Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Dennis Northcutt and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions, which were laced with Steeler rage …
Actually, we will start again this week with our intergalactically popular Twitter Poll segment. I posed a simple question Monday afternoon: “Now that we've all weighed in 8,000 times, did Mike Tomlin make the right call on the OT kickoff?”
In just one hour, more than 1,100 people voted — and 56% of them agreed with Tomlin’s decision to kick off to start overtime.
What we learned: That people are results-driven and really don’t think for themselves. Every decision that “works” is great, and every decision that “fails” is stupid. The result ALWAYS justifies the rationale.
So if I jump off my roof with a blindfold on and happen to land in a pile of leaves? Man, that was fun!
If I land on the sidewalk and break my leg? Man, that was stupid.
Read More
If I tell you right now Tomlin will go for it on fourth-and-10 in the first quarter against the Chargers, you’ll say, “How could he even think of such a thing?”
If Duck throws a touchdown on the play, you’ll say, “What a call!”
How about: That was a really bad decision no matter how it turned out.
Does that option exist?
The call worked once. How many times would it work in 50 tries? Would you make it again, under the exact same set of circumstances? Think a little, will ya?
If I’d taken the same OT poll immediately after the coin toss, 95% would have disagreed with Tomlin.
I still do. You simply don’t give the other team a chance to end the game without your team touching the ball. Nor do you give their great kicker the next crack to end it if you trade punts or field goals to start overtime. The percentages are not in your favor (as we will see in a moment).
Plus, your third-string quarterback was moving the ball pretty well.
Plus, your defense had just allowed Baltimore to tie the score with a late field goal — and would have allowed the game-losing touchdown if Lamar Jackson hadn’t overthrown an open receiver in the end zone.
I prefer to stick with my convictions no matter the result.
Exhibit A: I agreed with Tomlin when he tried an onside kick WITH THE LEAD against Green Bay late in a 2009 game. The Packers recovered. Aaron Rodgers promptly led a touchdown drive, leaving the Steelers precious little time. They did come back (last-second pass from Ben Roethlisberger to Mike Wallace), but Tomlin’s move was greeted with widespread criticism. I liked it. His defense could not stop Rodgers that day. Tomlin figured he could end the game right there or at least leave his offense some time once Rodgers scored again.
Exhibit B: I agreed with Tomlin’s fake field goal attempt at Seattle in 2015 when Landry Jones checked in and threw an awful pass to Al Villanueva. Fact is, Big Al was open. It was a great call. It didn’t work, so everyone hated it.
But when Al scored a TD on a fake field goal at Denver last year? Great call!
Lemmings, all of you.
Steelers coach Mike Tomlin explains decision to kick off in overtime
Anyway, here is a sampling of responses:
Andrew Rihn, @AndrewDRihn: Wins by team that possesses the ball first (in OT): 59 (50%) Of these wins, 23 were on an opening drive TD (39% of team with first possession wins, 19.5% overall overtime games) Wins by team that possesses the ball second: 52 (44.1%)
Ties: 7 (5.9%)
L.J., @Ldiddles3: Initially I hated giving Baltimore the ball. Then I came around to it and understood the rationale. Then I got to thinking. The chance was VERY good Baltimore gets at least a FG and the Steelers special teams has to return a kick anyway.
Uncle Randy, @hoDUERR: But this epitomizes some of the people that watch these games. If they scored first and ended it, people would be calling for Tomlin’s head. Now that it “worked” people want to pretend they thought it was good all along. It not being the reason we lost the game doesn’t make it right.
Tim Balchak, @balchak_tim: It was a calculated risk. I had no problem with the decision and I usually can't stand Tomlin's decisions.
Tim McAloon, @tjmcaloonsr: If this poll was taken right before the coin toss you would have a completely different result. Either that or it once again proves why I never want to be tried in front of a jury of my peers, cause their decision making is highly questionable.
Michael Bowman, @Bowman19xx: I didn't like it at first, but after Tomlin explained his reasoning I actually changed my mind. Defense was playing well & if not for a TRASH roughing the passer call maybe they end it in regulation.
And the winner is …
Neil Parker, @NeilPark49897889: It’s like hitting on 17 in blackjack and getting a 4 and saying “see it worked.”
MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: What is your skill level in operating a medical cart?
Starkey: Hello Fake Holtzy. As long as it’s not a stick shift, I’m good. And I’m not buying that it was OK for Mason Rudolph to get up and wobble (with assistance) all the way to the far tunnel, whether he wanted to or not. The man was unconscious moments earlier. He was in such medical distress that they unscrewed his face mask.
I’m no doctor — I don’t even play one on the radio — but as a general rule, I believe people who have just suffered severe head trauma should not take long walks.
Zack Henry, @zackoff39: Who has the best chance of succeeding after their long term star/stars retire? The Pens without Malkin/Crosby or the Steelers after Ben retires?
Starkey: The Steelers, without question, Mr. zackoff. I’m not saying they’ll be as successful without Ben as they have been with him, but they have hope in the form of an improving young defense. We’ll see if Mason Rudolph profiles as a legit successor. Early returns are mixed. Great quarterbacks are hard to find. The Steelers know that; they went a quarter century between Terry Bradshaw and Ben, and, not coincidentally, a quarter century between Super Bowl wins.
But you’re asking me about their prospects compared to the post-Sid/Geno Penguins. It’s almost impossible to imagine what that will look like. Getting both was a miracle that could never be repeated. They lost the draft lottery in Geno’s year but wound up with a generational talent with the second pick, then won the Sid lottery on a 6% chance. Also, their farm system isn’t exactly popping with hot prospects.
JB_Nimble, @JB_Nimble: Paxton Lynch time???
Starkey: Is it ever really Paxton Lynch time, JB? It sounds like Mason Rudolph is doing OK, thank goodness, but one never really knows how long concussion symptoms might linger. If he is out for a significant period, the Steelers would be wise to bring in a veteran backup for Duck Hodges, who played well. ESPN’s Bill Barnwell suggested Ryan Fitzpatrick from Miami in exchange for Artie Burns. I say why not?
You can never have enough ex-Dolphins named Fitzpatrick.
moonlite graham, @moonlitegraham6: Is it clearly l own that Hurdle chose to undress and leave clubhouse. His choice to skip last game. Also hurdle does not choose his coaches. Doesn’t want responsibility if they fail. Also entire support staff were actually thrilled when they fired him.
Starkey: Huh? Is there a question there, Moonlite?
I do like your Twitter handle, though, and it brings up a question: Five greatest baseball movies:
5. “Major League.”
4. “A League of Their Own.”
3. “Bad News Bears” (original).
2. “Field of Dreams.”
1. “The Natural” (filmed in Buffalo).
Todd McCollum, @mccollumT: Why hasn't the Pirates scouting and development team been fired?
Starkey: There’s still time, Todd. Could be more firings. But the real question is, how does the GM still have a job? Seems every time I watch somebody pitch in these playoffs, that question springs to mind.
Christopher Jeffrey, @triathaloon: Why God why
Starkey: I agree.
Thank you, my yinz. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Subscribe to our daily all-sports newsletter, the PG Sports Feed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.