The Steelers offense hasn’t exactly been a juggernaut, and that’s not a surprise given that Ben Roethlisberger went down with a season-ending shoulder injury at halftime of the second game.

The Steelers offense started the season behind the eight ball anyway as they looked to replace the production of Antonio Brown. And that much was made clear by the fact that they managed to score only three points in their opener against the Patriots.

But the Steelers seemed to find a winning a formula with Mason Rudolph at quarterback. The offense wasn’t high-powered, but it was effective and Rudolph did two things that winning quarterbacks do — he didn’t turn the ball over, and he made enough big plays at key times to move the ball and score points.

The Steelers had won four in a row, and while the team was led by the defense, the offense had a big hand in every one of those wins. In the first six games after Roethlisberger went down, the Steelers scored 20 or more points every game. They scored only 17 in a win against the Rams but should have scored more, as Rudolph played his best game and his receivers let him down with too many dropped passes.

Advertise with us

Then came the Browns game last Thursday, when the floor finally fell out from beneath the offense and Rudolph. The Steelers scored only seven points and their performance was every bit as bad as it sounds. And Rudolph was terrible, as he threw four interceptions and was missing open receivers all night long.

“We like Mason, we like what he does,” Mike Tomlin said Tuesday at his weekly news conference. “He earned the position he holds now [and] he will continually earn that through his play. He didn’t do a good enough job of taking care of the football though, and he knows that. And anybody who occupies that role for us, Job 1 is preservation of football.”

It would be nice to chalk that up as a bad night at the office for Rudolph and the Steelers, and I do believe he can get better as he continues to gain experience and get more comfortable in the offense. Rudolph has to play better if the Steelers are going to have any chance, but it isn’t that simple any more.

That’s because the Browns game wasn’t just a bad loss. It was a costly one. The Steelers lost receivers JuJu Smith-Schuster and Diontae Johnson to concussions, and Tomlin said both are still in the protocol. That means they may not be available Sunday against the Bengals. Center Maurkice Pouncey is out for three games because he was suspended for his role in the brawl at the end of the game. Running back James Conner re-injured his shoulder and is questionable for Sunday, too.

The Steelers have spent the week signing practice squad players and little-known free agents to fill the voids. The receiving corps without Johnson and Smith-Schuster is basically James Washington and a bunch of misfit parts. The offensive line has had to be patched together, and while Benny Snell, Jaylen Samuels and Trey Edmunds have some ability to make plays, none are capable of carrying the load as an every down back.

Advertise with us

This is now an offensive unit that has far bigger holes and deficiencies than just the quarterback. This is an offensive line and a group of skill position players that even the best quarterbacks would have a hard time having success with. There just aren’t enough playmakers, and the offensive line isn’t playing well enough and Rudolph isn’t good enough yet to hide some of those deficiencies.

Given all of that, the Steelers defense is going to have to carry the load even more than it has. There simply is no way the Steelers can win games without the defense creating short fields and turning the ball over. The offense can make some plays here and there, but it is not going to be able to sustain enough drives to score enough points to win without the help of the defense.

That doesn’t mean the offense can’t have some moments, but the NFL is a league of talent and stars and the Steelers just don’t have enough of either on the offensive side of the ball. In fact, if Smith-Schuster and Johnson are out, there is a strong case that they don’t even have enough NFL-level talent on that side of the ball.

That, combined with a first-year starter at quarterback who has struggled with consistency, is a recipe for an incredibly ineffective offense. That doesn’t mean the Steelers can’t win games, though; it means they will have to win in a different way. It means they will need to lean more on their defense and kicker Chris Boswell, and it means that they will need maximize the few scoring opportunities that will come their way.