Quarterback: For years, the Steelers had veteran backups behind Ben Roethlisberger, but in recent years they deliberately trended younger as they try to prepare for life after Roethlisberger retires. That meant going with second-year quarterback Mason Rudolph and rookie Devlin Hodges in 2019. When Roethlisberger was lost for the season in Week 2, that decision left the Steelers without a backup that had taken a snap in an NFL regular-season game. As one might expect, it did not go well. Rudolph, while going a respectable 5-3 as a starter, was benched after struggling in November, giving way to Hodges, who temporarily provided a spark until he lost his final three starts. In the end it was clear the Steelers got to eight wins not because of their quarterbacks but in spite of them. The Steelers finished 31st in the league in passing yards. Rudolph finished 29th in quarterback rating. That has led to speculation the Steelers might have to bring in a veteran during the offseason to provide some stability and a second option behind Rudolph, who already has been declared the backup by coach Mike Tomlin.

Grade: D

Running backs: The leading rusher was James Conner, whose 464 yards were the fewest for the team’s leading rusher since Don Shy ran for 341 yards in the 1967 season. It was quite the decline for Conner, who earned his first Pro Bowl nod in 2018 after compiling 1,470 scrimmage yards. Conner missed six games due to shoulder and quad injuries, which highlighted the lack of quality depth at the position. Rookie Benny Snell earned the backup job by season’s end and finished with 426 yards. With Snell’s rise up the depth chart, Jaylen Samuels’ role decreased. Samuels averaged just 2.7 yards per carry and 6.5 yards per catch, both significantly lower averages than what he posted during his rookie season. Kerrith Whyte, another rookie who was signed off the Bears practice squad late in the season, had a more prominent role in the offense than Samuels late in the season. Given Conner’s contract situation — he is entering the final year of his rookie deal — and the lack of a proven backup (or future starter) behind him, the Steelers likely will add a player to the mix this offseason through the draft.

Grade: C-

Advertise with us

Receivers: The good news is the Steelers look to have found another mid-round gem in Diontae Johnson, a third-round pick who led the Steelers in receptions (59) and receiving touchdowns (5) and was second in receiving yards (680). Johnson could be a future star. The bad news is the other receivers on the roster failed to live up to expectations. JuJu Smith-Schuster missed four games due to a knee injury and came back to play the final two games at less than 100%. Give him credit for trying to come back to help the team as it tried to make the playoffs. But even when Smith-Schuster was healthy, he didn’t produce like a No. 1 receiver. He posted one 100-yard receiving game and finished his third NFL season with just 42 catches for 552 yards. That was a huge decline in production from his 2018 season, when he had 111 catches for 1,426 yards. James Washington improved and led the team with 735 receiving yards, but his play over the final three games was disappointing. He was targeted 22 times and only had 10 catches in those games, all losses that prevented the Steelers from making the playoffs. Tight end Vance McDonald, like Smith-Schuster, saw his production steeply decline in a season the team was counting on him. In short, Steelers receivers and tight ends failed to win enough against man coverage, which they faced in abundance. Now they need new talent to compete for playing time because Ryan Switzer, Johnny Holton, Deon Cain, Amara Darboh, Nick Vannett and Zach Gentry didn’t move the meter much when they had opportunities in the passing game. The Steelers would be wise to add a receiver and tight end through the draft, not via free agency. It’s a deep draft for receivers, and the Steelers are still reeling from the Donte Moncrief signing last March and the Ladarius Green signing in 2016. Draft and develop. It’s what they do best with receivers and tight ends.

Grade: C-

Offensive line: There wasn’t a more disappointing position group on the team in 2019. Without Roethlisberger and an inexperienced group of receivers, the Steelers should have been able to lean on the line to develop a running game. But that never happened. This is an old line that was exposed last season. As a unit, they can pass protect but do little else. The Steelers were 29th in the league in rushing yards per game and 30th in yards per carry. It wasn’t all on the line. The quarterbacks, backs and receivers didn’t help matters when it came to patching together a run game, but the linemen were responsible for their fair share of the problems, too. The Steelers can get younger by releasing Ramon Foster. And they have some options due to the versatility that Matt Feiler provides. Feiler, who has made 26 starts at right tackle the past two seasons, can move inside to guard to replace Foster if Chuks Okorafor or Zach Banner is ready to assume a starting role at tackle. The Steelers got old really fast in one year. Now it’s time to get younger and reinvigorate the running game with new players and/or established ones at new positions.

Grade: F

Defensive line: This could have been a disastrous season for the defensive line when Stephon Tuitt was lost for the season in Week 6, but Cam Heyward wouldn’t let that happen. He raised his level of play and earned his second All-Pro honor with another dominant season. Heyward had nine sacks and set his career highs in tackles (83) and tied his career high in quarterback hits (22). Nose tackle Javon Hargrave also picked up his play after Tuitt’s injury. He took on more snaps at defensive end in sub-packages and registered four sacks and seven tackles for loss. He played out the final year of his contract and is set to become an unrestricted free agent in March so look for the Steelers to add a defensive lineman to the mix this offseason. If the Steelers don’t re-sign Hargrave, they’ll have to find a new starting nose tackle and preferably one that’s proficient at stopping the run. If there was one weakness on defense last season it was the inconsistencies in stopping the run, especially late in the season. A young run-stopper in the middle might be just what the doctor ordered for a defense that’s trending up.

Advertise with us

Grade: B+

Linebackers: T.J. Watt and Bud Dupree turned back the clock and brought back memories of James Harrison and LaMarr Woodley when they were at the top of their game. Watt had 14½ sacks and Dupree 11½. The 26 combined sacks represented almost half of the team’s season total (54). Dupree is set to become an unrestricted free agent in March, but Tomlin said Dupree is a “priority” this offseason. The most likely scenario is Dupree playing on the one-year franchise tag in 2020 and thus keeping the duo together for at least one more season. Rookie inside linebacker Devin Bush had high expectations as the No. 10 overall pick, and he did not disappoint. He led the team in tackles (109) and had four forced fumbles, two interceptions and a fumble recovery for a touchdown. Mark Barron was signed as a free agent last March to help in pass coverage and helped solidify some of the issues the Steelers previously had defending the middle area of the field. However, as Bush progresses as a pass defender, Barron’s role will diminish, and the Steelers have to decide if his hefty 2020 cap hit is worth it. With Watt and Bush both still on their rookie contracts, this group will be strong for years to come, but the front office would be smart to add some young depth with Barron and Vince Williams getting older.

Grade: A-

Secondary: The defensive backfield came together after general manager Kevin Colbert acquired Minkah Fitzpatrick early in the season. In 14 games with the Steelers, Fitzpatrick had five interceptions and earned All-Pro honors. But above and beyond the individual stats and accolades, he was the final piece to the puzzle that transformed the secondary to one of the best in the league. The Steelers had 20 interceptions, a marked improvement from eight in 2018. Fitzpatrick had the benefit of playing behind two really solid corners. After the Steelers signed Joe Haden to a new three-year contract in August, he rewarded the team with one of the best seasons of his distinguished career. He also had five interceptions, the most he’s had since grabbing six as a rookie with the Browns in 2010. Steven Nelson provided stability opposite Haden after being signed as a free agent. He only had one interception, but the stats don’t tell the entire story. Opposing quarterbacks shied away from Nelson as he locked down his side of the field with regularity. At strong safety, Terrell Edmunds failed to produce a turnover on one of the most opportunistic defenses in the league. That should be concerning for Colbert, who invested a first-round pick in Edmunds in 2018. He’s still young, but his third season is shaping up as an important one when it comes to his long-term future with the team.

Grade: B+

Advertise with us

Special teams: There were a few highlights. Chris Boswell returning to form certainly was one of them. Boswell, after slumping in 2018, made 29 of his 31 field-goal attempts and all 28 of his point-after attempts. And the emergence of Diontae Johnson as a punt returner was a terrific development in the second half of the season. Johnson, who had an 85-yard return for a touchdown, was named second-team All-Pro. But there were some lowlights, too. Punter Jordan Berry had a few too many of those. He was inconsistent late in the season and had two other major gaffes that cost his team — a dropped snap that led to a touchdown in Baltimore and not realizing a fake punt had been called off in Arizona. These are not miscues players with five years of NFL experience should be making. The kickoff return unit was bad, too. The Steelers averaged just 18.1 yards per return, which ranked 31st out of 32 teams. For a team with an offense that needed all the help it could get the special teams didn’t provide enough.

Grade: C

Coaching: In many ways, this was one of Mike Tomlin’s best coaching jobs. When Roethlisberger went down, the defense stepped up and carried the team during a stretch when the Steelers won seven of eight. He’s to be commended for pulling all the right strings on a unit that he largely oversees. Yes, Keith Butler still retains the title of defensive coordinator, but Tomlin has taken more ownership of the defense in recent years. As such, he deserves credit for helping build the defense into one of the league’s best. And that’s not discounting Butler’s role in the turnaround. He and the other defensive coaches did a terrific job. If we were just talking about the development of the defense, the coaches would get straight A’s. Tomlin could not fix a reeling offense. The coaches did not have a quarterback on the roster that was capable of pushing the offense forward after Roethlisberger went on IR. And the running game or lack thereof, is the single biggest reason the Steelers did not make the playoffs. With too many one-dimensional players geared toward a passing offense, the Steelers plodded along when a change in scheme or personnel, or philosophical approach might have helped. Now the coaches have to come up with answers this offseason. Roethlisberger is expected to play in 2020, but he’ll be 38 and won’t play forever. Tomlin talked about studying trends in the game at his season-ending news conference. The league began to shift back toward the run and away from the pass late in the 2018 season. Tomlin and the Steelers didn’t adjust. He can’t make the same mistake twice. The Steelers can’t go into another season being unable or unwilling to run the football in an efficient manner.

Grade: C

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1