Keith Butler knows a thing or two about great defenses. He’s been associated with a few during his 17 seasons as a Steelers assistant coach. The 2005 and 2008 Steelers won Super Bowls on the strength of the defense. The ’08 defense is considered one of the best in NFL history.

The defense Butler is coordinating this season is pretty special in its own right. The Steelers are a top-10 defense across the board (except for their 11th-ranked run defense). But what really makes this defense special is its ability to force turnovers.

The Steelers have produced 28 turnovers so far this season, a pace for 41 over 16 games. That would be the most in the NFL since the Bears forced 44 during the 2012 season.

That’s impressive, but it doesn’t come close to approaching the number of turnovers another Butler defense produced.

Advertise with us

Thirty five years ago, when Butler was a player for the Seattle Seahawks, he was on a defense that still has its named etched in the NFL record books.

In 1984, the Seahawks forced 63 turnovers. Sixty three!

It remains the most by a team since the 1970 NFL-AFL merger.

“Sometimes they just come in droves,” said Butler, a linebacker who started all 16 games that season. “They did for us that year.”

Chuck Knox was in his second year as Seahawks head coach. Tom Catlin was the defensive coordinator and switched from a 4-3 to a 3-4, which caused some issues for the other teams in the AFC West.

Advertise with us

But mostly it was about the players. The Seahawks had seven defenders that were named to the Pro Bowl in 1984, including one player that is enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Safety Kenny Easley was the NFL Defensive player of the Year in 1984. He had 10 interceptions and two touchdowns.

The starting defensive backfield of Easley, Dave Brown, John Harris and Keith Simpson combined for 28 of the team’s 38 interceptions. They returned six of them for touchdowns. They are the only team in NFL history with three players that scored multiple defensive touchdowns in the same season. The Seahawks also led the league with 25 fumble recoveries.

“We ended up being fourth in the league in defense,” said Butler, noting the Seahawks were more than just an opportunistic bunch. “We had some pretty good players.”

A different era

Defenses in the 1970s and 1980s took advantage of quarterbacks that weren’t under the thumb of micromanaging head coaches. The game was much different then.

Advertise with us

Quarterbacks, especially established ones such as Steelers great Terry Bradshaw, had carefree, go-for-broke mentalities. And it was clearly evident in Bradshaw’s statistics. In 1979, for instance, the Steelers turned the ball over 50 times during the regular season and eight more times in the postseason, including three in their Super Bowl victory against the Rams. Bradshaw threw three interceptions in the Super Bowl and the Steelers still won by 12 points, although they needed to score two touchdowns in the fourth quarter to do it.

Luckily for Bradshaw and the offense, the Steelers defense produced 42 turnovers of its own and six more in the playoffs to even the playing field. But that was barely notable then and nowhere near the franchise record for turnovers forced in a season.

During the 1973 season, the Steelers forced 54 during a 14-game regular season. Three years later, with a defense that is considered one of the best in NFL history, the Steelers produced 46, also during a 14-game season.

In today’s NFL, forcing 41 would be among the highest totals of the decade and more than twice as many as the Steelers forced in the past two seasons combined. The Steelers had just 15 forced turnovers last season and 22 in 2017.

“The turnover ratio statistic back then wasn’t really a big deal,” Butler said. “It wasn’t until the late ’80s when everyone started talking about it and thinking about it, realizing if you protect the ball better than the other team, then the likelihood of winning is pretty good.”

Advertise with us

Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin put an emphasis on producing more turnovers by drilling it in practice throughout the spring and summer and even into the regular season. Defensive backs are spending more time on the JUGS machine, and there are periods when defenders work at punching the ball and swiping it from the ball carrier.

But the Steelers’ thievery is also born out of necessity. It’s almost as if a switch was flipped the moment it was announced that quarterback Ben Roethlisberger was placed on season-ending injured reserve. The mindset of the defense changed because it had to.

“We have to get those turnovers,” defensive end Cam Heyward said. “It’s the way we have to play.”

The mindset has produced a competitive environment among the players.

“We preach it,” cornerback Joe Haden said. “Everyone thinks they’re going to be the one to make the play.”

Advertise with us

“We’re hungry,” outside linebacker Bud Dupree added. “We’re just trying to make plays. Ben’s gone so we have to pick up the slack for Ben. We’re playing young quarterbacks so we have to step up and make it that much easier for that side of the ball.”

It’s not just the defenders that speak so matter-of-factly about this. Offensive players openly acknowledge it, too.

Right guard David DeCastro said the Steelers have a good chance to win every week if all they do on offense is not commit a turnover. That’s how much he thinks of the defense.

And right now, that’s all the players on the defense believe they need.

“Each week we just have to figure out a way to win,” Haden said. “It might not be pretty. It might be ugly. But if we win an ugly game, it’s worth it. It doesn’t matter how we win. For the offense, just don’t turn the ball over, play a field position game. It’s complementary football.”

Advertise with us

There is one danger in all of this: becoming too dependent on turnovers to win games.

In games the Steelers have forced three or more turnovers, they are 4-2 with the losses coming to the 49ers and Ravens, two games they gave away with late turnovers by James Conner and JuJu Smith-Schuster.

When they have produced two or fewer turnovers, they are 2-3 with the only victories coming against the Bengals (twice). And they are 0-2 when they’ve failed to force a turnover in a game, including the 21-7 loss in Cleveland two weeks ago.

“We understand the situation we’re in defensively,” Butler said. “We have young quarterbacks and we’re playing guys who haven’t been starting running backs. We have to have turnovers to win football games. If you look at the last time we played the Browns, we didn’t play them that bad defensively. But what we didn’t do was get turnovers. And we only had one sack. That ended up getting us beat. The turnover ratio was minus-4.

“We think about that quite a bit. We coach that. We talk about ball awareness and getting the ball out. Plus, it’s a psychological deal for offenses if we do that.”