A quintet of quarterbacks almost made history of the night of April 26, 2018. Baker Mayfield, Sam Darnold, Josh Allen, Josh Rosen and Lamar Jackson were selected in the first round of the NFL draft. On only two other occasions had as many quarterbacks been taken in the first round — in 1999 (when five were drafted) and 1983, when a record six were selected.
Steelers quarterback Mason Rudolph was the sixth quarterback selected in the draft, but he had to wait hours before he heard his name called. Rudolph was taken 44 spots after Jackson, with the 76th overall pick in the third round.
Steelers general manager Kevin Colbert said moments after Rudolph was drafted that the Steelers had a first-round grade on him. Just don’t mention that to Rudolph, who remains irritated that he wasn’t drafted in the first round.
“Yes, I do carry that with me,” Rudolph was saying Thursday afternoon in a quiet moment in the locker room following Steelers practice. “What happened happened, right? So what people say after the fact — even though that’s my franchise and I respect their opinion, and I want that to be true — but it didn’t happen. I had to deal with that. It did add a chip to my shoulder because I thought I was that type of player.
“But everything happens for a reason. I feel like the situation I’ve been in for the last year — getting to learn from a veteran Hall of Fame quarterback, maybe something those other guys didn’t get a chance to do — it’s prepared me and helped me a lot. In 10 years that night won’t be remembered as much as maybe how I’ve developed. The pain from that hopefully will fade.”
Due to Ben Roethlisberger’s season-ending elbow injury, Rudolph is now being mentioned among the talented group of quarterbacks in that 2018 draft class. All six are starting for their respective teams, and three of them are ushering in a new era in the AFC North.
Read More
Rudolph, of course, is taking over for Roethlisberger, a two-time Super Bowl winner who had been the Steelers’ starter since 2004.
Jackson took over in Baltimore last season for Super Bowl-winning quarterback Joe Flacco, who had been the Ravens’ starter since 2008.
Cleveland hasn’t had a quarterback of note since the Reagan administration, but Mayfield is being viewed as the Browns’ savior after they used the No. 1 overall pick on him.
There is a similar scenario in the AFC East where Darnold, Allen and Rosen are quarterbacking the Jets, Bills and Dolphins, respectively.

The ’83 class is the most famous collection of quarterbacks in the history of the NFL. Three of them are enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. John Elway, Jim Kelly, Dan Marino and Tony Eason led their teams to a combined 11 Super Bowls. Elway won twice in his five appearances. Together, the six threw for more than 189,000 yards.
The 2018 class doesn’t even own a playoff win yet, but they carry the collective hopes of their fan bases that someday they’ll lead their teams to championships.
“Even high picks in the first round end up being a 50-50 proposition,” said Ravens coach John Harbaugh, who studied all of the 2018 quarterbacks closely in the run-up to last year’s draft. “These guys are all doing it. It’s pretty remarkable. I’m very impressed with this group.”
Harbaugh is right. For as many Elways, Kellys and Marinos that come along in the first round, there are as many, if not more, failures. Even No. 1 overall picks are pretty much a crapshoot in the past few decades. The top pick in the ’99 class was Tim Couch, who lasted five seasons before he washed out of the league. David Carr and JaMarcus Russell also were No. 1 overall picks. Other first-round quarterbacks who failed in recent years include Johnny Manziel, Matt Leinart and Jake Locker.
The 2018 class is trying to buck the odds and produce a large quantity of longtime starters. So far, they’re off to a good start.
Early success and early struggles
Mayfield and Jackson made an impact as rookies. Mayfield took over as the starter three games into the 2018 season and led the Browns to five victories in their final seven games to finish 7-9, their best record since 2014.
Jackson took over as Baltimore’s starter after nine games. He led the Ravens to a 6-1 record and overtook the Steelers for the AFC North title.
This season Jackson has the Ravens atop the league in scoring, averaging 33.8 points per game. He’s 11th in the league in passing yards per game (277.5) and 15th in rushing yards per game (59.5).
Mayfield is seventh in the league in passing, averaging 287 yards per game, and is coming off one of his best performances against the Ravens. He completed 67% of his passes for 342 yards in a 40-25 victory.
But they’re also prone to mistakes. Jackson threw two interceptions against the Browns last week. Mayfield is tied for the league-lead in interceptions and has thrown at least one in all four games this season. He has drawn criticism from analysts for his unrefined style of play. ESPN’s Rex Ryan, a former head coach of the Jets and Bills, called Mayfield a “one-read quarterback” and “overrated as hell.”

Rudolph, Darnold, Allen and Rosen are going through similar growing pains.
“Through one quarter of the season they have everyone’s attention,” said Hall of Fame quarterback Dan Fouts, who will work the Steelers-Ravens game as a color analyst for CBS sports. “Sometimes it’s good; sometimes it’s bad. But that’s what you expect with young quarterbacks. You can have these disaster plays and you have some fun highlights. It’s a fun time because of the uncertainty.”
Something else that sets this quarterback class apart is its variety. Mayfield and Rudolph played in the Big 12 where spread or “air raid” offenses are king. Jackson, who played at Louisville, came into the league as an electric runner but raw passer. Allen is the prototypical pro-style passer, but he played at Wyoming, where he wasn’t exposed to a lot of elite competition. And Rosen, described by many as the smartest and most NFL-ready of the first-round quintet, is, ironically, on his second team after the Cardinals traded him to the Dolphins in the offseason.
Defending Jackson is a difficult assignment for defensive coordinators because there are so few players like him at the position. It’s reminiscent of the late 1990s and early 2000s when former Steelers quarterback Kordell Stewart had his way with defenses for a while because he could just as easily run for 50 yards as he could pass for it.
“Lamar is the biggest challenge in the league right now,” Fouts said. “He is such a dynamic runner, and he’s improved so much as a passer. Their offense is well-balanced with Gus Edwards and Mark Ingram. And then you add Jackson on the perimeter. Who thought before the season that they’d be the highest-scoring team in the league?”
The right situation
So much of a young quarterback’s success depends upon the circumstances of his drafting team. The Cardinals, for example, took the extreme step of severing ties with Rosen eight months after he was drafted because they hired a new head coach, and Kliff Kingsbury preferred to work with a quarterback more familiar with his offense. So the Cardinals invested in another first-round quarterback in Kyler Murray, the No. 1 overall pick in this year’s draft.
And Rosen went from bad to worse. He’s the starter in Miami, where the Dolphins are tanking and could become one of the worst teams in NFL history.
It might happen to the extreme the way it has unfolded for Rosen, but young quarterbacks are thrust into bad situations all the time. The best franchises surround their young quarterbacks with quality talent and build around them.
The Ravens were committed to building around Jackson from the time they drafted him. Harbaugh hired Greg Roman as his offensive coordinator after last season, replacing Marty Mornhinweg, who oversaw the last few years of the Flacco era.
Roman, who had previous stops in San Francisco and Buffalo, came with reputation for developing strong running attacks. Through four games, the Ravens are averaging a whopping 206 yards per game on the ground.

It is true Jackson has made some big plays down the field through the passing game, but the Ravens are built around their running game. Ingram, who signed with the Ravens as a free agent after a successful run in New Orleans, has been a big part of that with 328 yards through four games.
But general manager Eric DaCosta also made surrounding Jackson with weapons an offseason priority. He added two receivers in the first three rounds of the draft. Marquise “Hollywood” Brown came in the first round and Miles Boykin in the third round. Brown is among the league leaders with 304 receiving yards and two touchdowns and Boykin has scored twice.
“There’s a lot of college-like stuff,” Steelers linebacker Bud Dupree said. “Lamar brought that mentality with him. He can make those types of plays. He’s stepped it up a notch. We have to make sure we contain him.”
A new age in the AFC North is upon us. Since 2008, Roethlisberger and Flacco helped to define this rivalry. They went head-to-head on 21 occasions, including three playoff games at Heinz Field. Roethlisberger won 12 of them; Flacco 9. The first career matchup between Rudolph and Jackson will happen Sunday afternoon at Heinz Field.
“It’s going to be pretty crazy,” Jackson said. “No Ben, a whole new team, a new era. We just have to get ready for it.”
If the Steelers beat the Ravens and the Browns lost to the 49ers on Sunday, the Steelers, Ravens and Browns will be tied atop the AFC North. That could make for an interesting final few months of the season.
And if their quarterbacks develop as their teams hope, it could be the start of something that will last years.
“We’ll see what happens,” Rudolph said. “There are a lot of great players in this division. It just so happens we’re in the same draft class. It’s going to be fun.”
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.
Steelers-Ravens: Gerry and Ray look ahead to Week 5 matchup at Heinz Field






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.