations to change the landscape. There was some talk of separate salary caps — one for the quarterbacks and the other for the remaining 50 or 51 players on the 53-man roster.

The NFLPA, Batch said, would have been in favor of it because it would have meant bigger salaries for their membership, but not enough owners were on board for the idea to gain any traction. The soonest that can be revisited is eight years because the deal that was ratified by the NFL and NFLPA last year was a 10-year deal.

Advertise with us

Which means the Steelers will be working under the same landscape as they continue their search for Roethlisberger’s successor.

The quarterback class for the 2022 draft is considered one of the weakest in years. Jeremiah said he has more evaluating to do on the prospects, but “there are a couple of interesting players.” He said he hasn’t fallen in love with any of the draft-eligible quarterbacks yet, but he does expect a couple to be selected in the first round.

What should the Steelers do?

“Take one early, in the first round,” Jeremiah said. “A guy with a chance to be the long-term guy. I don’t know if their quarterback of the future is on their roster now. I do think that would be a really good situation for a young quarterback. You have a young offensive line that is getting better. You have the running back and the tight end. There are pieces there that will make a very quarterback-friendly situation. I would think they are scouting the heck out of the quarterbacks that are coming out.”

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.