Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to the Steelers chat. Let's get it going.

Justin: Your thoughts on Minkah after his first three games with the Steelers?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think he's really good. I don't think it's a coincidence the defense has been much better since he arrived. I think they have 11 turnovers in the three games he has played in. I don't want to say he completes the defense, because they're not a finished product, but he definitely filled a big void for them. He's an excellent player.

Jaxon: Ray,

Advertise with us

Seems like we need to draft multiple positions early; WR, RB, TE, OL

Do you see our strategy changing to free agency more ?

Ray Fittipaldo: That's a long ways off. Maybe they'll re-sign Nick Vannett if they like how he plays. If that happens I'm not so sure you have to draft a TE. The WR thing is interesting. We'll have to see how things go with JuJu for the remainder of the season, but he certainly needs more help than he's getting. I agree with you on the O-line. They have to get younger there. I know they like Fred Johnson, but if they can get a quality G that can impact the running game they should consider it.

Eric: Why wasn't .fichtner fired on the spot for the insanely stupid decision to have

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think he should be fired, but having Samuels pass out of the wildcat was not a good decision especially when you're deep in your own territory. Fichtner has to find a way to get more out of his personnel. The defense is playing well enough. It's time for Fichtner to draw something up that will help the team win some games. What he's done for the past three weeks hasn't been good enough.

Advertise with us

Franco: I really like Mason long term but I kind of want to see Duck Dynasty. I think he could potentially give us the spark that we need to get going by moving the ball downfield and generating points. This D is on its way to being elite in my unit, we just need some ball movement and we can get on a run! Thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: A glass-full type of guy! I like it. Hodges looked good in his debut. He has "moxie" as Tomlin likes to say. But let's see how he does when a team has a week to prepare for him. I'm not saying he won't be a success, but there's a reason he was a tryout guy and not someone who was drafted or signed right after the draft.

KN: Hello. Thank you for taking the time to answer all the questions. 1)Do you see Washington playing this week ? I only heard Shoulder AC injury which does not tell you much about the length of absence 2) Do you think Nix will be back this week and would we see another RB added to squad , because of Samuel out for a month? Thank you very much as always.

Ray Fittipaldo: Hard to say at this stage of the week with Washington. He was in a sling yesterday. They practice for the first time this week tomorrow. I'd say he's questionable at this point. Tomlin seemed to think Nix would be able to practice this week. Not sure if that means he'll automatically play, but it's a good sign he's going to practice. He's been out for a month, and I think he can help the running game.

Timmy: Any word about dumping Moncrief to save the comp pick?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Gerry Dulac wrote about that last week. They can do that by Week 10 to ensure they'll get a third-round compensatory pick. In a related note, with Washington questionable this week, Moncrief could get back into the lineup after being inactive for the past three games.

Ashley: Tomlin still doesn't know how to use timeouts effectively. Why does he constantly get a pass? That's a major part of coaching.

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think he gets a pass. I tweeted about the sequence just before halftime. I factored that into his coaching grade in my report card. I gave him a D. I've given him Fs in other games this season. I think we do a pretty decent job of criticizing him when he deserves to be criticized.

Charlie : Steelers will be first to tell you that the goal is to win the Super Bowl every year, but this is starting to seem like a mini-rebuilding year where the team transitions from an offense-first team with Ben/Brown/Bell to a team built around a playmaking defense featuring Heyward, Tuitt, Watt, Bush, Fitzpatrick, and solid corner duo in Haden/Nelson. Is there anything to that?

Ray Fittipaldo: Sure, there is something to that, but they'll still try to win their remaining 11 games. That won't change.

Advertise with us

Amy: Pitt is losing with the ultra-conservative offense and losing qb's to injuries. Why not open it up and let it fly?

Ray Fittipaldo: I'd do the opposite. I'd get my offensive linemen in 3-point stances, run the ball with a fullback, possess the ball and keep my defense off the field. That's not conservative. That's smart football. You can play-action off that. You can do a lot of things when you run the ball effectively. Now I don't know if they're capable of changing their spots at midseason, but it's been done before. How about the Ravens last year? They changed their entire offense in the middle of the season and came back from the depths of the AFC North to overtake the Steelers.

Suzi: Time to change the touchback rule in the nfl to the college rule? That way Pittgets to the 25 yard line.

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe. If they truly are concerned about head injuries they'll do that.

Harry: Status of Mason Rudolph. What stage is he in the protocol?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Rudolph will have to pass tests each day of the week and then he'll have to be evaluated by an independent neurologist before he is cleared.

Carey: With Samuels out who will make up for his passing? Kidding, of course. Benny Snell to backup rb then who?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think Trey Edmunds will be elevated from the practice squad. He had a good camp.

DaquidoBazzini: Hi, Ray....I was at the game and sitting in the corner end zone near the Mason Rudolph hit. First of all, it was horrific. Earl Thomas should've been thrown out and should be suspended. Second of all....I never saw a flag. Did I miss one?

Ray Fittipaldo: I have to go back and watch the play, but I was told the flag came out well after the play was over. So I don;t think it was thrown immediately.

Advertise with us

Kenny: Vince Williams looked great in his return but can't cover at all. Is it Barron and Bush versus the Chargers?

Ray Fittipaldo: Barron has a hamstring injury so not sure about that. Plus, Williams might be useful against Melvin Gordon.

DaquidoBazzini: What do you think of the Tomlin to DC rumors? I actually thought about this a couple weeks ago. I'm not so sure it's possible. You?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think it's likely. First off, why would he want to walk into a situation like that? Washington hasn't been relevant in years. Plus, everyone in the NFL knows how Dan Snyder operates as an owner. Sure, he'd get paid a lot of money, but he already makes a lot of money. But the thing people are missing is he's under contract through 2021. The Steelers would have to trade him to the Redskins, and I don't think that will happen unless Snyder gave them 5 first-round picks. Even then, I'm not sure they'd do it. They believe in Tomlin and the way he runs his team.

Billy: Any coaching staff changes during the bye week assuming Pitt falls to 1-5?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think so. They usually do those after the season.

Tomlin: Thoughts on Tomlin's decision to kick to open overtime?

Ray Fittipaldo: After his explanation postgame I was fine with it. I'm not saying he was right because it could have backfired big-time if Baltimore went down and scored a touchdown. But I thought the reasons behind the decision were solid. It doesn't say much for his confidence in his special teams, but I was OK with it after I heard him explain why he did it.

Tampa Too: I saw where Ben got fined $5000 for wearing a watch on the sidelines. Do you know where this money goes? Is it charity? Does the league keep it? Just curious

Ray Fittipaldo: They use it to pay Alberto Riveron bonuses at the end of every season.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: (I'm kidding)

Matt: What, if anything, are Ju-Ju and James doing to correct their late game fumble/choke issues? The number's up to 5 now.

Ray Fittipaldo: Be more aware of game situations and squeeze the ball. JuJu was up front with us after the game. His mindset was to get more yards. I respect that. He's trying to make a play. But there are times when you cover up and get to the ground to fight another day. One of those moments might have been in overtime with the ball near midfield and Ravens on their heels. He'll learn. I'm a bit more concerned with Conner because he handles the ball much more as a RB. They should always be aware of defenders trying to strip the ball.

Watt: Why was Watt on the sideline in overtime when Ola got the penalty?

Ray Fittipaldo: I'd have to go back and watch, but he does pull himself out of games on occasion. It is curious that it would happen so late in regulation (not overtime), but I'd have to go back and watch to see why he exited the game.

Advertise with us

Obi: Any chance the Steelers start dumping players in a fire sale right before the trade deadline?

Ray Fittipaldo: None.

Tampa Too: I thought this game was one of the worst officiated games I’ve ever seen. There appeared to be bad calls on both sides. It was a flag fest Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you It's an embarrassment to the NFL.

Paul: I'm real pleased with the effort past few games especially with all the QB injuries. I thought the coaches and players did a fine job. Things are bound to get better I like the future of this team, your thoughts? Love your work Ray!

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I like the way the defense is trending. But I can't say the future is great when Devlin Hodges is going to play Phillip Rivers in LA on Sunday night. You lose that game you're 1-5 and the season is over.

Jason: Ray, Were you surprised how well Duck played? I thought he looked more confident than Mason throwing the ball. How did you see it and his chances this week? Thank you for your insight.

Ray Fittipaldo: I was impressed. He also scrambled 21 yards for a big first down to set up the late field go-ahead field goal. There's something about him, but let's get real. When Mason Rudolph is healthy he's going to be the starter.

Stan: Would you Trade Tomlin to the Skins for a 1st rounder? What's the minimum you'd take?

Ray Fittipaldo: 5 first-round picks.

Advertise with us

Pete: If Pitt needs to call up Lynch to qb, who do they cut?

Ray Fittipaldo: We'll find out Saturday. I don't think they make that move until they have to.

Melissa: A 2 point loss, a 3 point loss, a 4 point loss and a loss to the best team in the nfl that's only given up 2 td's in 5 weeks. Are the Steelers really that bad?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think the Steelers are bad, but it's nearly impossible to make the playoffs after starting 1-4.

Mary: Prediction for Pitt's end of season record and what percentage chance do you give them to make the playoffs now?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: 1 percent chance to make the playoffs. And right now, I'd say they'd do well to go 5-11 or 6-10. Still think they beat Miami and Cincinnati again. The Browns aren't good. The Colts are playing with a backup QB. You still have the Cardinals on the schedule too. I'd be shocked if they don't get to five wins.

TC in Charlotte: Do you feel like Thomas should be suspended?

Ray Fittipaldo: When was the last time someone was suspended for a hit like that? It was a bad hit. He launched himself into Rudolph's jaw. Maybe the referee should have ejected him. But I don't think he'll be suspended. He'll get a fine, maybe a steep one if he's a repeat offender. But the NFL doesn't usually suspend guys for hits like that unless you're a multi-time offender like Vontaze Burfict.

RPK: How often will we see the wildly effective Wildcat against the Chargers?

Ray Fittipaldo: After what happened last week it might be banned forever. Plus, Samuels is out for a month with a knee injury. I don't think we'll see the wildcat this week in LA.

Advertise with us

Long Island Joe: Hey Ray , What is the story behind coaches not being held accountable in Pittsburgh? Danny Smith has been the ST coach for 6 years and other than finding Boswell on the FA heap after failing miserably finding a replacement for Suisham what has he done. The ST unit has been a major liability for Steelers - haven't had a returner since AB and last year ST cost us 3 wins with missed FGs when something was obviously not right with Bos.

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't disagree with you about the special teams. And it's true Smith has been around for a long time. But the players have something to do with this as well. They just don't seem to find enough capable special teamers to make a difference.

Matt: After seeing the Browns last night it sure looks like 9-7 will win the division. Any shot Steelers can rattle of some wins and get to 8-7 or 7-8 and make week 17 interesting in Baltimore?

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe, but they'd have to pull off a few upsets for that to happen. No better place than this week in LA.

wburg412: What do you see that merits them continously putting Switzer back to return other than maybe Diontae Johnson.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Johnson had a fumbling problem in the preseason. So I think that's the issue.

Paul: BTW Thank God Mason is ok!

mike tomlin: ray im out of here heading to beautiful d.c. thanks for the chats!

Ray Fittipaldo: Will you be back for tomorrow's practice?

Bradshaw: I remember when you'd get knocked out like that once a week, they'd just say your bell was rung and shake it off, then go back out there in a couple plays. But then we realized the brain is important. So people are saying it was Rudolph's choice to walk off? So then what do we decide to let him drive himself to the hospital also? How could people let that happen? Get a damn stretcher.

Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin addressed that today. He said the medical personnel who evaluated Rudolph believed he was OK to walk off. He said the cart's mechanical issue (or whatever the issue was) was not a factor in him walking off. Tomlin said Rudolph wanted to walk off the field and the people who evaluated him thought it was OK for him to do that.

SD Stiller: In your opinion, is there any chance we trade Tomlin?

Ray Fittipaldo: No.

Dj Cain Arkansas: How much of the blame do you place on Randy Fitchner

Ray Fittipaldo: He's the OC so he'll get some blame for what's transpired with this offense. To me, the biggest issue is a lack of a running game. With a young Qb and this defense, it would be a no-brainer to lean on it. But apparently, there is no confidence in the line or the RBs because we keep saying the same things every week -- shotgun runs for minimal gains and all the pressure falling back on the QB to make plays on third down. That's not going to produce good results when the QBs are young.

Dj Cain Arkansas: Ray good work by the way! If we win Sunday is there still a chance we make the playoffs?

Ray Fittipaldo: In this division, yes. But it's a tall task to go to LA and beat Phillip Rivers with Duck Hodges behind center.

sean: Hi Ray thanks for your time and the weekly chat Im a little late not sure if any one asked but what does Moncrief do for the team now? thanks again!

Ray Fittipaldo: For the past three games he's stood on the sidelines in street clothes. That might change this week if James Washington is out with his shoulder injury.

Nathan: Even after Tomlin botching clock management, timeout/challenge management, and situational coaching in general, how much, if any, pressure has he gotten from upstairs to adjust? I know they hired Teryl Austin, but does Tomlin actually listen to him?

Ray Fittipaldo: Austin was hired to help with replay reviews. I can't say he was brought in to help with clock management too. At least I've never heard that. That's on the head coach to have a feel for that.

Tom: Ray, What am I missing with Conners? Average RB who is careless with the ball. Just do not see him long term as the answer.

Ray Fittipaldo: Not looking like he'll get a second contract at this point especially when they're going to have to pay T.J. Watt and JuJu Smith-Schuster from the same draft class. You can always find another RB.

iowasteelerfan: Is it the returners, or the blocking schemes that are causing our kick return woes - looks like there is simply little to no room to run - your observations please?

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you. There doesn't appear to be a lot of running room for the returners. Then again, I don't think they have dynamic returners. A lot of times, the returners made the blockers look good because they're so fast or so good at finding creases.

JoeB: Minkah pretty much proves that Davis is average to below-average, doesn't he?

Ray Fittipaldo: I mean yeah, but we already knew that, right?

JoeB: Do you disagree with Tomlin's OT decision? 10 minute overtime, it seems you should want as many possessions as possible, which means receiving, and a chance to end it without the other team touching, which means receiving. He gained about 14 yards on his decision, which was not worth it in my opinion.

Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah, but as Tomlin pointed out, what if you start at your own 15, go three-and-out and give the Ravens the ball at midfield after a punt? Then Tucker boots a 45-yard field goal to win the game? Then the game is over. I trust that he has a good feel for his kickoff return game, offense and defense to make that decision. I'm not saying he was right or wrong, but I see his rationale.

Jr High: Why not play Finney instead of Foster? He's been strong every time he gets in there.

Ray Fittipaldo: Because they signed Foster to a two-year, $8 million contract in March.

Jason: How does a national reporter print the Skins will go after Tomlin and still be taken serious? I guess something to grab the headlines.

Ray Fittipaldo: BINGO!

John: Tired of hearing that Mason Rudolph is not comfortable playing under center. This is the NFL. Since when is it not the coaches responsibility to get him comfortable under center, if they NEED him comfortable under center?

Ray Fittipaldo: Agree with you 100 percent. Not a knock on Rudolph either. I understand he didn't play under center in college, but he needs to learn how to do that. The same goes for the offensive linemen being comfortable playing in two-point stances because that's what they've done for the past five years. I was floored when Randy Fichtner said that last week when he addressed reporters. If you play offensive line in the NFl part of the job requirement is being able to play in a 3-point stance. If you can't then I'm going out and finding someone who does. It's a pretty basic part of being an offensive lineman.

CanadianSteelersFan : In my opinion the game was lost in the first two possessions when the Offense went 3 and out AGAIN and followed up with an interception. We spotted the Ravens 10 points in a 3 point loss. Why do you think the team always comes out so flat? Happens every week.

Ray Fittipaldo: Sounds like you read my report card. I agree with you 100 percent.

Steve in OH: We were at the game and didn't have a great replay. However, in the 4th, it looked like the Steelers got a safety. I haven't seen anyone talk about it. As I understand the rule, the whole ball has to get out of the end zone for it to not be a safety and it did not look that way. That would have been huge - 2 points and the ball. Why didn't Tomlin challenge? Was it clearly not a safety?

Ray Fittipaldo: I would never put my trust in Alberto Riveron to make the right call on a review. Plus, it was very close. It appeared the ball crossed the goal line. That's all that has to happen. Just the ball. Not any part of the body.

BamBam Murray: What ever happened to Artie Burns?

Ray Fittipaldo: Artie made a great play to pin the Ravens on the 1 in the fourth quarter. Would have been a huge play if the Steelers won. And hey, he might start this week if Steven Nelson can't play due to his groin injury.

Steve: Who played better against the fast 49ers defense: Rudolph or Mayfield?

Ray Fittipaldo: Definitely Rudolph although he struggled mightily early in the game when the Steelers had a chance put that game out of reach. The 49ers turned the ball over so much early, and all they could manage was six points off two field goals.

JJ: Seems as though our defense is improving. Any idea where we stand after five games ?

Ray Fittipaldo: I know they're first in turnovers forced with 12. (The patriots also have 12). And I'm sure their yardage stats are improving after the past two weeks.

Bill in SF: Watched the 49ers execute a running game to set up play-action passing. Watched the Colts use a running game to completely dominate KC. Watched the Patriots do the same thing last postseason? Why to the Steelers refuse to commit to it with back-up QBs to save the season? Can't believe this line is not capable.

Ray Fittipaldo: Great question, and I'm beginning to believe they're not capable of doing it. If not, it's coaching malpractice not to try it the way the defense is playing now. It's exactly what coaches do when they have young quarterbacks. So the fact that they haven't tried it lends to me to think they don't have the personnel to execute it.

Dj Cain Arkansas : When are we gonna admit the O-Line. Miss Munchak bad?

Ray Fittipaldo: The line was bad in the second half of last season too. At least in the run game. I've detailed that numerous times.

Steve: Ray, Is McDonald hurt again?

Ray Fittipaldo: Don't think so. Tomlin mentioned him today, but he said something to the effect that he came through the game OK.

ypar70: Has anyone asked the coaches why MR runs the offense from shotgun the whole game? But on Sunday I saw Duck under center a few times and also he used play action. Is running shotgun the whole game actually counter productive over the course of the whole game?

Ray Fittipaldo: I looked at the play-by-play. I counted two snaps from under center for Hodges. All of Mason's were in the shotgun. Fichtner was asked about it last week. He basically said we built this offense around a Hall of Fame QB and then he mentioned Mason played in the shotgun all the time at OK State. I get it. Your players are used to it. Your young QB feels comfortable. But if playing under center will help others then I think you have to do it.

JoeB: Chances that Rudolph plays Sunday?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not high.

Ray Fittipaldo: OK I went overtime this week! And I still couldn't get to every question. Thanks for joining in and we'll do it again next week after the Chargers game.