The Indianapolis Colts lost their franchise quarterback two weeks before the regular season when Andrew Luck unexpectedly retired. The news was leaked during a Colts preseason game, and a general sense of doom enveloped Lucas Oil Stadium. Fans booed Luck as he walked off the field as they imagined what life would be like without a top-line quarterback.

Well, Colts fans are getting a taste of what life is like without Luck, and they’re enjoying the flavor of first place in the AFC South at the halfway point of the season. They’re 5-2 and the No. 2 seed in the AFC behind the Patriots as they get set to visit the Steelers Sunday afternoon at Heinz Field.

When the schedule came out in April, this was supposed to be one of the NFL’s marquee matchups for Week 9: Luck vs. Ben Roethlisberger. Two of the game’s best quarterbacks squaring off in a possible playoff preview.

But Luck’s retirement and Roethlisberger’s elbow injury set the stage for Mason Rudolph vs. Jacoby Brissett. Other injuries and natural turnover in the league’s quarterbacks are giving NFL fans more of these young quarterback matchups.

Advertise with us

Through the first eight weeks, 99 of the 121 games have featured at least one starting quarterback under the age of 27, the most at this point in a season in league history. The young quarterbacks have 130 total starts and 69 wins, both highs for the league through eight weeks since the merger.

It might not have been planned for the Colts, but they were prepared to compete whether or not Luck was their quarterback. How general manager Chris Ballard built his team is something the Steelers can study as they make preparations in the coming months and years for life without Roethlisberger.

Planning ahead

Upon his arrival in 2017, Ballard knew Luck battled through injuries the previous two seasons, so he was proactive in searching for a quality quarterback to play behind Luck. Before that season began, Ballard pulled the trigger on a trade with the Patriots and landed Brissett, a third-round pick out of North Carolina State.

Roethlisberger did not have a serious injury history before this season, but Steelers GM Kevin Colbert also was proactive when in acquiring another quality quarterback last year when he traded up in the draft in the third round and selected Rudolph.

Advertise with us

Colbert did not know when, or even if, Rudolph would start for the Steelers, but he’s getting a big opportunity to prove to Colbert and the Steelers that he can be a full-time starter once the 37-year old Roethlisberger does retire.

It’s an opportunity Brissett got in 2017. Luck could not recover from a neck injury and Brissett started 15 of the Colts’ 16 games that season. The Colts went 4-12, but by playing an entire season Brissett gained valuable experience that prepared him to take over for Luck this season.

Andrew Luck retired just before the start of the 2019 season. (Andy Lyons / Getty Images)

“It starts with the fact that having a great GM who had the foresight to trade for Jacoby while Andrew was still here,” Colts coach Frank Reich said last week. “I really think Chris deserves a lot of credit for that and getting him here. What he thought and what I found out when I got here is, ‘Hey, this guy is a top-notch level quarterback.’ I think that’s a credit to Chris and his staff to make that move a couple of years ago.”

Brissett hardly put up impressive statistics in his first season as an NFL starter. He completed just 59% of his passes and threw 13 touchdowns and 7 interceptions. The Colts at one point in the season lost nine in a 10-game stretch.

The Steelers can identify with the struggles of a young quarterback experiencing the NFL on a full-time basis for the first time. They are 2-2 with Rudolph as their starter, but there have been plenty of ups and downs, not only from game to game but half to half and quarter to quarter.

Advertise with us

That was on full display in Monday’s victory against the Dolphins. Rudolph played terribly for most of the first half after he suffered a concussion three weeks earlier against the Ravens. But he eventually settled down, threw for 255 yards and two touchdowns as the Steelers erased an early deficit and won, 27-14.

“He’s been put in some unique circumstances already,” Steelers offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner said. “He made his first start on the road in a hostile environment versus probably one of the top two defenses in the league. He’s had to battle injury and come back. That’s a whole other aspect that you never really know about until you coach a guy and you see how they attack. I understand the concussion protocol is what it is. You never know how someone will respond after an injury. Quite honestly, I was expecting a little more early in that football game, but it makes sense. He grew through it, and I was proud of him for that.”

It’s obvious Brissett grew from his early trials and tribulations. This season he is completing 64.5% of his passes with 14 touchdowns and only three interceptions.

“He doesn’t make dumb mistakes,” Steelers defensive coordinator Keith Butler said. “He’s done a good job of not taking too many chances, maybe tucking the ball and running. But he doesn’t want to run. He wants to throw the ball down the field. He wants to go through his reads and what his coaches want him to do.”

He’s also finding ways to win close games. Last week, he only completed 15 passes against the Broncos, but he led the winning drive that culminated with an Adam Vinatieri 51-yard field goal with 22 seconds remaining.

Advertise with us

It’s been a theme with the Colts this season. Every one of their seven games has been decided by seven points or fewer. Four of them have been decided by three points or fewer.

“The good thing for Jacoby is he got the experience of basically playing an entire season,” Reich said. “And now what’s different for Jacoby is no one looks at Jacoby as a backup who is filling in for a guy. This is Jacoby’s team. When Andrew went down, he stepped in as the No. 1 guy. His mindset is appropriately different than it is as a backup when you know you’re going in and filling your role, doing the best you can, but knowing someone else is stepping [back] in. Jacoby has transitioned to that very well because of his maturity and his leadership ability.”

Brissett was the fifth quarterback taken in 2016 after Jared Goff, Carson Wentz, Paxton Lynch and Christian Hackenberg.

Hackenberg never played a down in the NFL and is out of the league. Lynch was out of the league all last season and for the first two weeks of this season before the Steelers signed him to be their third quarterback.

All of which proves evaluating quarterbacks is an inexact science.

Advertise with us

Steelers-Colts preview with Gerry Dulac and Ray Fittipaldo

How to build a better team

For years under former general manager Ryan Grigson, the Colts neglected their offensive line. He was GM from 2012-16, and he didn’t draft an offensive lineman in the first round until his final season in charge of personnel. Of the six offensive linemen he drafted before that, none signed second contracts with the Colts.

Ballard and head coach Reich have invested heavily in the line since arriving. The Colts now have three first-round picks starting on their line along with a second-round pick.

Guard Quenton Nelson arrived in the first round last year along with another guard, Braden Smith, in the second round. Nelson was named All-Pro as a rookie last season, a rare feat for an offensive lineman. Center Ryan Kelly was a first-round pick in 2016 and left tackle Anthony Constanzo in 2011.

The Colts are 11th in the league in rushing, averaging 128 yards per game.

Advertise with us

“It was really great when I got here for Chris Ballard and I to sit down and talk philosophically about what we wanted this team to look like,” said Reich, the former offensive coordinator in Philadelphia who won a Super Bowl with the Eagles with a similarly built offense. “My thoughts and Chris’ thoughts were perfectly lined up. We wanted to build this thing from the inside out starting with the offensive line and the defensive line. That wasn’t just talk. We put it into action and we will continue to build that way.”

The Steelers should take notice of how Ballard built the Colts. Colbert has invested heavily in his offensive line in the past. Maurkice Pouncey and David DeCastro were first-round picks in 2010 and 2012. Both signed second lucrative contracts, and Pouncey recently signed a third that kept him among the league’s highest-paid centers.

But four of the Steelers’ five starters on the line are 29 or older, and there have been signs of the veterans not being as dominant as they once had been. The pass protection remains strong, but their run-blocking has left a lot to be desired going back to the middle of last season.

The Steelers snapped an eight-game streak without one of their running backs rushing for 100 yards in a game last week when James Conner finally went over the century mark. They have produced just three 100-yard running games by a running back in their past 16 games. They are 8-8 in those games.

Colts running back Marlon Mack has five games with 100 yards or more in the past 16 games for the Colts. They are 13-3 in those games.

Advertise with us

Establishing a strong running game with a young quarterback is paramount, but the Steelers should start drafting some offensive linemen high in the draft the next few years even with Roethlisberger expected to make a full recovery from elbow surgery.

Older quarterbacks can benefit from strong running games, too. Just ask Tom Brady, who in February won his sixth Super Bowl not behind a prolific passing attack but a powerful running game.

The days of one-dimensional passing offenses terrorizing the league appear to be over. More and more, teams are winning with balanced offenses, many of them with young quarterbacks.

The Colts aren’t asking Brissett to throw for 300 yards every game. They’re simply asking him not to make too many mistakes, and to make a big play or two when the opportunity arises.

“He’s a dangerous guy because they have a great running attack,” Butler said. “If you have a great running attack the play-action is a lot more hurtful and difficult to defend. Guys get up on the line of scrimmage too much to try to defend the run. It’s going to be a chore for us.”

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.