Steelers-Colts preview with Gerry Dulac and Ray Fittipaldo

Mason Rudolph became the first quarterback in NFL history to get his first two wins on a Monday night. He led the Steelers by the Cincinnati Bengals Sept. 30 and the Miami Dolphins Oct. 28.

Rudolph’s next challenge is to beat a team that actually has, you know, won a game. The Bengals are 0-8, the Dolphins 0-7.

What exactly do the Steelers have with Rudolph?

Is he a big-time quarterback capable of adding to the franchise’s collection of Lombardi Trophies after Ben Roethlisberger is gone? Or is he just another warm body, as so many of the Steelers quarterbacks were between Terry Bradshaw and Roethlisberger?

Advertise with us

I’m not smart enough to figure that one out. Not yet, anyway. It’s too soon to tell.

But we should know a little more about Rudolph by late Sunday afternoon after the Steelers’ Heinz Field hair-pull with the 5-2 Indianapolis Colts. It will be his fifth NFL start. It is hard enough for any young quarterback to find his way playing the toughest position in all of sports. It is much tougher when he has to take over a veteran team that is used to its Hall of Fame quarterback. Rudolph was the next man up after Roethlisberger went down and out with an elbow injury in the second game.

There has been a lot to like and a lot not to like with Rudolph since then. We saw him at his worst and his best against the Dolphins. The worst was so bad for most of the first half that the Heinz Field crowd let Rudolph and the Steelers offense have it. “I would have booed that performance, too,” Rudolph said. But the best was, well, pretty good. Rudolph threw two touchdown passes to lift his team out of a 14-0 hole and avoid what would have been one of the worst losses in franchise history.

“I think anybody [who] lacks experience, there’s potential for struggle,” Mike Tomlin said the day after the game. “So how do you gain experience but through play? Particularly at the quarterback position, you don’t get to the position that he’s in unless you’re capable of smiling in the face of adversity. Often times, guys are defined by how they handle success. I think handling failure and adversity is a natural thing for guys that make it to this level …

“We’ve got a lot of confidence in him. We didn’t need to see that. We’ve been working with him now going on a couple of years. That’s just kind of his DNA. That’s one of the reasons why the guys rally behind him and believe in him.”

Advertise with us

Teammates have raved about Rudolph’s work ethic. His receivers have talked about how he’s always studying game film and how he will text them at all hours with an observation or a suggestion to make the passing game better. But it still comes down to execution on the field. That’s why Rudolph needed that in-game resurrection against the Dolphins. Needed it badly, actually. It should serve him well against the Colts and beyond.

“Everybody is going to have bad days and bad games,” Al Villanueva said late Monday night. “Tonight, it was a great challenge for Mason to be in that situation. He passed that test.”

Late in the second quarter, Rudolph had completed just 3 of his 9 passes for 23 yards. He had thrown an interception on his first pass and fumbled after taking a sack on his third series. His passer rating was 0.0. His wide receivers didn’t have a catch.

But then Rudolph made a sideline throw to Diontae Johnson for 12 yards on third-and-11 from his 5. The play didn’t just turn the game the Steelers’ way. It felt like it turned Rudolph’s season in the right direction.

“He made a play that presented itself,” offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner said Thursday. “He read it perfectly. We had perfect protection. The route was perfect. He put it in the perfect spot. He put a perfect ball on him.”

Advertise with us

Counting that connection, Rudolph completed 17 of his final 27 passes for 228 yards and the two touchdowns. He finished with a passer rating of 84.4 that, while not Roethlisberger-like, was a long way from 0.0.

“He did a phenomenal job staying poised,” Villanueva said. “He didn’t blink.”

Rudolph’s throw to Johnson on that big third down might have been perfect, but his game, even at his best, was not. Fichtner pointed out he took two unnecessary sacks. He also had Johnson and James Washington open deep on consecutive plays in the fourth quarter and overthrew them.

But even Rudolph’s misfires on those plays were encouraging to a point. Fichtner had been criticized earlier in the season for being too conservative with Rudolph, too hesitant to allow him to throw the ball downfield. But there were times when deep plays were there and Rudolph didn’t see them or was afraid to take a chance. Against the Dolphins, he said the plan was to be “more aggressive as an offense.” He certainly didn’t hesitate with his deep balls. He lost a 34-yard pass to Johnson when Johnson was called for pass interference. He also took four deep shots with JuJu Smith-Schuster, resulting in a 34-yard gain, a 26-yard touchdown and a 25-yard pass interference penalty on the Dolphins.

“I think he’s a great player,” Rudolph said of Smith-Schuster. “You have to feed him no matter what. He’s proven to do be a force down the field in those combat-catch situations.”

Advertise with us

It’s going to be fun to see how Rudolph does against the Colts, perhaps the Steelers’ most difficult opponent since San Francisco in Week 3. Even if they lose and take another, perhaps fatal blow to their playoff chances, it’s going to be interesting to watch how Rudolph develops during the rest of the season.

Not much is at stake, right?

Just the Steelers’ immediate future after Roethlisberger.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.