STEELERS WEEK 5 REPORT CARD

Quarterback: Ben Roethlisberger only threw for 239 yards, but he masterfully directed the Steelers offense in another victory. He threw three touchdowns and did not throw an interception, bringing his touchdown-to-interception ratio to an impressive 10:1 for the season. That might be the most important statistic of the season for the Steelers offense. It’s not prolific, but Roethlisberger is making a lot of correct decisions, getting his team into the right play and then executing. The final touchdown of the game, a 35-yard pass to Claypool, is a perfect illustration of that. Roethlisberger called for a short passing play in the huddle, but when he saw the Eagles sitting back in Cover 2, he made an audible at the line of scrimmage. The result was an easy touchdown that put the game away.

Grade: A+

Running backs: The Steelers rushed for 136 yards, but only 69 of them came from running backs. James Conner had 15 rushes for 44 yards, but other than one 25-yard run, there wasn’t much running room for him. The same goes for Benny Snell (7 for 19) and Anthony McFarland (3 for 6). Conner did add three catches for 19 yards in the passing game, but if the Steelers are going to be serious contenders in the AFC, they’re going to need more consistent performances in the running game. Right now, it’s too hit and miss.

Advertise with us

Grade: B-

Receivers: Claypool is emerging as an offensive rookie of the year candidate. The second-round pick out of Notre Dame had his coming out party Sunday, scoring four touchdowns, including a 35-yard catch and run with 2:59 to play that put the game out of reach. He also scored on passes of 32 and 5 yards and on a 2-yard end around, becoming the first rookie in club history to score four times. Claypool’s emergence was important because Diontae Johnson left the game in the first quarter with a back injury, forcing Claypool into a more prominent role for the second game in a row due to a Johnson injury. Ray-Ray McCloud also stepped up and produced some big plays. He took a reverse 58 yards to set up the Steelers’ third touchdown. He also drew a pass interference penalty. On a day when Johnson, JuJu Smith-Schuster and James Washington combined for eight catches for 52 yards, it speaks volumes to the depth of this receiving corps and the confidence Roethlisberger has in Claypool and McCloud.

Grade: A+

Offensive line: Give Kevin Dotson credit for being ready to play after David DeCastro exited the game in the first quarter with an abdominal injury. The offensive line kept Roethlisberger clean for most of the game, allowing just one sack on a day he attempted 34 passes. The Eagles are a stout group up front, but the offensive line has to improve their run blocking. Other than a couple of big running plays, including McCloud’s 58-yard reverse, the running game was poor for much of the game.

Grade: B

Advertise with us

Defensive line: The Steelers have yet to allow a 100-yard rusher this season, which is quite the accomplishment given the way Sunday started. Eagles running back Miles Sanders raced 74 yards for a touchdown in the first quarter. But other than that, the Steelers limited the Eagles to 18 yards on their other 15 carries. Credit the defensive line for not allowing Sanders to become a presence in the game after his early touchdown. Stephon Tuitt recorded 1 ½ sacks and Cam Heyward also had a sack, giving the Steelers a strong push in the middle.

Grade: A-

Linebackers: Many predicted Bud Dupree and T.J. Watt would have big games against a depleted Eagles offensive line, but they were quiet for long stretches of the game. Dupree was matched up against Jordan Mailata, a converted rugby player making just his second NFL start. Dupree had a sack late in the game, but he missed one on a third down in the second quarter, which helped the Eagles extend a drive and score a touchdown a few plays later. Watt recorded a sack in the first quarter, but he didn’t do much the rest of the game. Rookie Alex Highsmith saw some playing time in the fourth quarter with Watt, who is dealing with a knee injury, watching from the sidelines. It was a quiet game for the inside linebackers, too. Devin Bush and Vince Williams each had just one solo tackle apiece. But at least they did a good job against Eagles tight end Zach Ertz.

Grade: B-

Secondary: Steven Nelson had two interceptions, including a timely one early in the third quarter that led to the Steelers getting some much-needed separation on the scoreboard, but this was not a good day overall for the defensive backs. The Eagles came into the game with the NFL’s 27th-ranked passing offense, but Carson Wentz threw for 258 yards and two touchdowns. What made it disheartening for the Steelers is Wentz had success without his top two receivers. The Steelers allowed someone named Travis Fulgham to catch 10 passes for 152 yards and a touchdown. Fulgham, a sixth-round pick of the Lions in 2019, entered the game with two career catches. But it wasn’t just bad coverage for the Steelers. Slot corner Mike Hilton, the Steelers’ leading and surest tackler, missed Sanders in the hole on his 74-yard run.

Advertise with us

Grade: C

Special teams: Kicker Chris Boswell remained perfect on field goal attempts this season, booting a 41-yarder late in the second quarter to give the Steelers a halftime lead. The kickoff coverage was good, too, as the Eagles averaged just 16 yards per return. Coach Mike Tomlin was critical of his punting game on Tuesday, but Dustin Colquitt was solid on his two punts, including one when he pinned the Eagles inside their 20-yard line. The Steelers didn’t get much out of Johnson or McCloud in the return game, but that’s about the only criticism for the special teams.

Grade: B

Coaching: The coaches have to discover some answers to fix their ailing pass defense, especially on third downs. The Eagles converted 10 of their 14 third-down attempts. That’s far too many for a defense that many consider to be among the NFL’s elite. They simply can’t continue to allow so many big plays. Many of the Eagles’ conversions were on third-and-long. Conversely, let’s give some credit to the offensive staff for their game plan. The Steelers converted 11 of their 15 third downs and took advantage of some mismatches in the Eagles injury-ravaged secondary, most notably Claypool having his way with pretty much whoever tried to guard him. Tomlin admitted it wasn’t a perfect performance, but it’s the Steelers’ first 4-0 start since 1979. The coaches are getting the team in position to win games, and the players are coming through.

Grade: B

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.