JuJu Smith-Schuster was looking to make a play, just like he had some three hours earlier when he caught a pass from Mason Rudolph, shrugged off cornerback Marlon Humphrey and dashed into the end zone for the first Steelers touchdown of the game.
Only this time, Humphrey punched the ball out before Smith-Schuster could turn up the field. It was, as it turned out, a knockout punch for the Steelers.
Humphrey raced to recover the fumble and set up Baltimore’s winning field goal a few plays later.
It was the second time in seven games Smith-Schuster fumbled late when the Steelers had a chance to tie or win the game. With the Steelers driving for the tying field goal or perhaps the winning touchdown in Week 16 in New Orleans last season, he fumbled on the Saints 35-yard-line. The loss was devastating to their playoff chances. They went from controlling their own destiny to needing help in the final week of the season.
The latest miscue knocked the Steelers to 1-4 in a season that has been defined by injuries to quarterbacks and late collapses. A late fumble by James Conner in San Francisco cost the Steelers, and some late defensive lapses led to a loss against Seattle.
“I feel terrible, man,” Smith-Schuster said afterward. “It’s literally the worst feeling ever. Knowing the game is on the line in overtime, you have the ball, knowing that Humphrey … that’s what he does. He made a great play in a great situation. He came through for his team.”
Read More
Even with the knowledge that Humphrey was going to hunt the ball in that situation, Smith-Schuster was thinking big. He didn’t necessarily think he would score again if he could shrug off Humphrey, but his mindset was to gain more yards. He was stripped near midfield.
“My plan was to stiff-arm him and get up the field,” Smith-Schuster said. “The whole game he’s been doing that. He’s been pushing at the ball. He made a good play.”
Could he have done anything different?
“Just protect the ball,” he said. “Squeeze it hard.”
Steelers lose to Ravens in overtime, drop to 1-4
The fumble was the turning point in a strange game that included a curious decision by Mike Tomlin to kick off to the Ravens after winning the overtime coin flip. Under NFL overtime rules, the team that possesses the ball first can win the game if it scores a touchdown on its first possession. If there is a field goal, the other team gets a possession with a chance to tie or go ahead.
According to quirkyresearch.com, it was only the second time a coach decided to kick off in overtime after winning the toss since the new overtime rules were adopted for the 2016 season. Former Browns coach Hue Jackson also elected to kick off and lost the game.
Tomlin said the decision to kick off was rooted in the poor performance from his kickoff return unit. The Steelers were pinned inside their 15-yard-line three times by Baltimore kicker Justin Tucker during regulation.
“Did you see our kickoff return in this football game,” Tomlin said, when asked about the decision. “Did you see their kickoff team? Every time, they put the ball on about the 2-yard-line and Tucker hung the ball for about 4.5 seconds, and we couldn’t get back to the 15. Why would I sign up for that? I put the defense on the field in an effort to fight for field position and put the onus on them to get the stop. When we got the ball, we got it on the 30-something, which is dramatically different than when our kickoff return team took the field all afternoon.”
If Smith-Schuster does not fumble and the Steelers win, the decision would have been met with praise. But since the Steelers lost, the decision will be questioned even though the strategy proved to be sound because his defense came through for him.
Tomlin players weren’t second-guessing him.
“Mike T said ‘I’m going to put you on the field,’ ” said defensive captain Cam Heyward, who was on the field for the coin toss. “I fully support it. You take away their opportunity if you get a three-and-out. I’ll ride with that game plan every day, any time. We embrace those challenges.”
“Coach made a good call,” Smith-Schuster added. “The defense stopped them. We got the ball back, and I had poor handling of the ball and turned it over.”
Steelers coach Mike Tomlin explains decision to kick off in overtime
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.