It’s become cliche to downplay the Steelers’ slow start by pointing to the mediocrity of the AFC North as possible salvation. We’re only in Week 7 and you’ve probably heard the phrase “anything can happen in this division” enough times to fill one of the world’s few remaining classroom chalkboards.

History offers a counterweight for similarly vapid analysis. As we outlined a few weeks ago, just six teams have overcome 0-3 starts to reach the playoffs since 1980. Many critics will stick a fork in ‘em for that reason alone.

Computer simulations — well more than 10,000 of them —  strike a balance between the optimism and pessimism, suggesting the Steelers are still significant long shots, but not quite as long as the expansive graveyard of past 0-3 teams suggests.

Let’s start with overall odds from a few sources.

Advertise with us

Football Outsiders bases its forecasts on 30,000 runs based of its efficiency rankings. You can read more about that process here. The Steelers do pretty well given the circumstances. (And considering Football Outsiders has been deeply skeptical of individual players for long stretches of the season.)

Currently, their get-in odds sit at an in-the-ballgame 33.7%, basically a 1-in-3 shot. Broken down by outcome, the odds are 14.2% to win a wild-card spot and 19.6% to win the division. The latter figure even includes a 3.7% chance to earn a first-round bye, if you’re feeling punchy.

FiveThirtyEight, which bases its predictions on 100,000 runs using its Elo rating system, is cooler on the Steelers, but only slightly. That site currently lists get-in odds at 25% with a 16% chance to win the division.

ESPN’s Football Power Index, meanwhile, more or less splits the difference. Its get-in odds are 31.2% and 18.6% to win the North.

Averaged, those three sources round to get-in odds of 30% and division odds of 18%.

Advertise with us

That’s not bad at all when you consider that the Steelers started with get-in odds of 62.1% at Football Outsiders. Practically speaking, the 1-4 start only cut those odds in half. It could have been much worse.

Instead, they’re still kicking, statistically speaking. A big reason is that their schedule is shaping up favorably.

Through Wednesday, FPI listed the Steelers as the favorite in seven of their 10 remaining games. Only the home game against the Los Angeles Rams and road games against Cleveland and Baltimore are showing odds worse than 50-50.

Should the Steelers win all of those game in which they’re favorites, they’d finish 9-7, which is right about where Football Outsiders had them in the preseason when it pegged them as a 9.5-win team.

Historically, 9-7 has been good enough for a berth a decent number of times. In the last 12 seasons, 16 of 37 teams that finished 9-7 made the playoffs. That’s a success rate of 43.2%.

Advertise with us

Of course, it’s generally foolish to start counting too many wins before they happen. That’s especially true when the team in question is 2-4 and relying on backup quarterbacks and a defense that just lost a key piece.

This just isn’t shaping up as a lost season yet. There’s legitimate hope in the numbers.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.