Second in a 2020 offseason series breaking down the Steelers position by position:
The Steelers signed veteran offensive linemen Maurkice Pouncey and Ramon Foster to new contracts last March and kept their aging unit intact for another season. General manager Kevin Colbert’s plan might have worked better had quarterback Ben Roethlisberger not been injured in the second week of the season. Roethlisberger’s talent and experience might have covered up some of the warts that were eventually exposed during his absence.
The Steelers can’t make the same mistake twice with Roethlisberger coming off elbow surgery and set to turn 38 next month. Now more than ever, Roethlisberger needs the best protection he can get upfront. Just as important, the Steelers need to start assembling a line that can be effective with or without their franchise quarterback.
While Roethlisberger remains under contract for two more seasons, the Steelers have to develop an effective plan should he not be able to play. Their plan last season failed, and the line’s subpar performance played a role in the offense being among the worst in the NFL.
That means the Steelers have to cast sentiment aside and cut Foster, the 12-year veteran who is coming off a bad season. Foster has little mobility left in his 34-year old legs. He can no longer get to linebackers on the second level of the defense. Moreover, the Steelers can save $4 million on their salary cap by severing ties with him.
The Steelers also have to decide what they’re going to do with right tackle Matt Feiler and top interior reserve B.J. Finney. Feiler, the starter at right tackle for most of the past two seasons, is a restricted free agent. The Steelers likely will place a second-round tender on him for a little over $3 million to all but ensure his services for another season. At 27, Feiler is the youngest member of the starting five and could be a big part of the rebuild of the line. He has proven to be above average at right tackle, but he also has the versatility to move inside to guard in the event Foster is released.
Read More
Finney is an unrestricted free agent after being paid $3 million as a restricted free agent last year. The Steelers might have tipped their hand regarding Finney last spring when they elected to re-sign Foster and didn’t pursue a long-term deal with him. Then, in October, when Foster was injured, Feiler was moved inside to left guard and second-year tackle Chuks Okorafor started at right tackle. Those two moves strongly suggest the Steelers don’t view Finney as a long-term starting option. As a result, he’s likely to sign with a team this spring that will give him an opportunity to start and earn a bigger contract than he would otherwise get with the Steelers.
If Finney does leave, it would create a dilemma for the coaches. The only backup interior lineman behind Finney is J.C. Hassenauer, who spent most of last season on the practice squad. Hassenauer, who was elevated to the 53-man roster late in the season after Patrick Morris was released, has never played in an NFL game.
Other than those roster decisions, the Steelers will head into next season with Pouncey at center, David DeCastro at right guard and Alejandro Villanueva at left tackle. There is plenty of pedigree there — each has made multiple Pro Bowls in the past three years — but all three are 30 or older. The nucleus remains strong, but they must prove next season they still have it after the line as a whole failed to lift the offense on its shoulders.
More than anything, they have to help figure out what is ailing the running game.The Steelers finished 30th in the league in rushing yards per attempt. It was the second year in a row they finished near the bottom of the league’s rushing rankings. Blocking for so many different types of backs surely presented some issues for the linemen; the Steelers had five backs with 22 or more rushing attempts. Each had their own style and timing hitting the holes. It was not an easy adjustment for the linemen.
Roethlisberger’s return will help the running game, but it’s clear a strong run blocker is needed to help bolster the unit. That’s why it makes sense for Colbert to invest some draft capital in a lineman with an eye toward the future.
The pass protection also got worse in 2019. The Steelers surrendered 32 sacks, their most since giving up 33 in 2015. But much like the running game, it’s difficult to decipher how much of an effect Roethlisberger’s absence had on the rise in sacks. Mason Rudolph and Devlin Hodges were not as adept at changing protections, and the ball wasn’t coming out on time in a lot of instances. The young running backs also were responsible for some of those sacks.
How the Steelers feel about their offensive line will be revealed in the coming weeks. They can upgrade through free agency and/or the draft. It’s a good bet Colbert will use at least one draft pick on an offensive lineman. They have drafted just four offensive linemen in the past eight years and none higher than the third round.
It’s time for that to change. The Steelers need better linemen to get back to the playoffs, and they definitely need to begin the process of getting younger.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.
Steelers offensive line
• Matt Feiler
Position: right tackle
Year acquired: 2015, free agent
School: Bloomsburg
Signed through: RFA
• David DeCastro
Position: right guard
Year acquired: 2012 draft, first round
School: Stanford
Signed through: 2021
• Maurkice Pouncey
Position: center
Year acquired: 2010 draft, first round
School: Florida
Signed through: 2021
• Ramon Foster
Position: left guard
Year acquired: 2009, undrafted free agent
School: Tennessee
Signed through: 2020
• Alejandro Villanueva
Position: left tackle
Year acquired: 2014 draft, free agent
School: Army
Signed through: 2021
• B.J. Finney
Position: center/guard
Year acquired: 2015, undrafted free agent
School: Kansas State
Signed through: UFA
• J.C. Hassenauer
Position: guard/center
Year acquired: 2019, free agent
School: Alabama
Signed through: 2020
• Chukwuma Okorafor
Position: tackle
Year acquired: 2018, third round
School: Western Michigan
Signed through: 2021
• Zach Banner
Position: tackle
Year acquired: 2018, free agent
School: USC
Signed through: RFA
Top 5 offensive line prospects, according to CBSsports.com
• Jedrick Wills, Jr., 6-5, 320, Alabama
• Andrew Thomas, Jr., 6-5, 320, Georgia
• Tristan Wirfs, Jr., 6-5. 322. Iowa
• Mekhi Becton, Jr., 6-7, 369, Louisville
• Josh Jones, Sr., 6-7, 310, Houston





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.