Steelers insider: Ok let's get the chat started.

T Rex: With what we know now, do you think it would have been better to draft DK Metcalf in the first round rather than trade up for Devin Bush?

Steelers insider: No I don't. Metcalf is a nice player. Obviously, some of the concerns with his game were unfounded. He fell to late in the second round and I'm sure some GMs will regret that decision if he continues to play well. He has 44 catches for 705 yards. That's more than any Steelers receivers by a wide margin. However, I think Devin Bush will develop into a very good player for the Steelers defense. There have been some growing pains, but the upside is sky high.

Turk in MD: Is Tomlin riding with Duck until the wings fall off?

Advertise with us

Steelers insider: Certainly until he loses.

Artie Bridge: What do you make of the drastic decline in our tight end play? Eroding skills? Bad schemes? No Ben?

Steelers insider: I think it certainly has something to do with the QB situation. For whatever reason, Ben and Vance McDonald clicked and they were productive together. He hasn't clicked with Rudolph or Hodges. At least not to this point in the season. I wrote a story a few weeks ago about this. When Ben was placed on IR opposing defensive coordinators began playing almost exclusively man-to-man defense against the Steelers. And the WRs and TEs haven't been able to gain a lot of separation. It certainly could be that McDonald's skills are eroding, or maybe he just got open against zones more than the average fan knew. Whatever the case, it's exposed a big weakness in the Steelers offense. I would imagine the Steelers will be targeting a pass-catching tight end that will be more effective against man when the 2020 draft rolls around. Or maybe another big WR that can get open. There just hasn't been enough plays made by the skill players all season.

Tampa Too: Have we seen the last of Ryan Switzer?

Steelers insider: Well, he won't play again this year because he was placed on IR with a back injury. He's another one of those skill players that wasn't effective vs. man coverage. It got to the point where Ficthner wasn't even putting him out there. He was exclusively on the roster to be the punt returner. Maybe with Ben back they'd keep a slot guy that can work against zones, but maybe they just go in another direction altogether and look for someone else.

Advertise with us

Tampa Too: If AB never plays another down in the NFL is he Hall of Fame worthy?

Steelers insider: I think so. But he'd definitely be one of those guys people thought about because their on- and off-field behavior was deplorable.

Mo: With Antoni Brown coming off the books, will that free up the Steelers to pursue High Level Free agents, since they do not have a first round draft pick?

Steelers insider: No, I don't think they'll be in financial position to spend big in free agency. Not that they ever have. They don;t believe in building their team that way.

Luke S: With James Washington playing well do You feel that it will open up juju's game? Up until his injury, he has not had a good season

Advertise with us

Steelers insider: That's a great point. Washington's emergence should open things up for JuJu and Diontae Johnson once JuJu does return. Doesn;t sound like JuJu will practice tomorrow, but it sounded like there's a chance he could get on the field later in the week.

Luke S: Is it Benny Snell or better offensive line play that has improved the running game over the last 2 weeks?

Steelers insider: I noted this in my report card on Sunday. His downhill running style helps the offensive line. He doesn't get tackled for losses very often. And 2-yard gains become 4-yard gains because he is always falling forward or fighting for extra yards. He might not be a game-breaker in terms of his speed, but his running style has given this offense some semblance of an identity late in the season.

Jeff: i get this will not be a popular take since most think Pouncy walks on water but the running game is better with Finney, whether at center or guard. 11 yard gain straight up the middle when the defense knew it was coming? hasn't happened all year.

Steelers insider: Finney is a tremendous reserve. They're something like 12-1 when he is asked to start. I think he could start on half the teams across the NFL, including the Steelers. But let's also take into account the opponents. The Bengals were the NFL's worst rush defense when the Steelers played them. The Browns were among the bottom five teams in the league against the run. This week they play another bad defense. The Cardinals are dead-last in total defense. Another week the Steelers running game should do well.

Advertise with us

Steeler in Virginia: First, thank you to all the P-G writers and editors for all that you do. We support your efforts. Second, what is the actual injury to JJSS's knee? If the playoffs were out of reach, would he be having surgery?

Steelers insider: It's a knee injury. We haven't been given any details. All I can tell you is he's worn a big brace around the facility the past two weeks. He's rehabbing and the hope is he can return at some point. Not sure if it'll be this week against the Cardinals, but there is hope he can play again.

TJ: Your take on Edmunds ? Missed three tackles in first quarter alone, average player at best? Another DB tomlin hasn’t developed?

Steelers insider: I think there is room for growth in Edmunds' game. I like that he is dependable. However, he's not a great open-field tackler. Usually your strong safety has that quality. He's not great in coverage either. So I guess I'm wanting to see what he does well and for him to become a difference-maker for the defense. He's obviously a starter on a very good unit, but I just feel like he can and will do more with more experience.

Questfor7: Have the Steelers ever lost a game that BJ Finney has started? It seems like they never miss a beat when he fills in.

Advertise with us

Steelers insider: They usually don't. They did lose one game when Finney started at guard. I don't recall which one.

Blackdog: Will our offensive coordinator called a conservative game or let Duck open it up? Like using the wildcat again to break things open and keep the opposing defense on its back foot.

Steelers insider: If they're ever going to let Duck open it up it will be this week. Arizona is by far the worst team in the NFL defending the pass. I don't know if the Steelers can take advantage because Hodges is young and somewhat limited in his game, but it's not a very good defense.

Greg: Based on what we've now seen, in what round do you think Duck should have been drafted? He is outperforming some mighty highly chosen QBs (in a small sample size).

Steelers insider: You said it. Small sample size.

Advertise with us

iowasteelerfan: Duck = Team MVP if we make the playoffs?

Steelers insider: How about T.J. Watt? Or Minkah Fitzpatrick? Or Cam Heyward. Or... name another defensive player. I get your point, but this team is built around the defense.

NickFromVA: Has the offense turned a corner? The Browns have some good players on defense.

Steelers insider: I wouldn't say that. We saw some mistakes from Duck and some limitations in his game. I am encouraged by the development of the running game. I think that obviously can have a positive effect on the offense, but I'm not sold on this offense turning the corner.

Tom in Dallas: What happened to the chats last week? And there are no reporters names now on the online articles. When and why did this change? Feel like we lost the personal connection between reader and local reporter.

Advertise with us

Steelers insider: Our union is on a byline strike to call attention to some issues in our workplace. But we're still the same reporters and columnists supplying the same great content. Thanks for your continued support and reading our content. Our names will return to our copy at some point in the future.

Tom in Dallas: On the interception, did we ever find out if it was a bad throw, or the receiver ran the wrong route?

Steelers insider: Tomlin did not address that today, but if you watch the play Johnson stopped on the route. Duck threw it deep because he expected Johnson to keep running. Unfortunate mistake, but I blame the play call as much as I blame Johnson or Duck. Tomlin talked today about taking calculated risks to secure victory, but I think they could have been a little bit more conservative in that situation especially given that the Browns just kicked a field goal to get within seven points.

NickFromVA: Are the Steelers finally back to being a running team?

Steelers insider: Benny Snell has done a nice job of closing out games the past two weeks, but I'll be sold that this is a running team again when they can run the ball whenever they want. If you've watched the games closely, you know the offense really struggles early in games. The Steelers need to start running the ball better at all times.

Advertise with us

Franco: Terrell Edmunds- Has he been bad this year? or has he been solid staying quite and doing his job just not creating any turnovers?

Steelers insider: Yeah I would say he's been OK. You mentioned the turnovers. That's another area where he doesn't excel. I guess for a first-round pick I just want a player that does something extremely well. I don;t feel like Edmunds does anything extremely well. Is that fair?

Lee: Glad the “chats” are back!! What was the problem? Miss the quality coverage not found anywhere else!

Steelers insider: The quality coverage never went away. We continue to provide high quality content. Hope you enjoy everything we write as the Steelers try to secure a playoff spot over the next month.

pdxJaxon: The more this defense finally plays, I really don't think that we can afford to lose Bud Dupree- what % chance do we have now of paying the money needed to keep him?

Advertise with us

Steelers insider: It's going to be hard because he's going to command a lot of money on the open market. I suppose if they wanted to keep the momentum going with the defense they could place a tag on him, but that would be a steep price. They'd have to make some other moves to create cap space if they're going to do that. I can definitely think of a few areas of the team where they can cut salary, but then they'd be creating holes on the roster and they'd have to draft or sign someone as a free agent to replace them. It's going to be tough, but I guess we can worry about that when the season is over.

Too Tall Ball: Also, what self-respecting “Commentator” asks to not have his name shared because he is expressing opinions? This is all very weird.

Steelers insider: If you follow me on social media you'd know who I am. I promoted the return of the chat about an hour before it started.

NickFromVA: Do the Steelers hold onto that 6th playoff spot? Any chance they surpass

Steelers insider: If the Steelers make the playoffs I think they'll be the No. 6 seed. In order to catch the Bills, who are 9-3, I think Bills would have to lose out.

Advertise with us

Ken: Just wanted to say that I am very proud of the Steelers. Sunday's game could have been a slug fest with people hurt and penalties all around. Instead, they went the route of playing it for Pouncy. It was a positive way to play the game.

Steelers insider: I agree. They handled that situation very well. It was basically an elimination game, and they got a tough win when they were missing some key players.

NickFromVA: What happened to all the other chats?

Steelers insider: They're back.

Don: Tell me we can keep Hargreave and Dupree next year.

Advertise with us

Steelers insider: Going to be extremely tough to keep one of them let alone both.

Kevin: With the emergence of James Washington do you think the Steelers will run Juju out of the slot on 3 WR formations ?

Steelers insider: Good question. I do think they have some better options now that Washington has established himself as a dangerous player.

Pompeani Presley: Why do we still run the jumbo package with Holton as the one wide? Why not Washington or even Cain? They seem like they'd do a much better job drawing attention or making a play

Steelers insider: I agree with you. If Cain was out there instead I think the threat of a pass would be much more believable. And he could draw a safety out of the box with more effectiveness than Holton, who hasn't made a lot of plays. I guess Holton is a decent blocker, but boy the opposing defense knows the Steelers run 95% of the time out of that formation.

Advertise with us

Bob: Saw Dupree and Watt switched sides a few time against the Browns. Has this happen a lot and I just missed it? Seems like a good way to shake things up a little.

Steelers insider: Yeah I like it. It gives the tackles a different look in-game and it makes them prepare for different guys during the week.

Ryno: Do you see Rudolph regaining the starting job this season?

Steelers insider: Not if Duck keeps winning.

Alan: Do you think there’s a chance the Steelers look at RB in next year’s draft? I’d like to see them upgrade there and or on the OL.

Advertise with us

Steelers insider: I think they need a tone-setter at left guard more than an RB. A big run-blocker that can move and also pass protect. I wouldn't mind seeing an RB taken in the third round or after, but if it's me calling the shots I'm getting a nasty run blocker for the line. Then all your backs look better. Plus, I think Snell can be a good option for you. Maybe not a feature back but a guy that can play. Then you just need someone to complement him once Conner plays out the remainder of his rookie contract.

Kevin: If Big Al's play really is dropping off do the Steelers have an in house candidate who could compete for the LT job next year ?

Steelers insider: 2020 is the final year of his deal. The Steelers have Zach Banner and Chuks Okorafor on the roster as developmental tackles. I don't know if either is capable of being the starter next season. I think the hope was Okorafor would be that guy when they drafted him, but he's only dressed for one game this year. Usually when guys ascend to starting jobs for the Steelers they have roles the previous year. For instance, Feiler had been the swing tackle and guard and now he's a starter. I'm not saying Okorafor can't do that, but I think they'll let Villanueva play out the final year of his deal and then deal with who the starting left tackle will be in the spring and summer of 2021.

Turk in MD: If the Steelers don’t extend a 2nd contract to James Connor (a real possibility) is the next starting RB currently on the roster?

Steelers insider: Lots of teams go with a running back by committee approach. Why can't the Steelers? And yes they have guys on the roster who can be effective with a committee approach.

Advertise with us

Jack 58: So... at the end Hodges rookie gaff'd and stopped the clock by throwing it away... all while Washington was wide open on opposite side, downfield. I just get the feeling he knows it and will not do that again... I like him.

Steelers insider: I like him, too, but he can definitely improve his game by avoiding mental mistakes such as that one.

Oregon is Steeler Country: how many sacks does the D rack up this week ?

Steelers insider: I wouldn't necessarily be worried about sacks this week as much as containing Kyler Murray and making sure he doesn;t beat you with his legs.

chris: How can the reading public support the staff and writers?

Steelers insider: Please continue to subscribe and read!

Pompeani Presley: Should the team make a stronger effort to keep Hargrave this offseason?

Steelers insider: He's a really good player. In an ideal world you keep him. But if I'm deciding between Dupree and Hargrave I'm trying to keep Dupree because Tuitt is coming back next season, and you can always draft a nose tackle in the third or fourth round. There are no guarantees he'd develop into the player Hargrave is, but my point is Dupree would be much harder to replace. And yes I realize he'll make twice as much as Hargrave next year. I'm just talking about this from a football perspective.

Jack 58: Deion Sanders compared Ramon Foster, answering a question, at his locker, about Kitchens' childish t-shirt to a Hall of Fame acceptance speech, saying he's (Sanders) is with the coach & HoFers don't talk like that... Could Sanders be more clueless?

Steelers insider: I'm confused. I'm just glad I didn't catch what Sanders said because you;re right he's clueless.

Steve in NC: based on PIT, TEN, OAK, and IND remaining schedule, who do you see as taking the AFC 6th seed?

Steelers insider: So hard to say. If Oakland finds a way to beat the Titans this week I like their chances to finish strong. However, if the Titans win I think gives the Steelers a little bit more leeway because the Titans finish with the Texans (twice) and the Saints. I think the Titans would do well going 2-2 down the stretch. So, to sum up, I like the Steelers if they can take care of business. I just know it's going to be a close game every week given their QB situation, and I acknowledge it's going to be difficult to continue to win so many close games.

GSK: Do you believe that 9 and 7 for the Steelers secures a playoff berth?

Steelers insider: If the Steelers go 9-7 they'd have to sweat out a tiebreaker scenario or two to get in. I think 10-6 gets them in no matter what.

- TRUMP 2020 ! -: I saw/see something in 17 at WR... smooth, big, strong, confidence... His route running obviously but... Up to Finctner or Hodges to target him?

Steelers insider: I like him too. I thought he might get more snaps last week. Maybe they're just not comfortable with him knowing the playbook yet. When he does get a better understanding of the offense I think there is some potential there.

Ron U: What is your take on the pass interference penalty called on Bud Depree this past Sunday? I couldn't believe my eyes a penalty was called. Officials across the NFL have been horrible at best this year. Is the ref union on strike too?

Steelers insider: Terrible call. That referee was awful. He also called Duck for the false start.

mvandrews7: I keep seeing writers saying 9-7 gets us into the dance; do you agree?

Steelers insider: They can't say that with any certainty. Way too many scenarios where they'd lose out on tiebreakers depending on the opponent and which teams the Steelers lose to down the stretch.

mark p: bring James Conner back next year? lots of injuries but good when he is healthy

Steelers insider: Oh year I never said they'd cut him. I just don't think they'd sign him to second contract. I can see a scenario where Snell gets more carries and Conner is the guy in there on passing downs.

Mark: Good Morning, How would you rank this defense? Are they this good, or just better than some of the weaker opponents they have played? In other words, is this a championship caliber defense? Thank you.

Steelers insider: "Championship-caliber" might be going a bit far, but they're very good. I'd like to think the Steelers will be among the favorites in the AFC next season if Dupree somehow comes back. What's not to like about the team with a healthy Ben?

NC_Fan: Watching Edmunds in coverage, it seems like he never turns and looks for the ball, which results in either a PI call or a completion. This seems like something that could be fixed to take his game and the defense to the next level. Would you agree?

Steelers insider: Yes, like I mentioned, he's not strong in coverage. But they like him and I think the hope is he gets better with age.

VAsteelersFan: Is it time to look for a left tackle high in the draft?

Steelers insider: At some point in the next two years? Yes. But I don't know if it's this spring.

Scott: What happens when Conner comes back? Who gets more carries Snell or Conner?

Steelers insider: Tomlin indicated today that Snell has earned a bigger role. We'll have to wait and see what that means once Conner is healthy, but he's right. This offense is better when you have a RB that runs downhill and gains positive yards.

Elfonshelf: Any chance the team tries to get out of Tuitt contract since it seems he cannot stay on the field and is one of our highest paid players? More money to sign Bud/others?

Steelers insider: Don't think they'll make that move especially if Hargrave tests free agency and signs elsewhere.

Scott: Transition tag Dupree? I think we'll have a good chance to match offers, other quality FA edge rushers should drive his price down a bit.

Steelers insider: They definitely have some options with Bud. Those are nice to have when you want to retain a player in his prime.

Steelers insider: OK thanks for all the questions. It's nice to be back chatting Steelers with all of you again. Continue to subscribe and encourage others to do the same. Talk again next week.