Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Let's get started.
lamberto: call it crazy but maybe just maybe the run game picks up with finney in there for the next 3 weeks??
Ray Fittipaldo: The run game has excelled when Finney has played in the past, but most of those starts have come at guard, not center. It's a different position.
Goldstar: With all the WR injuries and Switz on IR, I'm surprised they didn't bring in an experienced guy who knows the offense like Eli Rogers - any insight into why he wasn't brought back?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm guessing they think he's done. No one else has signed him either.
Tom88: Based on his play so far, do you feel Rudolph can be Ben's eventual replacement?
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: Too early to tell. Tough to evaluate him with no running game, with the young WRs learning on the job, etc. I know people want instant analysis, but I think we'd all be better off if we just let it play out.
Utah Jim: Is this the worst Steelers offense you have ever seen? Maybe it's a case of recency bias, but I can't pick worse one over the last 45 years of following them.
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, I did some research on that and... you'll have to wait until later in the week because I'm writing about that very subject. I don't want to scoop myself. But rest assured there have been offenses that have been worse than this one.
Steelers-Bengals: RB Benny Snell cleared to practice
thomastown: There’s been a lot of talk that Bud’s performance is increasing his price tag too high for the Steelers. Doesn’t the opposite also apply to Juju and Conner? Doesn’t their performance this year lower their expected price tag from what it might have been at the start of the year when they were both coming off Pro Bowl seasons? With at in ind,
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, it does with JuJu. If he had another great season he would have been in position to sign a huge second contract. I still think the Steelers want to sign him, but he won't command top dollar. I never really thought they were going to sign Conner to a second contract.
NM Steeler: Hi Ray, does Boswell have a strong enough leg to kickoff deep into or out of the end zone? If so, could someone ask Coach Tomlin about the ineffective short kickoffs?
Ray Fittipaldo: He does have the leg to kick into the end zone on most occasions. I know some of those short kicks are designed. I don't know how many, but many teams employ that strategy. They want to kick it high and short and let their players get down there so the returner doesn't get to the 25.
Ryan: If the Steelers dont make the playoffs do you think there will be any changes to any of the coordinators or staff? (Not Tomlin obviously) special teams coverage units have been poor and Fichtners playcalling leaves a lot to be desired (though I doubt he goes)
Ray Fittipaldo: I highly doubt they'd make a change at coordinator. I don't think they want to start over with a new coordinator when Ben only has a couple of years left. This is his offense and he likes Randy. I do think you'll see Art Rooney II come out and make a statement such as we have to run the ball more effectively, or something like that. He's said similar things in the past, and I think he'd be well-served to say it again. I don't care how good the Steelers are with Ben when he's healthy. You need a good running game, and the Steelers don't have one.
AllanbTN: What is the most important change the Steelers could make on offense this coming Sunday to be more successful (or less awful)?
Ray Fittipaldo: Benny Snell? He's been cleared to practice. At this point, what would it hurt to give him 20 carries? No thing else has worked.
Ryan: Ray I think RB needs to be a priority in the draft need to take one in round 2 or 3 imo. Conner cant stay healthy and Samuels is more of a pass catcher than true everydown RB. What say you?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think you might be onto something. They also should take an offensive lineman and maybe a WR with some of their early picks. This is supposed to be a great year for WRs. And we've seen what this offense looks like without Antonio Brown. If they can add another quality WR to the mix they should do it.
thomastown: Not sure if you saw it, but the “no pass interference” call on the pass to Hopkins in the Ravens game was totally ridiculous. Not sure if Riverton is still reviewing these, but don’t you think that person should be fired? Is there anything the owners can do to force Goodell doing something since they’re the ones ultimately responsible for this mess? It didn’t affect the final outcome of this game but if it continues, it likely will affect a significant game down the the road. Don’t they realize how much this makes them look like total fools?
Ray Fittipaldo: I saw it. It's been that way all season. Calls you think will get overturned don't. It's a mess. The NFL should make a change there, but I doubt they will.
Jack Splat: Ray, With this current line up on offense how many of the remaining games can they win? Has to be the least talented side of the ball since Ben took over. How do you see it? Thanks.
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, if JuJu and Diontae Johnson can make it back for the Cleveland game I think they can win that game. It's not like the Browns are a juggernaut. That was a one-score game in the fourth quarter until the bad INT by Rudolph that set up the Browns' third touchdown.
Matt P Venice FL: In 30 years following team, I do not ever recall us “poaching” anyone from other team’s practice squads, slight chance we found a Willie Parker (Whyte runs 4.3) and an Eli Rogers (Deon Cain)?
Ray Fittipaldo: It doesn't happen often, but it demonstrates the dire straits they are in right now with all the injuries.
Mike in Portland: Ray, I feel like last Thursday could be a turning point for Mason. Am I crazy to think that if he plays angry/with a chip after last weeks incident that he can turn a corner and lead this team on another win streak? Still waiting for it to "click".
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't necessarily correlate a QB playing angry to playing well. Can he use it as motivation? Sure. But I don't think getting too fired up for the next game is a good thing for a QB.
TXSteeler: Steelers worst in league on 3rd/4th & 1 (40% below league average, let alone the top). Has anyone bothered to ask Coach Tomlin or Fichtner about this?
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin was asked several questions about it today. He said they can do some things to help the line, but sometimes it's just a matter of winning the battle with the guy in front of you. And too often the Steelers haven't done that this season.
Mark from L.A.: Ray, I though the fact that Garrett hit MR late, and was continuing to lay on him, gave MR sufficient cause to try to remove him. And if that involved some grabbing at his helmet, so what? I think a fine on him is not warranted. It doesn't seem much attention is given to not only the late hit, but late hit and lay on you.
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you. He doesn't deserve to be fined. But the NFL apparently will.

Luke S: Why do You think thé offensive Line has performed so poorly This year?
Ray Fittipaldo: Great question. I think their collective age is showing. Some of those players simply are losing a step. It happens to everyone. I also think it's a line that was built to pass protect. The Steelers threw the ball more than any other team in the NFL last season. They planned to throw it as much this season until Ben got hurt. There are good pass protectors on this line, but I don't think there are very many good run blockers. I think they need to address that during the offseason.
DuckDynasty: Will the Duck get a fair shot at quarterbacking the Steelers if Rudolf does indeed gets a one game suspension ?
Ray Fittipaldo: Rudolph isn't getting suspended.
Steve in NC: Hi Ray, one of the most disturbing things i saw during the game (besides the weaponized helmet) was during the worst of all that fiasco, i saw Vance McDonald on the field just standing and watching about 10 yds away and then slowly meandering towards the PIT sideline, while most of PIT players were running in for support of their teammate. Changes my opinion of him ALOT. Wondering if you happened to notice that, and your take on McDonald's lack of action in this circumstance
Ray Fittipaldo: I'd have to go back and watch the video. I didn't notice that. I will say I want others doing what Maurkice Pouncey did if I'm coaching that team.
Lori: Ray we know the games have to be played and no game is easy .. however do you agree that Sunday is a most? Losing would mean season over realistically speaking .. losing to the worst team in the league..
Ray Fittipaldo: You're right. The Steelers probably don't recover if they lose that game.
Bob R: Ray, would it surprise you to see Garrett's suspension reduced on appeal? How about Pouncey's?
Ray Fittipaldo: They won't reduce Garrett's suspension. That's why it's indefinite. They want to punish him into next season. I'm not holding my breath on Pouncey getting his reduced. Maybe to two games, but that's it.
Mj: Has anyone asked Rudolph why he was clearly trying to rip
Ray Fittipaldo: Because Mylges Garrett tackled him to the ground for no reason. That's your answer. I don't even need to ask Rudolph.
Lenny from NY: Afternoon Ray. Once again the Steelers have third and one. MR is in shotgun and they don’t get the first down. Steelers call time out and then come out in shotgun again for fourth and one. Pass incomplete. Horrible. Who’s to blame? MR,MT, or RF? Offense is pathetic. The narrative that MR is young and inexperienced is getting old. There are a lot of young QB’s getting it done. Thanks for the chats.
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, first off, their refusal to use a QB sneak hurts them in those situations. But since Rudolph almost never operated under center in college I'm guessing that's why they don't do it. But they should. They should practice it because it could help their short-yardage efficiency. As for the other play calls, do you really have any confidence in this offensive line getting a push in those situations? They haven't done it all season, so I'm OK with the passing plays. How many times do you have to watch RBs get tackled in the backfield to drive the point home that the line is not very good in those situations?
Yinzer in Colorado: Thanks for the chat Ray. As a native of Jeannette, I find the Terrelle Pryor story interesting. Any indication the Steelers are interested?
Ray Fittipaldo: No.
PdxJaxon: Ray it seems we need our draft picks desperately to rebuild the offense (TE, WR, RB, OL). I dont see how we can afford to lose dupree and try also replacing him in the draft. Any chance we are able to resign him ?
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you. That would be ideal if you keep this defense intact. I'm not sure it can happen because I'm not sure Dupree will want to sign one with him being so close to unrestricted free agency. I also don't know if they can do it cap-wise.
Draft18: Ray, did Steelers miss a trick on 2018 draft by not drafting Lamar (see- Tomlin loved Mike Vick). Terell Edmunds was indeed a reach...it would have been a whole different story
Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah if you knew Ben would get hurt. But there is no way of knowing that. Ben wasn't happy when they used a third-round pick on Rudolph. How do you think he would have felt if they used a first-rounder on Lamar Jackson?
Brian in CA: Not a good game for Rudolph (even before the end), but AB and bell are gone, Conner, JJSS, and Diontae got knocked out, and OL played poorly. Yeah he missed some throws, but not sure Ben would have been much better. What say you?
Ray Fittipaldo: I tend to agree. There are a lot of things that play into his poor play. But I also know Ben's mere presence likely would open up more running lanes. Opposing defenses would be more threatened by the potential of throwing deep. So your point is well-taken, but Ben would certainly make a difference if he was healthy.
Jacque Strap: Wouldn't you think a WR is out there who is better than Johnny Holton? Sure he covers punts, but lots of guys can do that who can also catch.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think that's why they signed Deon Cain.
Tprod: Ray, why the sudden drastic decline in pass blocking prowess by the offensive line.
Ray Fittipaldo: No threat of a running game doesn't help them. But they're not playing well in any aspect. I think that's obvious. Before he did the unthinkable, Myles Garrett was working over Al Villanueva on almost every play. Other guys were losing one-on-one battles. It's not a good situation.
Franco: I haven't seen a Steelers Offense this bad in maybe my lifetime (31 yrs old) than I did Thursday night. Even with JUJU and JC healthy we just cant move the ball like we want and are a bottom 5 unit. Its a shame because this D is special. What is your opinion on what is needed to make the offense good enough to be contenders? coaching included in your opinions...
Ray Fittipaldo: When you have limited personnel like the Steelers do the coaches have to get creative and do some different things.
scrub: Why was the Johnson hit not discussed more. That kind of hit is what the NFL is trying to eliminate
Ray Fittipaldo: Exactly. But it's easy to understand why the Garrett play did overshadow that. It was a disgusting act by a talented player.
Bob: Skipper says he back. The deletes the tweet. Any idea on what is going on there?
Ray Fittipaldo: I have no idea. I saw the tweet too. Not sure why he would delete it.
Ray Fittipaldo: James Washington and Deon Cain. That's just a guess. Maybe Diontae Johnson gets out of protocol. That would be huge if he does.
Alan F: Starting WRs Week 12 are.....
Ray Fittipaldo: Question to previous answer.
Tprod: Ray, should the Steelers either started Finney or moved Feiler and not signed Foster?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes.
DB: Thanks very much for your article on Nov 17 regarding victim blaming, among other things. It is aggravating to read about so many people willing to back those who cause the problems. Hopefully, this will all go away soon. The Steelers have massive problems on offense - are they going to be able find enough decent RB's and WR's to compete in the next six games?
Ray Fittipaldo: Depends on your definition of decent.
John Strange: I have seen players grab each others face masks plenty of times while confronting/fighting each other. I have never seen a player rip off another player's helmet and try to bash his skull in with it. NEVER . Why does Rudolph get fined? Also, the coward Larry Ogunjobi runs up to a helmetless Rudolph with a sucker punch hit from behind and only gets one game? Imagine if he laid that sucker punch hit from behind on Brady. I am more incensed about that cowardly hit than Garrett's. What say you?
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you. Ogunjobi will have a target on his back on Dec. 1.
Jason : Ray, Do you think JUJU is a true No 1 receiver? Seems best in the slot with true No 1 outside like AB. How do you see it? Thank you.
Ray Fittipaldo: Hard to say with all of the extenuating circumstances, Ben's injury, etc. But the stats don't lie.
Mj: Is masons leash starting to shorten?
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin said today they like Mason. He believes he earned this job. But he also said Mason has to continue to prove that every week.
AK: What’s your take in the people who blame Rudolph for the melee at the end if the game?
Ray Fittipaldo: They're knuckleheads.
JerseySteel: Hi Ray - is Tuzar Skipper coming back? Saw on Twitter that he was, but it is Twitter after all
Ray Fittipaldo: Steelers haven't announced it yet. But they still could.
rman: Has there been any specifics on the exact injury to Ben's arm? Any specifics on his rehab schedule?
Ray Fittipaldo: Ben told the P-G's Ron Cook about a week ago that he expects to be ready for OTAs or minicamp. OTAs are in May. Minicamp in June.
Greg: At this point, would you agree that the Steelers need to have Juju play out his contract next year before signing him to an extension? I know the they typically like to lock guys up going into the final year but if Juju has another down year it could be catastrophic to overpay a WR.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they'll try to sign him. We'll see if he accepts. I don't think they're going to offer him Deandre Hopkins or AJ Green type of money.
AK: It seems to me that if Dupree leaves, which is likely, that the Steelers #1 priority would be OLB. Do you agree?
Ray Fittipaldo: It would be a priority, but RB, OL, TE and WR are top priorities too. They can't waste whatever talent Ben has left by surrounding him with players with diminishing skills. They have to do something about the talent on the offensive side of the ball, too.
Bill : I believe vananimal is a more get in the way type blocker not like Heath Miller who would drive players away. I think they need to draft a tightend fairly high in the draft because l also think this would help the running game. Not a fan of vananimal.
Ray Fittipaldo: It's hard to find great blocking tight ends anymore. They're all glorified slot WR coming out of the college game. But I agree with you. An old-school Heath Miller-type would bolster the running game. But where do you find players like that anymore?
Lipps: If Ju Ju and Johnson can’t go, could this be the worst (or maybe just least experienced) WR group we have ever trotted our for a game?
Ray Fittipaldo: It would rank right up there.
Greg: Steelers finally bringing in more of a scat back in Whyte. Do you get the feeling that Samuels is now playing for his spot on the team next year? With Juju and Snell, it seems that we need more of a scat back rather than another big body in Samuels, who lacks elusiveness.
Ray Fittipaldo: We'll see what White has. He wasn't even on a 53-man roster. I know they liked him in the predraft process, but let's not anoint him just yet. I am surprised Samuels hasn't been more effective. It might have something to do with the play of the line. No RBs are lighting it up, you might have noticed.
Scott: Utah Jim, I believe the offense of Joe Walton in the late 80's was worse.
Guest: If the team makes the playoffs, will the beat writers be advocating for Tomlin to win Coach of the Year?
Ray Fittipaldo: He might have his name mentioned, but have you heard of this guy Kyle Shanahan? Or John Harbaugh?
Bill in SF: When Nixed returned from his first injury, all the coaches and players talked about how important he is to the running game and the offense. Given that, why do the Steelers only carry one player on the roster who can play that position?
Ray Fittipaldo: Some coaches might consider one FB on the 53-man roster a luxury. Now maybe they should have one on the practice squad. That's not a terrible idea. Then again -- and I've mentioned this in the past -- it's not like the colleges are producing a lot of quality FBs.
so no Kap questions answered?: Why is PIT sports ecosystem determined to assume Duck is the best QB option when a very serviceable Kaepernick is available? Vick wasn't a problem for the Rooneys, why is being outspoken on social justice issue disqualifying for Pittsburgh?
Ray Fittipaldo: Kapernick doesn't want to play. Did you see how he handled that situation on Saturday? His team changed the venue an hour or so before the scheduled workout. I don't know what the end-game is for him. Even he doesn't seem to know.
mrbig: I keep hearing about a kick to Garrett's groin... I don't see it, did you?
Ray Fittipaldo: No. I watched the video. He was yanked to his feet by Garrett. Of course his legs are going to react. There was no kick.
biG fisH: Troy Aikman described MR as heavy legged, do you agree?
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, he's certainly not fleet of foot.
JR: Ray, what is your assessment of Devin Bush so far? Worth trading up for? What do you see as his ceiling; could he be a perennial All Pro?
Ray Fittipaldo: He hasn't been as noticeable as he was in the Chargers game. I think a lot of it has to do with some of his struggles in pass defense. Teams can get him in mismatches. And he's missed some assignments. It happens with a young LB. I'll be concerned if it happens next season. I think everyone knew there would be some growing pains this year when he was a rookie.
Alaska Steeler: I'm not bashing Rudolph, but if I college prospect can't play under center, why is he considered a top draft pick? Kinda like saying Player X is a great hitter, but he can't hit the curve or the fast ball.
Ray Fittipaldo: Hardly any of these QBs that come into the league now play under center in college.
Will: Why are the Steelers so repellent to the idea of considering Kap. He'd be an immediate improvement over MR. Is it because Ben is so active with supporting Police dogs (serious question)?
Ray Fittipaldo: Good Lord. The guy hasn't played football in three years. And you think he's better than Mason Rudolph right now?
Jack Lambert's tooth: Any of these recently signed guys going to get a helmet on Sunday?
Ray Fittipaldo: We'll find out, but Cain and White were signed to the 53-man roster. They'll probably dress and have a role if JuJu, Johnson and Conner don't play.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK thanks for all the great questions this week. We'll do it again after the Bengals game.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.