Off the top of your head, how many quarterbacks would you guess started games for the Steelers this decade?
Obviously, Ben Roethlisberger started the vast majority of games from 2010-19. But there were times where he was either suspended or injured and backups had to come in and do their best to lead the Steelers to victory.
For the record, seven other quarterbacks started at least one game for the Steelers over the past 10 years. They all brought a diverse array of skill sets to the table and had varying degrees of success filling in for Roethlisberger under center.
While you try to remember that one quarterback whose name is just on the tip of your tongue, check out this list of non-Roethlisberger starting QBs from the past decade:
7. Dennis Dixon

Remember Dixon? The Steelers took him in the fifth round of the 2008 draft out of Oregon. They must have liked his athleticism and ability to use his legs to potentially break big runs.
Read More
Dixon wound up starting three games for the Steelers, one in 2009 and two in 2010. In those two 2010 starts, he went 22 of 32 for 254 yards, no touchdowns and an interception. He also rushed five times for 32 yards and finished with a QB rating of 79.4.
That was pretty much the highlight of Dixon’s time in Pittsburgh, as his post-Steelers career only amounted to two brief stints with the Ravens and Cardinals before flaming out of the NFL for good. That overtime win over the Falcons in the 2010 opener was pretty cool, though.
6. Landry Jones

There was a brief moment where it seemed like the Steelers might be grooming Jones — their 2013 fourth-round draft pick — to be Roethlisberger’s long-term successor. Clearly, that idea never quite panned out.
Jones started five games for the Steelers between 2015-17, acting as a solid but unspectacular stopgap during a few Roethlisberger recovery periods. His shining moment as a Steeler wasn’t even as a starter, but when he came in for an injured Michael Vick and led Pittsburgh to a 25-13 upset victory over the eventual 13-3 Arizona Cardinals.
The Steelers may have moved on from him after the 2017 season, but they did reportedly inquire about his availability earlier this season after Roethsliberger went down for the year. The XFL blocked the request, so we’ll never know if a second stint would have yielded better results.
5. Byron Leftwich

As backups go, Leftwich was probably overqualified. He spent a few years in the early 2000s as a starter for Jacksonville before bouncing around from Atlanta to Pittsburgh to Tampa Bay and finally settling in as a Steelers backup.
He’s this low on the list mostly because he only started one game for the Steelers this decade: a 13-10 loss to the Ravens in 2012 in which he hurt himself early on an uncharacteristically athletic 31-yard touchdown scramble and struggled the rest of the way. The video of this game is worth a watch purely because the Steelers were wearing their oft-maligned but criminally underrated bumblebee jerseys.
Leftwich went 18 for 39 for 199 yards, no touchdowns and an interception in that contest. He’s probably better than other quarterbacks who started a game for Pittsburgh between 2010-19, but a poor performance in his one start held him back.
4. Devlin Hodges

The luster of the quack attack may have faded over the last three games, but the undrafted rookie out of Samford who no one would have guessed in the preseason would ever see the field in 2019 did more than anyone could’ve expected, putting the Steelers in position to make the playoffs.
Hodges has started six games and won three of them. Despite performing admirably in his first three starts and the occasional electric play, Hodges’ wings were clipped over the last three weeks. His four-interception meltdown in Week 15 against the Bills was followed by two interceptions (and a quick exit, then necessary return) against the Jets and another subpar performance against the Ravens.
He won enough this season to earn a higher spot than those who had fewer opportunities.
3. Michael Vick

The Steelers knew they weren’t getting prime, world-beating Vick when they signed him before the 2015 season. But his presence in black and gold came in handy when Roethlisberger went down in Week 3.
Vick started three games that season, including an overtime loss to the Ravens that many may remember as “the Josh Scobee game” and a 24-20 victory over the Chargers that included a walk-off Le’Veon Bell touchdown and Vick turning back the clock to make some spectacular plays down the stretch.
He will always be a subject of controversy due to his past transgressions, but Vick held down the fort admirably when he was called upon in Pittsburgh.
2. Mason Rudolph

If you're thinking this seems a bit too high for Rudolph given that he spent a few weeks riding the Steelers bench after being supplanted from his starting role by a quarterback named Duck, hear us out.
Rudolph started eight games between Roethlisberger getting hurt during Week 2 and him being pulled from a game against the Bengals in Week 12. Overall this past season, he threw 13 touchdowns and nine interceptions and led the Steelers to arguably their best win of the season, a 17-12 victory over the Rams in Week 10.
The sheer number of games Rudolph was able to start (and win) — plus the fact he came into the Week 16 game against the Jets and immediately performed well — bolsters his case. Of course, his inconsistency and inability to stay on the field prevent him from topping this ranking.
1. Charlie Batch

There was a time last decade when there was a real argument to be made that Batch was the best backup quarterback in the NFL. Even during the latter days of his career, he was still everything you could ask for from a backup.
He went 6-3 overall as a starter for the Steelers and 3-2 this decade. Batch led a 38-13 beatdown of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 2010 during which he threw three touchdowns and two interceptions. The numbers may not be gaudy, but how often do you see a backup quarterback come away with a margin of victory that large?
Every team would love a backup quarterback as trustworthy as Batch when the worst happens to the starter.
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxel222




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.