The Steelers have nine wins in their first nine games, and if you had that written down in pen before the season, we’re going to need to see some evidence of that.

Certainly, none of us on the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette sports staff saw this coming. As usual, we published our predictions for the 2020 NFL season in early September, and now that the Steelers are more than halfway done — and could have a deep playoff run too — why don’t we take a look back at what we got right, what we got wrong and what’s still in play.

Steelers record

• Joe Starkey: 12-4

Advertise with us

• Gerry Dulac, Ryan Winn: 11-5

• Ray Fittipaldo, Ron Cook, Mackenzie Rodrigues: 10-6

• Brian Batko, Gene Collier, Adam Bittner: 9-7

• Paul Zeise: 8-8

Dr. Starkey, come on down! Joe stands alone as the one man who was highest on the Steelers coming into the season, and he’s also the only one who picked them as the AFC North champion. The other nine of us? We all went with the Baltimore Ravens, the same ones who are three games behind the Steelers. Zeise’s win total already has been surpassed, but the rest of us technically aren’t wrong yet.

Advertise with us

NFL MVP

• Dulac, Fittipaldo, Cook, Zeise, Winn, Bittner, Rodrigues: Patrick Mahomes

• Starkey: Kyler Murray

• Batko: Lamar Jackson

No sign of Ben Roethlisberger here, as the vast majority projected the reigning Super Bowl MVP to double (triple?) down. That’s not a bad pick at all given that Mahomes has the third-most touchdowns, second-highest quarterback rating and fifth-most passing yards for the only team that might be favored against the Steelers on a neutral field right now, the 8-1 Chiefs.

Advertise with us

But Starkey deserves a lot of credit once again for choosing Murray, every bit as likely to take home the hardware as Mahomes given his rushing and passing prowess for the Cardinals. It’s just a shame that Murray’s MVP moment last week — the “Hail Murray” touchdown pass to DeAndre Hopkins — came against Joe’s beloved Buffalo Bills.

As for the dope who picked Lamar Jackson to repeat … it wasn’t even his worst call. Stay tuned.

Defensive Player of the Year

• Dulac, Fittipaldo, Cook, Collier, Zeise, Rodrigues: T.J. Watt

• Batko, Starkey, Bittner: Aaron Donald

Advertise with us

• Winn: Nick Bosa

Watt seemed poised to break through this year, and given his ranking at or near the top of just about every pass-rushing category, he might make a bunch of us look wise for the hometown vote. Donald has just as many sacks, though, with nine (0.5 behind Myles Garrett for the league lead). Bosa’s season ended with a torn ACL in Week 2.

Coach of the Year

• Fittipaldo, Collier: Mike McCarthy

• Bittner, Rodrigues: Kliff Kingsbury

Advertise with us

• Dulac: Sean McDermott

• Batko: Mike Vrabel

• Starkey: Bruce Arians

• Cook: Andy Reid

• Zeise: Brian Flores

Advertise with us

• Winn: Bill Belichick

By far the category with the most variance, which is fun, but majority does not rule when you look at the job McCarthy is doing in Dallas. Kingsbury could still be in the running, but he’s far from a favorite.

It’s Zeise who might have the best odds of being on the money with this one given Miami’s turnaround, but wow, none of us backed the clear front-runner for this year’s award, a guy who would be a first-time winner: Mike Tomlin. Would’ve been a strong choice. Obviously.

First coach fired

• Dulac, Fittipaldo, Batko, Starkey: Doug Marrone

Advertise with us

• Cook, Winn, Bittner, Rodrigues: Adam Gase

• Zeise: Matt Patricia

• Collier: Bruce Arians

Much to our collective surprise, Marrone and Gase are still around! No one had the actual first coach fired, Bill O’Brien, or even the second coach fired, Dan Quinn in Atlanta. It’s entirely possible that Marrone could be done in by the Steelers this weekend, and one would think Gase and Patricia also could go at any time. Gene went with a bold call on Arians, who’s much more likely to win coach of the year than get the ax.

Super Bowl

Advertise with us

• Cook, Bittner: Chiefs over Saints

• Winn: Chiefs over Vikings

• Zeise: Chiefs over 49ers

• Fittipaldo: Saints over Chiefs

• Starkey: Buccaneers over Chiefs

Advertise with us

• Dulac: Ravens over Seahawks

• Collier: Seahawks over Ravens

• Rodrigues: Cowboys over Chiefs

• Batko: Cowboys over Ravens

Credit to us for independent thought, as we managed to get 10 journalists to give nine different answers on our Super Bowl picks. And once again, no fearless prediction for the Steelers to win No. 7. Four picked the Chiefs to go back-to-back, with Ron and Adam looking like they might have the best chance of being right on that one. Vikings and 49ers? Probably safe to say they won’t be there.

Advertise with us

Ray and Joe at least have the Chiefs getting to Tampa, and New Orleans or Tampa Bay could certainly hoist the Lombardi Trophy. Gerry and Gene were in the same church, different pew with a Russell Wilson-Lamar Jackson showdown, which is still on the table despite the Ravens looking less dangerous by the week.

And what is this? Do my eyes deceive me? An NFL beat writer actually picked the Dallas Cowboys the 2-7 Cowboys, last-in-the-NFC Least Cowboys to not just play in the big game but win it? That’s a tough one to live down. We didn’t know in early September that Dak Prescott would go down with a season-ending injury, but they were a mere 1-3 to that point anyway. But hey, it was my idea to open this time capsule and be fitted for the dunce cap. At least Mackenzie has to share in this embarrassment.

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.