Brian Batko: Hi. Busy weekend in Pittsburgh sports, eh? And now it's Monday Night Football time, Steelers vs. Bengals, somebody's 0 has to go. Unless there's a tie. Please, no tie. Let's chat.
Thumper95: Hey Brian:
What are the chances if the Steelers flop on their faces tonight, Keith Butler gets demoted to just linebackers coach and Teryl Austin gets a shot at coordinator?
Brian Batko: I can't see the Steelers doing that midseason, but hey, they'd never traded a first-round pick before in the Super Bowl era, either. As far as Teryl Austin goes, sure, he has some NFL DC experience. But it's not as if his defenses were particularly good in Detroit and Cincinnati. Not that obvious of a guy to promote, is all I'm saying.
CCL: What up Brian.
Brian Batko: Just hangin' out, you?
Read More
Stephen : In light of the current poor defense against the run, might the Steelers turn to Tyler Matekevich?
Brian Batko: You never know, Stephen. Since I started covering the team in April, i've always thought he looks pretty solid in practice settings, but he's pretty much been used exclusively as a special teamer in the NFL, save for one start last year vs. Atlanta. Keith Butler said Friday that Mark Barron and Devin Bush need to be better and more physical against the run, and that does seem like something Matakevich could help with as Vince Williams remains out. But would Cincy be able to pick on him in coverage?
Tampa Too: Call me crazy but with Cleveland beating Baltimore if the Steelers win tonight they will once again control their own destiny. :)
Brian Batko: Hey, crazy. Yeah, this was a battle royal week for the AFC North. Suddenly, my Browns pick to win the division at the beginning of the season doesn't seem so stupid anymore. I still think the Ravens have the best shot because of how pleasantly surprised I've been by Lamar Jackson, but sure, the Steelers outlook changes a lot with wins tonight and next week against the Ravens. Both games at home. All is not lost yet.
BB: Brian - One of the theories behind the poor run game performance so far was the difficulty in run blocking from a two point stance for the O line when in shotgun...which is most of the time. When I was watching the Eagles this past Thursday night, they had no difficulty getting into their run blocks from a two point stance...they were opening nice holes. What gives? Thanks.
Brian Batko: More than that, I think it's that this offensive line was built to favor pass pro over run blocking, which makes sense. The Eagles also have Carson Wentz under center, so the Packers can't tee off on the run the way teams might do until Mason Rudolph shows a little more. But no doubt, the Steelers O-line has to get a little nastier and beat some dudes off the ball to help out this ground game.
ALB: Hi, Brian. In your opinion is there anything that could transpire this season that could cost MT his job, or does the loss of Ben give him a pass no matter what happens?
Brian Batko: I mean, there's always something that could happen. Unless Art Rooney guaranteed somewhere that Tomlin will be back in 2020 and I missed it. Like, what if the Steelers go 0-16? I think the odds of that are very low, but, ya know, that'd be hard for anyone to survive. For the most part, though, if everything about Ben's recovery goes as planned, there's an argument to make to get the band back together next season and let them take another run at it.
Andy: brian, it appears from watching the All22 film that the OC hasn’t changed the old isolation type of routes with AB, to more scheme oriented to help receivers get open. He does understand JuJu, DJ & JW have a combined 3 yrs of complete season experience?
Brian Batko: There were some guys open early on, and Mason Rudolph just missed them. You make a valid point, but hey, talent is talent regardless of experience and age. Obviously, no one expects Washington, Johnson or even JuJu to be the second coming of AB, but Fichtner what does this quote Friday from Fichtner tell you? "You've got to win one-on-one. You win one-on-one, don't worry about what the quarterback can or can't do, or isn't doing. To me, that's always the challenge individually ... It's not a want-to thing. It really comes down to man vs. man. You have to whip someone's ass."
Brian Batko: My apologies for the language if there are any young children in the chat. Why aren't you in school?
Greg: Would you take Martavious Bryant back at the league minimum at this point?
Brian Batko: No. Martavis Bryant has had enough chances, here and elsewhere. It's not like he ever played with or would have any kind of pre-established rapport with Mason Rudolph, anyway.
Roy: Judging from watching better teams play so far, I don't think the Steelers can compete. Even the Browns and Ravens appear much better. Giving up the number one pick next year may end up being a disaster for the Steelers. What do you think?
Brian Batko: I'm kind of with you there, Roy. From what I've seen from this Steelers team versus the quality of play I saw from Cleveland and Baltimore on both sides of the ball yesterday when I was watching, the going will be tough. I still don't mind the Fitzpatrick trade, though. Even if it's really high, as long as you believe Ben is coming back, what would you do with it? There'd be people arguing for a trade down anyway.
CCL: Hi Brian. Game score prediction for Steelers-Bengals?
Brian Batko: I'll save that for the end of the chat. The ol' tease n'at.
Steeler Nation · Peasant '63: The head coach sez, rather than "embracing" it... he is going to "absorb" the negativity. Is that counterintuitive for a man known as "Teflon"?
Brian Batko: I don't know, man, I wasn't a Physics major
Brian: Do you think the Steelers window has closed with this group of players to challenge for a Super Bowl run ?
Brian Batko: No, I really don't. I think that's probably out the window now, unless Mason Rudolph really figures something out, and soon. But there are still pieces in place for this defense to be good again next year. All depends on Ben's health and effectiveness.
Texas Steeler: Wouldn't you know it... The over/under for my "Vontaze Burfict Gets Suspended" pool was 4 games. Looks like the house wins everything!
Brian Batko: Aw, nuggets. I had him in a prop bet vs. Richie Incognito.
jacklambert58: If the Steelers don't win tonight Tomlins job has to be on the line no
Brian Batko: No
LA Matt: Will Moncrief ever see the field again in a Steeler uniform?
Brian Batko: Great question, Matt. As I wrote in this week's Skinny Post newsletter (which you can subscribe to at the top right of this page and I'd be delighted if you did), can two (really bad) games really erase the body of work on which you evaluated a guy to sign him this offseason? Moncrief didn't take that bait when I essentially asked him as much in the locker room this week. There'd be some salary cap issues to deal with if they cut him, but possibly also a compensatory draft pick in return. It's an interesting story line to keep monitoring.
Brian Batko: I guess I should answer the question, at least. I'll guess no.
James from Philly : Thanks for the chats! Any work on how P. Lynch has performed in practice? Will he soon unseat Hodges?
Brian Batko: My pleasure. He hasn't been especially impressive or anything, but yeah, his experience in this league might eventually get him the No. 2 job. Depends just how much this staff believes in "Duck." He's one quack away, you know
NickFromVA: Do you think there's any chance that we'll see Mason Rudolph under center more tonight? To me, that is one of the biggest reasons the running game is having a hard time getting started. The O-line can't line up and tee off against the D-line.
Brian Batko: Oh yeah, I think we will. The question is how much. He did take some snaps under center last week, just not many. Against an 0-3 team that isn't doing anything terribly well, there's something to be said for getting back to basics and just having your guys beat their guys.
Morey: Hey Brian...do think the Steelers playbook needs revamping? It seems the offense is unimaginative and predictable. For instance, when (if ever) have you seen a fake screen to one side and then a screen to the other side?
Brian Batko: Sean Morey, is that you? Honestly, I'm not going to pretend to be some brilliant football mind. Wouldn't be fair to me or you or the folks who actually are. Randy Fichtner tried quite a bit of motion with Diontae Johnson last week, including the very first play, when he ran through the backfield pre-snap and stopped as if he'd be an option for a screen. But no, to your question, I can't really point to or think of off the top of my head a play design through three games this season that really blew me away.
jake: i was looking at some of our previous drafts and can you believe that Hargrave and Matechevich are the only players from the 2016 draft that have a chance to be on the team next year. talk about a wasted draft
Brian Batko: That's kind of a backhanded reasoning for why I don't hate the trade for Nick Vannett. It's not like the Steelers have been nailing any fifth-round picks anyway. Even the two guys you mention might be gone next year. At least Jerald Hawkins netted them a draft pick from Tampa Bay when they dealt him preseason. Artie Burns, even at the time it seemed, they reached for. Sean Davis, maybe him too. But remember that the Bengals grabbed William Jackson one pick before the Steelers in the first round, and they chose to settle for the next best corner.
Pitt Panther in NC: Could Ben have screwed us by insisting on Fichtner and a short pass offense? Also minimizing running game? I read the Steelers do anything he wants.
Brian Batko: I don't think I'm going to criticize Ben for negatively affecting a Steelers offense that he's no longer able to be part of right now.
Randy F.: Wouldn't it be neat to run a bunch of sidecar hand-offs tonight?
Brian Batko: Pony backfield, baby, lay it on me.
Steeler Nation · Peasant '63: At this point... isn't Pick 33 the best we can hope for, since it would force ARII to consider cleaning house? Of course, by example, it's doubtful that he's capable.
Brian Batko: Love the optimism, Mr. Peasant. Why so much hand-wringing about possibly trading the No. 1 pick when you could be psyched about having the first pick in the second round?
Tom Stephens: Steelers will win by 10 tonight.
Brian Batko: OK, Tom
Lettuce Wynn: Are the Steelers catching up to the rest of the NFL, especially the Pats, in using FA and trades to bolster the team? Building through the draft is so 2010
Brian Batko: Possibly. Good piece from Ray Fittipaldo this week on exploring different approaches, and he talked to a couple former execs about it. If you haven't read it, check it out: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/09/29/miami-dolphins...
Kramer: I'm excited for Rudolf I still believe he can be our future but our o line needs to get it together what's your assessment on rudolf so far? I know hes only started 1 game by the way love the chats!!!!
Brian Batko: Thank you, Kramer. My assessment is that it's too early to tell. He was very shaky in the first half last week - indecisive, not comfortable in the pocket, missing a couple chances downfield. But he looked a lot better in the second half, thank you very much, Mr. Verrett.
Huh?: I am always surprised when some asks (You, Gerry or Ray) a question, you give your opinion, then they go off on you. Are any of you just sitting at your desk scratching your head?
Brian Batko: I'm actually sitting at my kitchen table right now, occasionally stroking my beard. We're pretty used to how this goes by now.
ClownShow: So the Steelers most likely lose tonight. Have you guys at the PG scheduled your meeting yet to talk about who to blame tomorrow besides Tomlin?
Brian Batko: Huh?
Mark: Hi Brian. I bet Rudolph wishes he had the sure handed Jesse James to throw to. The decision to let the Outlaw walk is looking more stupid by the minute. What say you?
Brian Batko: Hey, Mark. I say Jesse James would certainly have been helpful this season, but probably not enough to justify the price tag ($22.6 million over 4) the Lions put on him. It's a logical argument, though.
Coach15: Y do we not hear management outright address the same excuses, they're paying performers/players BIG $$, & should demand better results--communication issues, penalties, poor special teams play, defense non-existent, clock management, & run-blocking are issues as a fan, I'm tired of hearing about-
Brian Batko: Kevin Colbert has a policy of not doing media in-season, as far as I know. If you couldn't tell by now following this franchise over the years, it's not a very reactionary group at the top.
NickFromVA: I think ClownShow was suggesting that you and your colleagues provide cover for Tomlin and the rest of the Steelers coaching staff after a loss. While I don't agree with him on that, I do think that the coaching staff gets too much of a pass. A lot of the issues I see with this team are coaching related.
Brian Batko: A chatter starting a question with "I think ClownShow was suggesting..." is why these exercises are fantastic
NickFromVA: I'm not so sure I agree this team is as bad as everyone thinks. Let's face it be they've lost to a 4-0 team, a 3-0 team, and a 3-1 team. And only the first one was a blowout. A few breaks in Pittsburgh's way, this is a 2-1 team. Do you really think they are that bad?
Brian Batko: No, I don't think they're the worst team in the AFC North, which is where they sit right now. But, uh, they might be. We'll find out a significant data point on that front in about 10 hours here. Nick you make a solid point that the schedule has been difficult, probably even more so than expected given how SF is playing. We knew that going in, though. I definitely predicted an 0-2 start, and said 1-3 was possible. Now, that's the best-case scenario. Obviously.
The Fleas in Dan Fouts beard: What's your addy?
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com
Ryno: If the Steelers end up drafting in the number ___ spot or above next year, you will be upset about trading away the first round pick for Fitzpatrick?
Brian Batko: Even if they get the top pick, I don't think it'll be that bad of a move. Have to imagine they at least entertained that calculation going into the trade, even if they weren't expecting to finish with the worst record in the league. But that all gets baked in to the decision, based on the likelihood of that happening.
Texas Steeler: How big a role does the new TE play this week? How much production can we expect from another teams backup TE?
Brian Batko: I think Nick Vannett will probably get the start, for better or worse. Even though he's not ruled out, I can't imagine Vance McDonald playing. Vannett has a chance here to prove he's capable of doing more than Seattle asked of him. I also think Zach Gentry will be involved. If you're in some crazy deep fantasy league or do a daily thing for Monday night games or something, throw a dart at him.
Matt-Fl: Washington breaking out tonight?
Brian Batko: I'll say yes. But I predicted that last week too and it didn't happen that way. Could've had a long touchdown if not for drawing the DPI that directly resulted in Diontae Johnson's score.
You Listenin' Art?: Quick... How many 'S' in Steeler Nation?
Brian Batko: 1
Alex B.: The Steelers offense has gone into a shell, they played to conservatively in the first half against the 49ers, this defense is not going to hold opponents down. Why handcuff Mason Rudolph need to use all weapons and incorporated Samuels and Washington more.
Brian Batko: Starkey is that you? https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/joe-starkey/2019/09/28/jaylen-samu...
Greg: Hey Brian. You’re reporting is insightful and refreshingly upbeat. Very appreciated! What’s the best question you’ve received so far this year? This one?
Brian Batko: Yes, this one, by a mile
Duke: Hi Brian...I hope the recently departed Sam Davis will be inducted into the next Steelers Hall of Honor. I believe the late Steelers captain has been under appreciated since his retirement, partly because he did not call attention to himself while playing and also due to his post/retirement health problems which kept him out of the public eye. Your thoughts?
Brian Batko: Thanks for the question, Duke. Sam Davis is well before my time. But from what I know of him, he'll certainly be in future discussions for that wing of Steelers history.
Brian: Hey now, JP Holtz caught a pass yesterday ! Looks like he may have found a home, his active roster guarantee ends this week and will be subject to waivers if the Bears do not keep him on the 53, do you think the Steelers would bring him in if available ?
Brian Batko: That'd be great. My guy George Aston is also a free agent, too. But clearly, the Steelers aren't putting much stock into bolstering the fullback position while Roosevelt Nix is out. Think he might be back soon, anyway.
KC: Brian: any news on Ben's surgery? Media reports are that he had it last week in LA. Any current news on recovery time?
Brian Batko: Nope, not that I've seen or heard. Probably a question for Mike Tomlin at his next weekly presser.
SD Stiller: Any idea how AB did on his paper that was due last night?
Brian Batko: I have a call in to Central Michigan, waiting to hear back
ClownShow: Notice how the can't answer that question NickFromVA. They are like MSNBC for Tomlin. Nothing but excuses and place blame elsewhere to protect their golden Rooney rule goose.
Brian Batko: You're right, we've never criticized Mike Tomlin. Well, except for Ray Fittipaldo giving "coaching" an F, F and a D in three games this season in his postgame report cards https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/09/08/steelers-patri... https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/09/22/49ers-steelers... https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/09/22/49ers-steelers...
Tom Stephens: Let's get Benny Snell in the game more, don't you agree?
Brian Batko: Yeah, he's provided some pop on a few limited attempts. There aren't too many touches to go around between the three RBs, but I still like Snell.
Guest: Im with you on the Fitzpatrick Trade. Regardless of where they pick, they were likely going to target a safety high in the draft anyway. If they Picked a Safety in Round 1 that was as good as MF, we would all consider that a successful draft pick.
Brian Batko: Basically, yes. This isn't a team that is ready to blow it all up anytime soon.
sean: Thanks for the chats Brian!..Do you think the departure of Munchack is really effecting o line play? I thought since Serrett took over and was with him previously there would be minimal if any drop off in play.
Brian Batko: Not as much as some are speculating. They weren't running too well even under Munchak at the end of last year, and it's still a veteran group.
GPT: I like the Fitzpatrick trade. It keeps Tomlin and Colbert from picking a player with a 3rd round grade to fill a position of need. Anywho, did the Steelers mess up by exposing Skipper to waivers to keep the thoroughly replaceable Johnny Holton?
Brian Batko: Maybe. But how much would Tuzar Skipper be rotating in right now anyway? He'd probably be inactive, at least until Anthony Chickillo's injury. And hey, you call him thoroughly replaceable, I call him this team's No. 4 receiver right now.
Carl: What do you think of a mock football draft I saw which has the Steelers taking Wisconsin running back Jonathan Taylor in the second round next year? Personally, I don’t know if he will be available at that point. Thanks.
Brian Batko: No idea about Jonathan Taylor's draft stock, but I wouldn't use anything higher than a late round pick on a running back next year if I'm the Steelers. Too many other issues to deal with.
Pat: How many wins do you see this team having this year?
Brian Batko: Oh, geez. Well, I predicted 9-7 before the season. I'll move off that a bit, but not too far. How about 7-9? Remaining wins over Cincyx2, Miami, Jets, Cards, and some combination of Colts at home, Bills at home, and the two Browns games.
Kevin: Brian who's your pick tonight?
Brian Batko: Ah, yes, I did promise a prediction, didn't I? It'll probably be wrong. But what the heck. I'll go Steelers 31, Bengals 20. Sorry I couldn't get to every question. I never can. You can always email me or tweet me. Enjoy the game, everyone!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.