Quarterback: What’s not to like about Duck Hodges? The kid exudes confidence and makes plays when the Steelers need them the most. Once again, the stats aren’t gaudy. He threw for just 152 yards and one touchdown, but he didn’t make any big mistakes. In fact, he outplayed Kyler Murray, the No. 1 overall pick in this year’s draft, who tossed three interceptions. Hodges also shows great instincts on when to tuck the ball and run on scrambles. He finished with 34 yards on five carries and was the team’s third-leading rusher. Duck season continues for another week.
Grade: A
Running backs: The Steelers continued their running-back-by-committee approach with great results for the third week in a row. Rookies Benny Snell and Kerrith Whyte each had 41 yards. Whyte’s speed to the outside is something the Steelers were missing all season. He averaged more than 8 yards per carry. Snell had an early fumble that got the Cardinals back in the game, but he came back strong and made some nice runs after the mistake. For the Steelers to be winning with three rookies as their top three rushers is an amazing feat. Even if James Conner returns from his shoulder injury, the Steelers should have plenty of faith in their young backs if the coaches choose to continue with a rotation.
Grade: B+
Receivers: A week after making some costly mistakes against the Browns, Diontae Johnson redeemed himself with the best game of his rookie season. He was a factor as a punt returner, receiver and runner. His 85-yard punt return for a touchdown will be on all the highlight shows, but his 14-yard catch and run, when he shook Patrick Peterson at the line of scrimmage, might have been more impressive. It also helped set up his 2-yard touchdown catch a few minutes later. James Washington didn’t put up big stats — he only had 33 yards on four catches — but he did draw two crucial pass interference penalties. It’s not a deep receiving corps, but someone steps up each week and makes a big play or two. And like the running backs, it’s a bunch of young guys who are doing most of the heavy lifting.
Grade: A-
Read More
Offensive line: The run-blocking, especially in the second half, was strong again. The Steelers might be taking advantage of some weak defensive fronts. The Cardinals, Browns and Bengals are among the worst defenses in the league, but at least the Steelers know how to take advantage of them. It was the third week in a row the Steelers went over 100 yards rushing. Hodges was sacked three times. One was a strip sack. Matt Feiler recovered after Chandler Jones beat him around the edge. But all in all, it was a winning effort from a unit that continues to improve late in the season.
Grade: B
Defensive line: Only one defensive lineman recorded a sack. That came from Cam Heyward, but they did a terrific job of pressuring Murray and forcing him into quick decisions. They got consistent pressure on Murray, particularly in the first quarter and on Arizona’s final drive. They let up a bit in the middle of the game, allowing Murray a few clean pockets that resulted in big Cardinals gains. But for the most part, they made his day very difficult.
Grade: B+
Linebackers: It was another monster game for the outside linebackers. Bud Dupree had a sack and three tackles for losses. T.J. Watt didn’t have a sack, but he had a critical interception in the end zone when the Cardinals were driving for a score in the fourth quarter. The inside linebackers showed up, too. Mark Barron and Vince Williams had sacks and Barron finished in a tie for the team lead with seven tackles.
Grade: A
Secondary: Joe Haden is having a Pro Bowl-caliber season. He had two more interceptions to give him four in the past five games. Steven Nelson had seven tackles and Minkah Fitzpatrick did a great job containing Murray when he tried to run a read option in the first half. Murray came into the game with only six interceptions all season. It’s a credit to the work the Steelers put in during the week to pick him off three times. This group continues to get turnovers — and timely ones — week after week.
Grade: A
Special teams: If you had to come up with a movie title to fit the play of the special teams, it would be “The Good, The Bad and The Ugly”. First, the good: Johnson’s 85-yard punt return was huge because it gave the Steelers an early 10-point lead on the road. The bad: allowing a fake punt run on fourth-and-7. The ugly: the ill-advised fake up 10 midway through the fourth quarter while in their own territory. If the Steelers had lost this game, Jordan Berry’s gaffe would have gone down as one of the biggest mistakes in franchise history. Berry explained that he didn’t hear the fake was called off. But he has to know in that situation that a fake would never be on. At least he had a good sense of humor about it afterward.
Grade: C-
Coaching: The decision-making and play-calling in the fourth quarter left a lot to be desired, but let’s get real: Mike Tomlin is winning games with a rookie undrafted free agent and a bunch of other rookies on offense. Other than the decision late in the game to throw on second down, offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner had some effective play calls that kept the Cardinals off balance. It’s a conservative game plan every week, but there is a certain art to calling the right plays in situations when the team needs a first down or a big play. Fichtner did that very well on Sunday. The defense is well-coached and playing at an elite level. Keith Butler has his players at the top of their game. But back to the fake punt, because it’s such a strange call. Berry didn’t grow up playing football. He’s from Australia. He doesn’t necessarily know game situations as well as American-born players. So in that situation, it was up to Mike Tomlin or Danny Smith to communicate to him that in no circumstance should he go through with a fake. That obviously didn’t happen. It’s a mistake that could have cost the Steelers a playoff berth. They’re lucky the defense bailed them out at the end.
Grade: C



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.