How does a 10-year playoff streak sound? Much better than missing out on the postseason four times in eight years, that’s for sure.

If the new collective bargaining agreement is agreed upon by the NFL and the NFL Players Association, expanded playoffs with seven teams per conference will be a big part of the new deal.

If the new format had been in place in recent years, the Steelers would have been perennial contenders instead of the perennial bridesmaid. The Steelers narrowly missed the playoffs in 2012, 2013, 2018 and 2019. They were the seventh seed on each occasion, meaning they would have qualified as the final team from the AFC in every one of those years.

Under the proposed format, the No. 7 seed would play the No. 2 seed in the first round of the playoffs, eliminating a bye week that No. 2 seeds have enjoyed since 1990. That would make the race for the No. 1 seed an exciting and important new aspect of the season.

Advertise with us

According to published reports, NFL owners and players are meeting separately Thursday and Friday, and there is hope a new collective bargaining agreement will be in place before the new league year begins March 18.

In addition to the expanded playoff format, the league is trying to get the players to agree to a 17-game schedule with a reduced preseason slate. Adding more regular-season games had been a sticking point in negotiations as recently as six months ago.

Ramon Foster, the NFLPA rep for the Steelers, told the Post-Gazette in July that players were not interested in expanding the regular season. At the time, the NFL floated the idea of an 18-game schedule. In exchange for the extra games, one of the givebacks was players only being eligible to play in 16 games. It was a chip to appease the health and safety concerns players had over playing two extra games during the regular season.

“I’m more quality over quantity at this point,” Foster said. “Once you start extending stuff, you’re going to give guys games off? You’re just going to say, ‘Hey, what are you paying for the season tickets? And your starting QB isn’t playing that game simply because he can only play 16?’ Well, in that case, keep it at 16 games. Put the best product back out there.”

It now appears the two sides are close to settling on a compromise at 17 games. As always, money will talk.

Advertise with us

Five years ago, the Post-Gazette reported adding two teams to the playoffs would generate an estimated $280 million in revenue for the league’s owners. The players will get a bigger share of the financial pie with the expanded playoffs and regular season in addition to some other concessions from owners.

The NFL is eager to reach their previously stated goal of reaching $25 billion in revenue by 2027. That’s why there is a push to get a new CBA in place in the next few weeks. If the two sides cannot come to an agreement before the new league year begins, there is a chance for a labor dispute next year when the current CBA expires.

The NFL has already lost millions by not going to an expanded playoff format earlier. The College Football Playoff beat the NFL to the punch when it agreed with ESPN in 2012 on a $5.64 billion contract to broadcast three playoff games per year through the 2025 season.

NFL commissioner Roger Goodell had wanted to spread the extra playoff games over three days by pushing one or two to Monday night, which also would have maximized revenue due to an extra prime time slot. But there are direct conflicts with the CFP championship game almost every year.

Until the CFP contract with ESPN expires, the league likely would have to play three games on Saturday and Sunday.

Advertise with us

When Steelers president Art Rooney II discussed expanded playoffs with the Post-Gazette five years ago, he was not a fan of the No. 2 seed giving up its bye, and he had some concerns over how the games would be scheduled.

“I think we’ve always said that’s something that’s worth considering,” Rooney said in March of 2015. “But the details of it ... when would the game get scheduled? Monday night is kind of one of the possibilities, which I don’t think is a great alternative. The idea is OK, it’s just that when you get down to exactly how does it work, it gets a little complicated.”

The 17-game schedule would generate a similar number for owners, as TV networks would get big ratings from late-season games with added playoff implications.

Entering the final weekend of the 2019 regular season, three teams were batting for the final spot in the AFC playoffs. The Titans beat out the Steelers and Raiders by winning their regular season finale. In the NFC, the Eagles and Cowboys remained alive for the final spot in Week 17. The Eagles made the playoffs by winning their final game.

The seventh seed in both conferences will undoubtedly add more drama in most years.

Advertise with us

Football purists aren’t thrilled with the expansion. The NFL has been careful over the years not to dilute the regular season. In 1989, only 8 of the 28 teams in the league qualified for the playoffs, or 28.5% of the league’s teams. Now, if the proposal is ratified by owners and players, it would be 44%.

There also is the question of whether expanding to 14 teams will lead to some bad first-round matchups. This past season, the Steelers, who lost their final three games and were down to their third-string quarterback, would have played Kansas City in the first round.

The Steelers only averaged 10 points per game over their final three games of the regular season. They finished 8-8 and hardly resembled a team that was worthy of the postseason, much less a team capable of competing in a game against the Chiefs, who ended up as Super Bowl champions.

But a look at the past decade in the NFL suggests the Steelers would have been an outlier. The average win total for the No. 7 seed in the AFC during the past 10 years is 8.8. On only three occasions would a team have gotten in the playoffs with eight wins — the Steelers in 2012, 2013 and 2019. Five nine-win teams would have qualified and one 10-win team (the 2015 Jets) would have qualified.

The average win total for the No. 7 seed in the NFC during the past 10 years is 9.1. Four 10-win teams would have qualified while only two .500 teams would have qualified.

Advertise with us

Interestingly, in many of those years, the No. 7 seed was far superior to the No. 4 seed, the worst division winner. In 2014, Carolina won the NFC South with a 7-8-1 record while a 10-win Eagles teams was left out. In 2010, Seattle won the NFC West with a 7-9 record while a 10-win Giants team was left out.

Carolina and Seattle both played host to and won playoff games that season due to the league rewarding division winners with home games. In the end, as long as the NFL rewards division winners with playoff berths, NFL purists will take issue with the quality of teams that qualify. The No. 7 seed in most years will have an equal or better record than the worst division winners.

The 2018 Steelers — even though they lost four of their past six games — finished 9-6-1. They beat New England, the eventual Super Bowl champions, in mid-December. One week later, they narrowly lost to New Orleans, which advanced to the NFC title game.

In many years, the No. 7 seed will be dangerous, which will in turn, will make the networks happy and the NFL fan base thrilled.

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.