Quarterback: Mason Rudolph was playing well before he was knocked out by a helmet-to-helmet hit by Ravens safety Earl Thomas. He had a 100.2 quarterback rating and completed 13 of 20 passes for 131 yards in a little more than two quarters of work. Devlin Hodges came on in relief in his first NFL action and acquitted himself quite well. He was 7 for 9 for 68 yards and had a quarterback rating of 98.1. He also added a 21-yard scramble that helped set up the go-ahead field goal late in regulation. Other than another slow start for Rudolph, there wasn’t much to complain about. Then again, the Steelers have to figure out how to start faster. It’s costing them games.

Grade: B

Running backs: It has been tough sledding for the running backs in the first five games, and this game was no different. James Conner had 14 carries for 55 yards. In total, the Steelers had just 19 rushing attempts for 77 yards. It’s a little bit better than the totals in their other three losses, but it’s not good enough. Now more than ever, with Hodges likely to start in Los Angeles against the Chargers, the Steelers need more from their running game. Six days after being one of the stars of the first victory of the season against the Cincinnati Bengals, Jaylen Samuels was much less effective. He had three carries for 2 yards and threw an ill-advised interception in the first quarter that contributed to the Steelers falling behind by 10-0 early.

Grade: C-

Advertise with us

Steelers lose to Ravens in overtime, drop to 1-4

Receivers: Another late-game fumble by JuJu Smith-Schuster was costly. This one led to the Ravens kicking the winning field goal in overtime. It was the second time in seven games that Smith-Schuster fumbled late in regulation or overtime. He fumbled with 35 seconds left in regulation when the Steelers were driving for the tying field goal in New Orleans in Week 16 of the 2018 season. Smith-Schuster did battle through a toe injury and led the Steelers with 75 yards receiving and a touchdown, but the late gaffe turned the game in Baltimore’s favor. No one else was able to find much room against a beleaguered Ravens secondary, another bad sign this group isn’t living up to its billing. James Washington had three receptions for 52 yards, but he left the game in the third quarter with a shoulder injury. The Steelers need more from the receivers.

Grade: C-

Offensive line: Once again the pass protection was excellent for Rudolph and Hodges. On the hit that knocked Rudolph out of the game, he scrambled around the pocket and extended the play. That’s not on the line. But as good as the pass protection has been, the Steelers continue to struggle in the run game. Ramon Foster gave up the only sack of the game and also got called for a costly holding penalty. Offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner talked Thursday about this offense being built around Ben Roethlisberger. They weren’t changing it for Mason Rudolph. But it would be nice to change it now with a rookie under center. Of course, that depends on the line developing a downhill running mentality, and we haven’t seen any ability to do that through five games.

Grade: C-

Defensive line: The Ravens came into the game averaging over 200 yards rushing per game, but the Steelers were able to hold them to 138 yards on the ground and only 58 in the second half. Much of the credit goes to the stout defensive line that was led by Stephon Tuitt and Cam Heyward. Tuitt led all linemen with eight tackles. Heyward had four tackles, a sack and two quarterback hurries. Nose tackle Javon Hargrave also added a sack. They allowed Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson to break contain a few times early in the game, but they did a better job in the second half.

Advertise with us

Grade: B

Linebackers: It was another strong performance under some difficult circumstances for this group. Mark Barron left the game in the first quarter with a hamstring injury. That forced Vince Williams into a lot of snaps in his first game after missing the past two with a hamstring injury. He stepped in and played very well, leading the team in tackles with nine and also recording a sack. Devin Bush had eight tackles and showed some resolve after committing what could have been game-changing penalty. He jumped off sides, which gave the Ravens a fourth-and-1, which they converted. But a few plays later he made an acrobatic interception deep in Steelers territory. T.J. Watt and Bud Dupree each had five tackles and a sack. Ola Adeniyi committed a roughing the passer penalty that helped the Ravens tie the score late in regulation, but it’s hard to find fault in him in what was a ticky-tacky call by referee Walt Coleman.

Grade: B+

Steelers coach Mike Tomlin explains decision to kick off in overtime

Secondary: This group is turning into a very strong unit for the Steelers. They had three more interceptions, including two by defensive backs. Kameron Kelly got his first career pick, and Mike Hilton added another. Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson entered the game averaging 277 passing yards per game. The Steelers held him to 161 and only 68 in the second half. The only negatives were some early completions by Jackson, including an 11-yard touchdown pass to Marquise Brown in the second quarter. But after that, the secondary shut him down. They deserved a better fate on this day.

Grade: B+

Advertise with us

Special teams: It wasn’t a good start for the special teams, but things improved later in the game. Punter Jordan Berry pinned the Ravens at their 1 with 7:14 remaining with the score tied. Gunner Artie Burns did a great job of keeping the ball from bouncing into the end zone. On the ensuing drive, place-kicker Chris Boswell booted a 33-yard field goal to give the Steelers a 23-20 lead with 2:14 to go. Those were some big plays made at crucial times. The players deserve credit, especially Boswell, who remains perfect on the season. But there was a lot of bad early in the game. On the opening kickoff, Johnny Holton fielded the kick 2 yards deep in the end zone and decided to bring it out. He was tackled at the 11, and the Steelers lost 14 yards in field position. They punted, and the Ravens scored on the ensuing drive. Ryan Switzer was back for the next kick. Ola Adeniyi was called for holding, and the Steelers started at the 12. On the third kickoff, Holton was back there again. He knelt on it in the end zone, and the fans at Heinz Field gave him a Bronx cheer. Later, after the Steelers cut the deficit to 7 after a field goal, they gave up a 46-yard kickoff return. Luckily for the kickoff return unit the defense rose up and forced a punt. If not for the late-game plays by Berry, Burns and Boswell this grade would have been a big F.

Grade: C

Coaching: Forget about the decision to kick off in overtime. If JuJu Smith-Schuster did not fumble, the Steelers very well could have won the game. This game was lost in the first half. The play-calling to open the game was atrocious. A three-and-out, with no pass attempts down the field, was followed by Jaylen Samuels throwing out of the wildcat formation. Of course, it was intercepted. And before the fans could settle into their seats, the Steelers trailed, 10-0. Late in the second quarter, with a chance to cut the lead to three, the Steelers had second-and-1 from the 7. They came out in the wildcat (with seven linemen and two tight ends) and lost 5 yards. No one in the stadium thought Samuels would pass again after he threw a pick on his previous attempt. The Ravens gleefully played the run and made a big stand that resulted in three points instead of seven for the Steelers. The defense settled down and played well, but it took some time for Keith Butler to get a bead on how to stop Lamar Jackson. He led the Ravens to three scores on their first three drives of the game. When your offense is being guided by young quarterbacks, that’s too many points yielded early in a home game.

Grade: D

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.