Brian Batko: Good afternoon, everyone, and happy holidays. It's also my mom's birthday, so special happy birthday to her. I know, I know, yesterday was a brutal one for Steelers fans, but let's chat through it, shall we?
JuJu 2017: Good Morning Brian, is it me or did the Team, especially the Defense look a little flat in the 1st half yesterday?
Brian Batko: Or maybe the Jets just came out hungry? They were running the ball well early, but that's been an issue for the Steelers in other weeks, too. A rare mistake by Minkah Fitzpatrick, too, and it's probably not a stretch to say that if he picks off that pass instead of getting called for DPI, that whole game plays out differently.
Jw: Are we not able to throw the quick crossers? ESP when they blitz and vacate that area?
Brian Batko: It has been a struggle for the Steelers to use the middle of the field this season, especially for Devlin Hodges. You saw Mason Rudolph have a little more success with that when he came in.
Tampa Too: If Duck plays lights out against Baltimore and wins the game do you think we can trade him to Cincinnati for the number one draft pick? Merry Christmas!
Read More
Brian Batko: That would be a Christmas miracle, my dear friend. The Bengals fans are all set for hometown-ish kid Joe Burrow to come back home and be the franchise QB. I don't know how it will affect my boss Tyler Batiste if the Steelers have to face an LSU legend twice a year for the next umpteen seasons.
Lou: If the Steelers add an offensive skill player via free agency, who do you think it could be?
Brian Batko: More than anything, I think they could use a more dynamic, field-stretching, pass-catching tight end. Not that those grow on trees or anything, but assuming Nick Vannett becomes a FA, the 2020 class isn't particularly intriguing. Eric Ebron will be on the market, but he's injury prone. Same goes for Hunter Henry of the Chargers.
In search of 7: Hi Brian. My brother and I have different views of the Steelers' potential next season. I think they have enough pieces, with a healthy Ben, to be a serious SB contender. He thinks most the offense needs to be rebuilt and that 2020 will be another lost year. What do you think?
Brian Batko: I'm on your side. Partly because of my belief in said pieces, but also because I don't think it's realistic to try to rebuild this offense on the fly. The Steelers' future without Ben Roethlisberger is the great unknown, so you can't really afford any more "lost years" with him still in the fold and this defense the way it's been playing.
Realist: Yes, it’s the NFL, and I know...on any given week...but after witnessing the QB and overall offensive (word is intentional) performance the past few weeks, does anyone truly want to see this team in the playoffs? It may set a new level of ineptitude that could be unprecedented.
Brian Batko: I don't understand this sentiment. Of course you still want to see the Steelers make the playoffs if you're a fan. This is like when fans of a mediocre college basketball team say they'd rather win the NIT than make the NCAA tournament. No. That's dumb. The goal every year is to get in the dance, partly because anything can happen once you're in, but also for legacies and what it says about your organization overall. Plus, in this case, the Steelers don't have a first-round pick anyway, so there's nothing to play for - or lose for - on that front.
Guest: Any word on who the QB will be Sunday?
Brian Batko: No, sir. The locker room will be open here on the South Side shortly - no "Victory Monday" for these guys - and it's highly unlikely anyone will spill the beans in there. If Mike Tomlin follows his same pattern, he'll inform us of his plans tomorrow at his press conference.
Utah Jim: Should Tomlin have challenged the DPI on Fitzpatrick? Looked to me like he was standing still and the receiver ran into him. What about challenging Haden’s interception?
Brian Batko: I don't think so on the DPI. Looked like a good call to me. The Joe Haden play, maybe. It very well may have been a catch and then down by contact. But hey, with the way the NFL rules are anymore, I can't blame a guy for not wanting to go down the road of what is or isn't a catch.
Gravel: Hi Brian- No doubt QB position has alot to do with offensive ineptitude. But there appears to be no plan on usage of RBs. O-Line has been source of a number of miscues. Both positions have new coaches this year. RB position is young and O-Line is old. Has the QB woes blinded fans to other issues that have contributed to paltry scoring?
Brian Batko: Seemed like the plan yesterday was for a lot more work on James Conner's plate, but then he got hurt. All of that factors into the offensive ineptitude, but I do still think the QB play is the biggest issue.
Marty: What's so disappointing is the decline in performance Duck/Mason each week. Tomlin needs to think & get a QB coach for them. The OC can't do both QB coach & run the offense. Plus our play calling is terrible. We run on 1st down with less then 2 minutes left & we have to go 70 yds for TD to win.
Brian Batko: Indeed, it might be time. They do have an offensive assistant who works with them, but a full-time staffer at that spot would be a simple move to make this offseason.

Dr. Mike: What is BIG BEN currently weighing?
Brian Batko: Heavy on the minds of those who thought this offense could keep producing without him
Steeler in Virginia: As much as I want to see this team make the playoffs to reward this great defense, the difference between 8-8 and 9-7 could be huge when it comes to draft order with nine teams right now all around the same spot. I know we don't have a first-round pick, but a good draft could make this a Super Bowl team next year. Would you be tempted to tank?
Brian Batko: That's a fair point, but still, no. Would be a pretty bad message to send to this locker room that has kept the train moving and the team in contention during an injury-ravaged season.
Tom: Brian, Watched the Eagles game and they have had as many or more injures and somehow won a big game. Having a NFL caliber QB helps. Like it has been written if Mason cannot go why not throw Paxton out there. Whether they lose by 1 or 50 what does it matter at this point? What are your thoughts? Thank you.
Brian Batko: It certainly does. But I still think there's more comfort in starting a QB (Duck) who has been in game situations with this offense this year as opposed to a guy who has done nothing but run the scout team in practice (Lynch). If Lynch had been impressing in that arena, the Duck Tale probably never gets its start at home against Baltimore or in LA.
Realist: Mobility seems to be more important than ever in today’s NFL. For every Tom Brady, there are 2-3 emerging stars like Jackson, Mahomes, Allen, who illustrate the advantages of mobility. Ben, back in the day, had great mobility to at least extend plays, as do the Brees, Garropolo’s and seemingly all other playoff team’s QB’s. Ben will be a yr older and legs that much heavier, Rudolph has not shown this ability, and Duck doesn’t matter as he simply doesn’t have an NFL arm. Without a 1st Rounder, it will be difficult to get this breed of QB “off the shelf”. So Stillers will need to develop one. Do you see them drafting a project (and not addressing other needs, then), or finding one in FA? Or does the Stiller way dictate we ignore this trend and ride Ben “‘til the wheels fall off”, as sadly, that is happening now and we have no viable QB solution waiting in the wings.
Brian Batko: I would guess they'll hold off on drafting another QB next year, unless it's a true project in the late late rounds. The position is indeed changing, but you still have a Hall of Famer at that spot, albeit an aging one. To me, the way to go is just what a lot of teams are doing. Bottom out when your time comes, use a high pick on your next franchise QB, hope he's the real deal.
rman: The Steeler offense as far as the skill positions looks like something we would see in the last few minutes of a pre-season game. Not to besmirch these guys because they've done some good things but it's not like the QB can recognize a defense and nod at the wide receiver and change a play. There hasn't been any continuity due to injuries. My question is this---why take the time to try to assign blame? After all, we are heading into the last week of the season with a chance to stumble into the playoffs. Merry Christmas to all !!!!
Brian Batko: I like it, rman. But I have a feeling we have a lot more questions assigning blame before this chat is over.
BringBackWeegie: Were you surprised Vince Williams did not play much yesterday, especially with the need to shutdown the Jets running game? Jets ran just enough to beat us.
Brian Batko: As a matter of fact, I was. After two games in a row with more than 50 percent of the snaps, he had just a 38 percent share yesterday.
Jay: The OC should be gone after this season. I know he lost Ben but he has shown no creativity in working with what he has. Why call plays that Duck cannot execute because of this limited arm strength? A good coach figures these things out. I do not see any teams bringing him on as an OC. How do you see his future with the Steelers? Thank you.
Brian Batko: Everyone always wants to fire one of the coordinators. Last year it was Keith Butler, this year Randy Fichtner. I personally don't think he's been doing a great job, but if one of his best attributes is his chemistry with Roethlisberger, it might not be wise to fire him before those two get a chance to work together again.
BringBackWeegie: Who gives the Steelers a better chance to win next week - Lynch or Duck, assuming MR cannot go?
Brian Batko: Still think it's Duck
SteelersfanSLC: I see people saying we "played down" to our competition. When you look at the offensive talent we had available plus the talent that left sue to injuries can you really say we "played down"?
Brian Batko: No, not really. The Jets were at home and have at least a little bit of talent, anyway. It's not like they lost to the Bengals or Dolphins.
TomnBloomfield: Any idea how severe Rudolph’s injury?
Brian Batko: Not yet
Is Steelers QB Paxton Lynch ready to play?
jack: Who do you think was the biggest loss in the off-season. AB or Mike Munchak?
Brian Batko: From a pure production standpoint, Antonio Brown, hands down.
SteelyDan: The Texans are pretty banged up and will be resting their starters. Even if the Steelers can score more than ten points in Baltimore the will need a festivus miracle to get into the playoofs.
Brian Batko: Correct, I don't expect Houston to beat a Tennessee team that has been a fun story and is trying to get to the playoffs for just the second time since 2008.
Krut: With missing the Play-offs again this year, we now qualify for the Hard Knocks Jinx and HBO/NFL will surely pick the Steelers. Is there anyway we can refuse being on that show?
Brian Batko: I don't believe so, but they could make themselves ineligible ... by firing Mike Tomlin. (That's not gonna happen.)
Doug from Raleigh: With Ben being at some level a ? for next year, do you think the club will retain Rudolph for another looksee and development, but go out and get an actual experienced backup in case Ben can't rebound? Quarterback OJT with this roster seems like a bad idea.
Brian Batko: Sure, they could. I do think Mason Rudolph will be on the team next year. Duck Hodges is probably the bigger question mark at this point. Oh, how much things can change in just a couple weeks.
Steve o: And if Lynch is worse than both Rudolph and Hodges then he must be awful and probably is wasting a spot
Brian Batko: I mean, let's not act like there's no gray area between "No. 3 QB" and "NFL-capable starter"
TomnBloomfield: Is playoff money to players counted in the salary cap?
Brian Batko: I believe those are pure bonuses. Otherwise you'd be penalizing teams for making the postseason.
Jack: Do you really think JUJU is a No 1 receiver? I just do not see it. Good slot receiver seems to me.
Brian Batko: Can I say the jury's still out? It doesn't look like it from this season, but he's had mediocre QB play, injuries and not a great supporting cast to draw double teams away from him.
Scooter: Has to be one of the worse showings from the O Line is quite one time? Missed assignments, letting LBs and tackles have free run at the QB on more than occasion? It seems we have gone from 3 pro bowlers last year to now a concern - agree?
Brian Batko: Agreed. The front office will have some tough decisions to make there, it seems.
Mr Medium Chest: Was at the game yesterday and the difference in arm strength between MR & Duck is extreme. Duck INT in the endzone was so bad i think the defender called for a fair catch. I’m not sure you can run him out there with that arm, the league is on to him. Would you start Lynch if MR cant go? Thank you and Merry Christmas
Daniel from Ohio: How long do we have to watch these vanilla play calls? Randy F. seems like he has 4 play calls and we run on first down 90% of the time...the game plan doesn’t seem to be innovative at all...what are your thoughts?
Brian Batko: Let's pair these questions together, shall we? If we're acknowledging Duck's physical limitations, that doesn't exactly make life easy on the guy trying to call plays to work around those limitations. Now, have I seen much creativity in play design and whatnot? No. But even then, when he has tried to think outside the box, at least with the Wildcat, things have gone terribly wrong.
Mark: Terrel Edmunds could cover a book...he is terrible!
Brian Batko: He's gotta make some kind of play on that Robby Anderson touchdown. Didn't manage to break it up or try to knock the ball loose. That was bad.
Sydney Beagle: Perhaps, just perhaps if the highly paid offensive line was less offensive, the QB would have a moment to complete a pass or the RB could gain more yards. Pouncey's wild snaps replaced by Finney's big feet and bad snaps compounded the QB woes. Neither QB had much support from their mates catching the ball either. What a mess! I know it won't happen but the offensive coordinator (Friend Of Ben Fitchner) and o-line coach need to go. Your thoughts?
Brian Batko: Shaun Sarrett is in his first year as the OL coach, but had been in the organization working under Mike Munchak for years. Actually, he predates Munchak, so obviously they like him to a certain extent and have for a while now.
Timmy Colorado Springs: Do you think the Steelers play the Cowboys on Thanksgiving next year?
Brian Batko: Hadn't really thought about it. But I hope not. Steelers-Cowboys will be in Dallas, regardless. Or in Arlington, if you're a stickler.
Pitt Panther in NC: What’s next, B-man? Paxton? Btw, how well can you throw a football? Ray can block and Gerry punt. The BFD line! Hehe.
Brian Batko: Not particularly well. Although I am pretty much equally adept at throwing with either hand, for some reason.
Chotty: How does one even begin to evaluate Connor's market value at a free agent? How does one attempt to do the same with JuJu? Is JuJu a #1 WR? Never mind the drops, he cannot get open...
Brian Batko: Yeah, it's gonna be tough, Chotty. I think smart organizations aren't spending big money on running backs these days, unless you have a clear no-brainer big-time talent like a Christian McCaffrey. JuJu will be an even harder decision to make. I'm not sure you can pay him big bucks this offseason if you're the Steelers. And going into this year, I figured it would be a slam dunk.
Franco: I am an overweight 31 yr old who sits at home and drinks beer while watching the Steelers so i guess I shouldn't be criticizing too much. With that being said- If it was Masons non throwing shoulder do you think that given his particular circumstance he should have gutted it out and continued playing. He looked good out there when he got his chance. Do you feel like players would lose respect for him for not giving playing through the pain in a must win season deciding game?
Brian Batko: Ha, maybe cut back on the beer and increase the exercise as a New Year's resolution, my guy. But to your question, no, I think it was pretty clear how big of a hit Rudolph took on that one. He has everything to gain right now by proving himself as better than the player he was last time we saw him in game action.
dsf: what do you make of lev bells entrance wardobe? signaling regret?
Brian Batko: Nah, I think Le'Veon Bell is pretty good at trolling and knew that wearing Steelers colors to the Steelers game would get people talking.
Stephen : Happy Holidays Brian and Happy Birthday to your mother. May God Grant Her Many Years. Could you explain the apparent bad blood between Hines and the Steelers, particularly Ben. Thanks
Brian Batko: Thank you, Stephen. "Bad blood" might be a strong word, but Hines Ward joined the chorus of former players questioning Roethlisberger's leadership abilities this offseason when all the AB stuff was going haywire. I believe his exact words were that Ben "needs to do more" as a leader.
rfredward: Could Lynch be much worse than what we saw Sunday?
Brian Batko: Marshawn? He's reportedly re-signing with the Seahawks!
Jim From Venetia : Is James Conner worth keeping around if he can’t stay healthy? He’s a great guy but isn’t very productive over the course of a season.
Brian Batko: I mean, no one's worth keeping around if they can't stay healthy. At a position that's already devalued, that could be bad news for his future with the Steelers.
WV Black & Gold: Getting ahead of myself for sure, but I’ve heard that the Cardinals and David Johnson may part ways this offseason. Johnson has a very similar skillset to Lev Bell, but none of the baggage. Do you think the Steelers might show some interest if the price is right?
Brian Batko: Nah. Johnson has fallen out of favor in Arizona with the new coaching staff, and I think the Steelers need to use their money elsewhere. I really don't expect them to make a big move at RB, and I wouldn't even use a high draft pick on one.
AK: How is it that people think a guy who hasn’t seen game action in two years and never with the Steelers will be better than what we have?
Brian Batko: Because the backup QB is always the most popular guy in town.
Jwandburgh : How does it play out this final week? Steelers Titans Raiders lose and PITT backs in or lose/Titans,win and stay home for 4th time in last 8 seasons!
Brian Batko: If the Steelers lose, they need the Titans and Raiders to lose and the Colts to win. That's not asking too much, right?
Brian Batko: OK thanks for joining today, folks. Almost time for the locker room to open. Have a great holiday week.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.