Brian Batko: Hello everybody! Not much has happened in Steeler land since we last chatted a week ago, but we are fresh off a weekend of wild playoff football, so I'm sure you all still have a lot on your mind. Here. We Go.

Change the guard: Hi Batko, Even with the year left on Bens QB do we draft a QB in this draft? I think Hurts would be a great addition and a steal in the 2nd. Time to think about the future and it's not #2 or #6.

Brian Batko: I really don't think so. As much as I do like Jalen Hurts - he gives off some Deshaun Watson/Dak Prescott type vibes - to me, the Steelers have too many other areas where they need to improve. And while it's always good to think about the future, they have a window that's still open right now, with this defense and Ben Roethlisberger presumably returning healthy.

Brian Batko: And I'm with you that neither Mason Rudolph nor Duck Hodges is the successor to 7. But you can still cross that bridge when you get to it. I don't see that being in 2020.

Advertise with us

Heath Miller Fan: Brian, based on the success the playoff teams have running the ball it seems obvious the Steelers need to make a significant commitment to improve the running game. No more BS and half hearted strategies. And accomplishing this goal must include a starting running back in the draft& upgrade from Ramon Foster. There is NO WAY you can rely on Connor to lead this team’s running success.

Brian Batko: Fixing the Oline, in whatever form that might take, is more significant than upgrading the backfield, in my opinion. But I'll say this much: 2020 seems like an AWESOME draft for running backs. So maybe the Steelers have one fall to them in the second or third round (assuming they get their comp pick) and get a steal. Plus, how many teams around the league really need a new back at this point? Miami for sure. Maybe Tampa, maybe Denver. And JK Dobbins, Najee Harris, Jonathan Taylor, D'Andre Swift and Travis Etienne are all studs likely to come out this year.

Kevin: What’s your prediction for most overasked question of the offseason?

Brian Batko: Great question, Kev. Definitely concerns about the QB situation, and almost certainly about the health of Ben. And rightfully so, really. Problem is, we can hear and read and write all we want about how his recovery is going, or how he believes it's going, but we won't truly know until he's back on the field, and probably not until he's back in game action, right? It's gonna be a long eight months from that standpoint.

STEEL72: Brian, likelihood of Colbert being lured away by Tepper?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Not gonna lie to you, I really have no feel for that one. It's up to Kevin what he wants at this point in his career. But it is hard to imagine him working anywhere else, and from the outside, it seems like it'll be pretty much a total tear-down and rebuild in Carolina, at least on offense outside of Christian McCaffrey.

jimmy: Hello - am i the only human on earth that seees so many problems with Coach Randy? He was a qb coach thrown into the OC spot and its easy to see he is over his head. Plz dont tell me 'everyone was hurt' this year, cause i have a thousand examples of how a great OC can adapt/adjust/scheme for backups. Also Haley's top 5 offense for 5 straight years had Ben making easy decisions(which he needs), now with Randy Ben was throwing 58 times a game. Can you tell me who the OC candidates they interviewed and DIDNT hire after they fired Haley....cause it seems they caved to Bens request of having Randy as OC, and didnt bring in a sharp/tenured/advanced talented OC that they cud have. To me the ABSOLUTE weakest link in the entire organization is their OC, Randy.

Brian Batko: No, you definitely aren't the only human on earth who thinks that.

Dave: If Ben’s injured elbow forces him to retire how much dead money will count against the Steelers 2020 cap?Thank you.

Brian Batko: According to the numbers from overthecap.com, he would count against the Steelers for 25 million next season and 12.5 million the following year.

Advertise with us

JuJu 2017: Brian, do you think the Steelers are taking a gamble thinking #7 will return healthy in 2020? After this years NFL Draft, Baltimore, Cleveland and Cinncy will have a future Franchise QB.

Brian Batko: No, I think it would be more of a gamble to try to find your heir apparent in a year you might not need to, at the expense of other positions. If that makes sense.

Titan in Charlotte: Hi Brian, not a fan of Fichtner but have to accept he will be OC next year. After watching the playoffs, it seems the Steelers front office MUST upgrade the TE situation for him. Do you think this is number 1B priority, with Dupree being 1A. I like our chances with a healthy Ben and a stud TE.

Brian Batko: Pretty much, yeah. I've been saying TE is a bigger need at this point than QB, WR and RB, when you look at the skill positions. But if the Steelers do intend on cutting Ramon Foster, OL might suddenly become priority 1B after keeping Bud Dupree. Depends on what this staff and front office thinks of the guys in waiting: Zach Banner, Chuks Okorafor, BJ Finney.

Ralph LA: Has Boswell talked at all about how he “fixed” whatever was wrong last season?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Not really. For better or worse, Chris Boswell doesn't say much.

SteelHeart: Hi Brian - Happy New Year ! If there is any silver lining in the 2019 season, do you think that coach Tomlin has learned that a team CAN WIN with "RB by committee" versus the "run em until their wheels come off" approach ? Thanks

Brian Batko: I do. Coming into the year, I believed that Mike Tomlin would indeed alter his usual approach and use more of a committee. He did, but partially because of James Conner's health holding him back. Do you use Conner less in attempt to keep him healthy? Do you use him differently? Do you bring in someone new altogether? Figuring out how to approach that in 2020 will be part of the evaluation process for Tomlin and his staff this offseason.

Franco: when will we know what the Steelers will do with Bud? Any specific dates that will be relevant? (start of FA, ect..)

Brian Batko: The first day teams can designate a franchise player is Feb. 25. The deadline to do so is March 10. It's entirely possible the Steelers will tip their hand before Feb. 25, which is what happened back in 2016 with Le'Veon Bell.

Advertise with us

California Bill : Big question- Bens arm strength?Are they planning for the worst?

Brian Batko: As Tomlin would say, they'll have a hardcore plan but be light on their feet!

Brian Batko: Still waiting to find that one in a fortune cookie by the way

abowers: Did the NFL investigate Myles Garrett's accusation that Mason Rudolph used a racial slur? There are fans that are claiming the NFL covered it up to protect the brand. My own feeling is that if it was said and picked up on the field mics, then FOX Sports would have reported it that night. They own the rights to the broadcast, I doubt the NFL would have the ability to censor whatever was captured on audio.

Brian Batko: Yes, the NFL said back in November they investigated it and found no evidence.

Advertise with us

Alaska Steeler: If Stillers don't spend the huge $$ to tag/sign Dupree, what position in free agency gets those dollars?

Brian Batko: Well, in that case, it'd probably have to be edge-rusher.

Lenny from NY: Hi Brian. Do you know why Rudolph mostly lines up in shotgun. I read that he is not comfortable under center. But he’s in the pros know , shouldn’t he be doing it. Thanks

Brian Batko: So does Duck. So did Ben before he got hurt. That's the changing tide of offense, both in the NFL and in college. A lot more shotgun, or if you're Baltimore, the pistol. To your question, unless I missed it, Rudolph has never once said he isn't comfortable under center or prefers not to do it. Not that I would expect him to, or any other QB, for that matter.

livinthedream: Happy New Year Brian, So we are to believe NE is ready to turn the keys over to a rookie named Jarrett Stidman and wave goodbye to the GOAT? What is going on? Although it would make 2020 interesting to have talent like Tom Brady and Eli Manning sitting on the sidelines waiting for somebody's starter to get knocked out.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I'd be surprised if Tom Brady isn't back with the Patriots. He strikes me as a guy who's going to have a Mariano Rivera type of farewell tour.

Jacque Strap: I understand that the Steelers have continued to pay Ryan Shazier for good reasons - allows him to stay around the team and use their facilities to rehab, which I have agreed with. If they moved him to a coach/scout (i.e. took his salary off the cap), would he still have access to their rehab facilities, or is there more to it than that?

Brian Batko: Oh, I'm sure he would. They're doing right by Shazier, and I imagine they'll continue to do so for as long as they can.

TheChotGun: Brian, love you and love the chats; thank you for a great season. Serious question - is there no dress code for coaches on the sideline? Randy Fichtner' sideline apparel, in particular, seemed unbecoming of the organization and our city.

Brian Batko: Ha, thank you. To be honest, I didn't spend a lot of time noticing or considering the sideline fashion of Fichtner or any other Steelers coaches. There might be a loose policy for what they wear, but Bill Belichick has long been known for his hoodies with cutoff sleeves and whatnot.

Advertise with us

D from Chi-Town: Everyone rightfully so is talking about the end of the New England dynasty and the dominance of Tom Brady and Bill Belichick over the past 20 years. One thing that stands out is the 17 division titles in 20 years. It seems many people overlook how the pathetic AFC east helped set the Patriots up with a first round bye on so many occasions. How many division titles would the Patriots have won if they were in any other division (such as the NFC East or AFC North), let alone have a first round bye so often - which set them up nicely for their 9 Superbowl runs?

Brian Batko: Bills Mafia is on the rise!

Steeler in Virginia: Is it fair to say it's much easier to get a top TE, OL, RB or WR in the second round as opposed to an OLB? Does that play a big role in franchising Dupree now so you can replace him with a first rounder in 2021 if you can't work out a deal?

Brian Batko: Yeah, I think it's fair to say guys at those positions generally can come in and make more of an impact immediately. But hey, with all the attention Cam Heyward and Stephon Tuitt draw on the interior, and of course the double teams awaiting TJ Watt on the other side, perhaps you can afford to slide in a lesser player, or younger player, or free-agent acquisition to replace Dupree. It's really tough to argue or overlook Bud's production in his contract year, but it's something to think about - find a guy who might not be as good, but is capable of winning his share of of 1-on-1s.

iowasteelerfan: If we decide to not resign Finney - who is our backup center for next year?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Currently it would be JC Hassenauer, Alabama second-year guy who was with the Steelers all through camp, then got back on the practice squad midseason, then came up to the 53 for Week 17 with Maurkice Pouncey out.

Jds317: Should Steelers be revamping offense to highlight run? Ben is a question mark and receivers aren't great. Move out foster and Big Al and bring in a quality back. Your thoughts?

Brian Batko: I don't know about revamping the offense just yet. Let's see what Ben has left in the tank before we go that far. And I think releasing Foster would be a prudent move, good as he is in the locker room, but I don't know about moving on from Al Villanueva at this point. He has one year left on his contract, and while he had some struggles this season, breaking in a new left tackle seems risky to me.

Mr. Big Chest: I gotta whole lotta money.

Brian Batko: That's what I'm hearing

Advertise with us

GSMP: What rookie or first year player that played sparingly this year may be poised for an expanded role next year? Layne? Skipper? Spillane? Someone else?

Brian Batko: Justin Layne basically redshirted this year, other than his special teams work. I'm not sure where he'd fit in unless there's an injury to outside corners Joe Haden and Steven Nelson, or if they try to move him to a slot corner role. But that's not really his game. Tuzar Skipper would almost certainly get a crack at starting on the edge IF for some reason they don't tag Bud Dupree. I do kind of like what I saw out of Deon Cain. Not a rookie, but a guy who was in his first year here.

Jimmie: With the loss of Big Chest and the disappointing McDonald season, shouldn't the #2 draft choice go for a pass catching tight end as first priority for the pass-first offense under #7?

Brian Batko: If Bud is back, I think the Steelers are in a position where they can go best available player, within reason. Identify your favorite RB, TE, OL or maybe even ILB that's still on the board when you pick in the second round and pull the trigger.

KK: I see that it’s not unusual for guards to play center and vice versa. Is it easier to switch from G to C or the other way around?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Probably from C to G. You're asked to do a lot more with communication and, obviously, snapping the ball when you move to center.

Bill in SF: I know the Steelers don't like to "live in their fears," but do you suppose they have a solid plan B in place for if Ben's February 1 rehab update is not good news?

Brian Batko: If that update goes poorly, they'll probably have to take a step back and assess this offseason in a different light. But at this point, I still think Mason Rudolph is the Plan B for 2020.

Seven’s Coming: Hey Brian- thanks for the chats. I look forward to them! Watching the playoffs this week made me realize how much our offense missed having a big body, solid hands type TE. I wonder how much a guy like that could have made check downs easier on a young QB. Do you see anyone in the draft who could fill that void for the Steelers?

Brian Batko: Thanks for looking forward to the chats. I'm with you, and that idea played out perfectly against Seattle in Week 2 when Mason Rudolph stepped right in and found Vance McDonald for two TDs. And then McDonald more or less disappeared. Whether Mason or Duck, they just didn't use the middle of the field all that often. Nick Vannett was never much of a pass-catcher in Seattle, so his acquisition was more about the blocking aspect of his position.

Advertise with us

Sydney Beagle: Any chance that the Steelers take LeVeon back? The Jets may be to make a deal and eat part of the contract.

Brian Batko: That would be rather outlandish, Sydney. He's good, but not good enough to invite that headache/distraction/etc. all over again.

Steelers22: Do you think both Polamalu and Faneca make the 2020 Hall of Fame class or just the former?

Brian Batko: Just the former, my dear Steelers22

Ryno: Tomlin commented that Dupree is a priority. Do you take that to mean they will bring him back one way or the other (longterm deal or tag)?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Yes, that is how I took it, and I'm thinking tag

Paul from Sacramento: Hi Brian, Happy New Year!! Love your chats and insight. Do you think there is any chance that the Steelers would draft a QB in the 2nd round? Seeing that Ben is now (my estimation) a bigger question mark coming off Tommy John (he's a year older - and that the deep throws really put a strain on that ol elbow) and that we're beginning to see teams move to more mobile QB's (ala: Wilson, Jackson, Mahones and to a lesser extent Tannehill). Mason doesn't seem to move around much in the pocket and can't seem to extend the plays much...

Brian Batko: Same to you, Paul! For the record, Ben did not have Tommy john as far as we know, but you've got a great point. I do think that's a route the Steelers could take in looking for their NEXT franchise quarterback. I've already said here today that I don't think that's Rudolph. Not that that's some hot take or anything. But I also don't believe you have to find that guy in this upcoming draft. With Lamar Jackson and Kyler Murray, we're seeing running QBs be able to come into the league and play pretty well right from the jump.

Koopla: All the naysayers talking about D. Bush and Edmunds performance but, they led the Steelers in tackles... #1 and #2. Check the stats...

Brian Batko: Uh, tackles are kind of an empty stat sometimes, Koopla. Especially for a safety.

Advertise with us

Titan in Charlotte: Fictional question. Without worrying about salary, or if the player is actually available, what one current NFL player you would choose to be a 2020 Steeler?

Brian Batko: Man, that's a great question. Unsurprising coming from a Shaler grad. Part of me says Travis Kelce because of how much he could help this offense. Part of me says Michael Thomas because he's the best receiver in the world. And part of me says Lamar Jackson because he's just absurd. I'll say Thomas. You add him to this offense and you're probably giving Ben the best WR corps in the league.

Greenwood: Over the years I've heard the reason LC Greenwood was not voted to the HoF is because too many voters thought too many Steelers from the 70's were in. Of course, the HoF should be on individual merit and have nothing to do with how many others are in or not. With the 10 seniors going in this year, the only reason I could think LC was on on the list is perhaps because he's passed away. Shell should, of course, also already be in, and hopefully will this year. Do you think if Shell goes in, that will seal the cap on Steelers from that era?

Brian Batko: I would think so, just because as time goes on, you have more and more great players end their NFL careers and it gets tougher and tougher to make that final ballot.

Avoid Lloyd: Don't spend the dollars on Bud, replace with Ola/Skipper (plenty of talent at defense to make up for it) Use the savings to bring in FA at TE/OL/WR. Crazy or crazy like a fox?

Brian Batko: You might be crazy like a fox. But Ola Adeniyi didn't get a ton of opportunities this year, so i wonder how much the powers that be really believe in his ability. Same for Tuzar Skipper. And given how they've operated in the past, the Steelers have always tended to lean more toward stability rather than splashy signings. I'd say it's been working, for the most part.

Brian Batko: OK buds, that's all the time we have for today. Thanks for all the great questions and participation in an early-January chat. Our final edition of the Skinny Post newsletter will hit email inboxes on Wednesday, and will be sort of a season-in-review type deal. Please subscribe here if you haven't already. It is free, and you made a resolution to try new things this year. https://my.post-gazette.com/newsletters/