Steelers-Dolphins preview with Gerry Dulac and Ray Fittipaldo

This decade will end in two months, and at no other point in NFL history has offensive football been so prolific. Six of the top-10 scoring seasons in league history have happened since 2012, and the 2019 season is trending toward that status.

A generation stocked with future Hall of Fame quarterbacks -—including current greats Tom Brady, Drew Brees and Ben Roethlisberger — ushered in the new era. Spread offenses are the norm as coaches try to take advantage of the rules that favor offense.

All of which is why it’s hard to explain what’s happening in New England and San Francisco this year. The Patriots and 49ers are putting up defensive statistics that rival any of the great defenses in NFL history in an era when it’s not supposed to happen.

The Patriots and 49ers were the lone remaining undefeated teams after Week 8 victories, and they’re winning with defense.

Advertise with us

In their 9-0 victory in Washington last week, the 49ers held the Redskins to 154 yards. They are the sixth team since 1990 and the first since the 2005 Patriots to allow seven or fewer points and 200 or fewer yards of offense in three consecutive games.

For the season going into Week 8, the 49ers were allowing 10.7 points and 223.5 yards per game. In most seasons, that would far and away be the best totals in the league.

But the Patriots are even better. They were allowing 6.9 points and 223.1 yards per game. They recorded their second shutout of the season last week against the Jets and have not allowed any of their first eight opponents to score more than 14 points in a game.

The Patriots still have to play eight more games and the 49ers nine, but it’s worth putting their numbers into perspective.

• The 1976 Steelers gave up 9.9 points per game. They also posted four shutouts.

Advertise with us

• The 2000 Ravens gave up 10.3 points per game, posted four shutouts and didn’t allow any of their four playoff opponents to score more than 13 points in a game.

• The 2002 Tampa Bay Buccaneers gave up 12.3 points per game and posted two shutouts.

• The 1985 Chicago Bears gave up 12.4 points per game, posted two shutouts during the regular season and two more in the playoffs.

• The 2008 Steelers allowed 13.9 points per game. They held eight opponents to 10 points or fewer, including one shutout.

All are in the discussion for the best defense of all time, and any NFL historian has them in their top 10.

Advertise with us

The 49ers and Patriots have a chance to put up better numbers and do it in an era that favors offenses.

“Football hasn’t changed,” said Anthony “Booger” McFarland, a defensive lineman on the 2002 Buccaneers defense. “To be a great defense you have to be able to affect the quarterback. New England does that and San Francisco does that. But they do it in different ways. San Francisco is a 4-3 team that plays zone. New England is a 3-4 team that plays a ton of man.

“To be a dominant defense one part of your defense has to be dominant. For the Patriots, it’s their secondary. For the 49ers, it’s their defensive line. They’ve invested a lot of first-round picks in defensive linemen. But to be a great defense in any era you have to be able to affect the quarterback, and they both do that very well.”

Going into Week 8, the Patriots were second in the league with 26 sacks and the 49ers were tied for fourth with 20.

Start of a transformation

Advertise with us

The 2019 Steelers defense isn’t close to being considered a dominant defense, but there are signs that the team’s identity is quickly changing in real time. Roethlisberger’s injury might have sped things up, but the offense was among the league’s worst in almost every statistical category entering Week 8. This comes after five years of being among the league’s top offenses.

The young defense, meanwhile, is on the rise. After allowing an average of 27.6 points and 442 yards per game in the first three games of the season against the Patriots, Seahawks and 49ers, the Steelers have almost cut in half their point and yardage totals in the past three games.

They are giving up 15.3 points and 266 yards per game in their past three outings. They’re also getting turnovers — a lot of them. The Steelers have forced 13 of their 15 turnovers in the past four games and are second in the league in takeaways. They’re also among the best in the league at pressuring the quarterback. Along with the 49ers and a few other teams, they also had 20 sacks entering Week 8.

The Steelers already have many of the qualities needed to be a great defense. So can they someday become a dominant unit again?

“I hope so,” said Steelers defensive coordinator Keith Butler, who has been on staff since 2002 and was linebackers coach for the 2008 defense. “I am not ready to say just yet. We had some good defenses back then. We went to three Super Bowls and won two of them. The outside linebackers were good players. The inside linebackers were good. We had good defensive linemen. We had a good defense, a real good defense. Are we at that stage? No, but I am hoping we get there.”

Advertise with us

McFarland, for one, believes the pieces are in place.

“I think they can,” said McFarland, color analyst on the ESPN “Monday Night Football” crew that will call the Steelers-Dolphins game. “They have a ton of talent. They have T.J. Watt. They have Devin Bush. They have Minkah Fitzpatrick. The big question for me is, can they cover?”

That’s a luxury New England has with shutdown cornerback Stephon Gilmore. The Patriots pass defense is doing things that have never been done before in the history of the NFL. They had 18 interceptions and only one touchdown pass allowed through seven games. They’re giving up an average of just 148 passing yards per game (second in the league behind the 49ers). Three of their first seven opponents didn’t crack 100 yards passing.

“Their defense is a collective effort, but what Gilmore gives them is he allows for a lot of flexibility,” said Steelers veteran linebacker Mark Barron, who played against the Patriots in the Super Bowl when he was with the Rams and again in this year’s opener. “They can do a lot of things. They can put extra players here and send extra players there because they know Gilmore has this and they don’t have to worry about him. They can blitz or do whatever. Having a player like that on the edge gives you a lot of flexibility.”

Barron always pays close attention to the Patriots defense when he has a chance to watch them. He played in a similar defense when he was a college player at Alabama. Crimson Tide coach Nick Saban coached under Bill Belichick when he was the head coach in Cleveland in the 1990s and remains close to him.

Advertise with us

“I love watching great defenses,” Barron said. “I always pay attention to the Patriots because of the similarities to the defense that I played in college at ’Bama. Schematically, it’s a lot of the same stuff because of the relationship between Saban and Belichick.

“It’s some schematics and being smart and knowing how to use your players, but there’s also a lot of accountability for the players as far as doing your job and everyone being where you’re supposed to when you’re supposed to be there, and doing it consistently.

“Everybody having that level of trust in each other is the key. You have to know your teammate will be where they’re supposed to be. I’m going to be where I need to be. He’s going to be where he needs to be. So there’s a trust. It’s like a puzzle. Everything comes together, and it’s hard to find cracks in that puzzle.”

Belichick doesn’t need great players for his defense to succeed. He needs players with enough talent who are smart, dependable and can carry out their assignments on a consistent basis. He routinely cuts Pro Bowl players because they freelance too much or aren’t committed to doing things his way. He did it again last week when he traded three-time Pro Bowl defensive end Michael Bennett, whom he acquired over the offseason.

Belichick won’t replace Bennett with a more talented player, but no one is predicting the demise of the defense, either. He’ll simply plug in another player, and he won’t expect a drop-off in play.

Advertise with us

Why there is so much hope for the Steelers is their stable of young stars. They have impact players at every level of the defense on their rookie contracts. Watt, who is one of the best outside linebackers in the league, is in his third season. Fitzpatrick, a second-year safety who was acquired in a trade with Miami in the third week of the season, is the playmaker the Steelers coveted for the back end of their defense. And Bush, the No. 10 overall pick in this year’s draft, has quickly proven to be a turnover machine in the middle.

It might not happen overnight, but the Steelers have a young defensive core that figures only to get better with time.

“We can definitely be that,” Barron said. “That’s our competition so I don’t want to use the Patriots as a measuring stick, but they are doing a great job defensively right now. A lot of those guys have been together for a while now. I know they bring some guys in and rotate people through. But the core of that defense has been together. Their communicators have been together. The way they want to get things done, their standard is already set.”

The good news for the Steelers is they might not have to wait long. The 49ers were 13th in total defense and 28th in scoring defense last season and the Patriots were 21st and seventh.

Does competition matter?

Advertise with us

When the 1976 Steelers or the 1985 Bears come up in conversation about the best defenses of all time, the competition each team faced rarely comes up.

The statistics and accomplishments stand on their own. All of the aforementioned great defenses, except for the 1976 Steelers, won the Super Bowl. Not only will the Patriots and 49ers have to keep up their dominance over another half season, but they’ll likely have to close the deal and raise the Lombardi Trophy to be considered for all-time greatness.

But it’s worth pointing out that the Patriots have played just one team with a winning record so far — a Buffalo team that has been the surprise of the AFC early in the season. Others on their schedule in the first half of the season included the Steelers, Jets (twice), Dolphins, Redskins, Giants and Browns. The combined record of their opponents was 12-33 (before Week 8).

That’s not exactly a murderer’s row of the NFL’s elite.

The 49ers also played just one team with a winning record. The combined record of their opponents was 11-26.

Advertise with us

“It’s not who you play, but it’s how you play,” McFarland said. “So if you’re playing an inferior opponent, are you dominating them? The Patriots are doing that. I think all that stuff about the records of the opponents is for writers and the media. This is the NFL. Everyone is getting paid.”

To McFarland’s point, the Patriots have outscored their opponents by 175 points this season. According to the Elias Sports Bureau, it’s the second-largest point differential after seven games in NFL history. Only the 1920 Buffalo All-Americans had a better differential after seven games.

The schedule does get a bit tougher for the Patriots over the final eight games, but there is talk of the possibility of going 16-0. After defeating the Browns Sunday, the Patriots have three of their next four on the road against the Ravens, Eagles, Cowboys and Texans. They finish with the Chiefs, Bills, Bengals and Dolphins.

With the winless Bengals and Dolphins at the back end of the schedule, the Patriots could have a legitimate shot at setting NFL records for fewest points per game in a 16-game season, fewest touchdowns and fewest yards allowed.

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo @post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.

Advertise with us