Living in Dallas, Landry Jones doesn't get many opportunities to see his former team play. But perhaps he’ll feel compelled to tune in for the Steelers-Bengals matchup Monday night, when a quarterback not named Ben Roethlisberger will start a meaningful game for the home team at Heinz Field for the first time since 2016.
That was Jones back then in that Week 7 clash with New England, a 27-16 Patriots win with Roethlisberger sidelined by a torn meniscus. Not a rare instance of the starter in Pittsburgh being injured, but throughout his 15 seasons as the No. 1, only every few years would a new replacement come along who’d have to make a cameo in lieu of the future Hall of Famer.
Mason Rudolph is just the latest one of the seven men who have had to step in and start for No. 7. He does so in a situation that’s similar — Roethlisberger is expected, at least publicly by the organization, to regain his status once healthy — but different, in that he’s the only quarterback who’s had to succeed the franchise cornerstone for an extended period.
“We’ve never seen this before in the 15 years that Ben’s been here,” former Steelers passer Charlie Batch said Friday. “Now that Mason is being thrown into the fire, we’re all figuring this thing out together.”
Looking over the shoulder
Rudolph, Jones, Michael Vick, Byron Leftwich, Dennis Dixon, Batch and Tommy Maddox. That’s the list of those who have had to fill Big Ben’s big shoes from start to finish in a game.
Read More
The first crack at it for Rudolph last week at San Francisco didn't go particularly well: just 174 yards, two touchdowns, one interception, two sacks and a fumble on 14-of-27 passing in a 24-20 loss. But it was no worse than anyone else who made their first Steelers start under center since Roethlisberger’s first Pro Bowl appearance in 2008.

Worst of the bunch was Leftwich, who threw for 199 yards with no touchdowns and a pick in a Week 11 game in 2012. Best was Vick, with 124 yards and one touchdown and no turnovers on 19-of-26 passing. But one thing Dixon, Leftwich, Vick and Jones have in common? They all lost their first starts in place of Roethlisberger, whose two Super Bowl rings set a high bar for anyone playing the most pressure-packed position in this city.
“Man, everything just happened so fast that I didn't really have a lot of time to think about that,” recalled Jones, who actually jumped in for Vick initially, until Vick went down with his own injury.
Roethlisberger has never missed more than five games in a season, but he will this season due to surgery on his right elbow. Historically, he’d go down for a few possessions here and there, sometimes a week or two or three, and then the gunslinger would get back out there, occasionally even sooner than anticipated.
For Jones, who’s now out of the NFL and preparing to play next year in the upstart XFL, he doesn't want to put words into Rudolph’s mouth and has no interest in trying to get inside his head. But Jones does know what he felt when he was a fourth-round pick trying to discern his role in the Steelers quarterback room, five years before they used a third-rounder on Rudolph.
“That was always the sucky part about being in Pittsburgh, is it was kind of one of those things that, it was what it was. It didn't matter what I was going to do, Ben was going to come back and be the starter,” Jones said Wednesday. “That was always kind of hard to deal with and hard to swallow.”
Jones didn’t mention the 2015 home game against Cleveland, three weeks after he made his first career start at Kansas City, but Batch did. Batch was in his third year of retirement, but remembers well how Jones made his second NFL start that day. Roethlisberger was now dealing with a foot sprain, so Jones was back in the saddle, but it didn't last long.
Jones hurt his ankle in the first quarter, and on came Roethlisberger, with plenty of time to put up 379 yards and three touchdowns in a 30-9 blowout of the Browns. Naturally, Roethlsberger started the rest of the season en route to the playoffs.
“We don't know what Mason’s capable of doing, because we’ve never seen it before,” Batch said. “So that’s the beauty of what we’re all witnessing at this point. Now that he gets to his second game, and you’re replacing Ben, it’s a totally different aspect. The only good thing about it is he doesn't have Ben looking over his shoulder — looking over his shoulder and helping — to the point of ‘If I mess up, they’re going to throw Ben back into the game.’ He doesn't have that.”
The nature of the beast
Of course, that circumstance could be a gift or a curse. It’s Rudolph’s team, for better or worse, but he’s a second-year quarterback with an undrafted rookie and a young journeyman signed 10 days ago behind him.
When Batch started eight games here from 2005-12, he did so as an old hand who was more experienced than Roethlisberger, who had been in Pittsburgh longer than him. He felt a sense of relief, of “Oh, he’s the veteran backup, he’s able to step in,” from his teammates.

Does Rudolph engender that kind of confidence? Only those behind closed doors and in tense huddles can say for sure, but Batch sees this as a rare opportunity for a young Steelers quarterback in a number of ways. No. 1, Rudolph can mold the offense to his tendencies and vice versa. Filling in for Roethlisberger for a brief stint might have been more about adapting to how the scheme worked with him, but Rudolph is in this for the long haul.
“Whether it’s the command of the huddle, his command at the line of scrimmage, his cadence,” Batch said. “His cadence can be completely different to what Ben’s is. Now, the offensive line has to adjust to that, where before, you would have to be accustomed to what Ben was doing at the line of scrimmage, how his cadence was, because that’s what the offensive line was used to.”
But Batch also points out that Rudolph can make the most of an upside that never came to fruition for Jones before him.
“In Mason’s case, it doesn't matter how great he plays. Next year, it’s Ben’s job,” Batch said. “But he has to prove that he can play. He’s trying to carve out what the rest of his career can potentially look like. If he plays lights-out, then they can say, ‘You know what, we have a starter in waiting,’ and there are many different options. If he doesn't, then questions will continue to be answered as the year goes on heading into next season.
“And that’s the whole nature of the league right now if you don’t play at a younger age. They don't have the luxury of sitting around and figuring out if you can do it in Year 5. They move on.”
That’s essentially what happened with Jones, who saw his roster spot surprisingly disappear entering last season with the addition of Rudolph combined with Josh Dobbs winning the backup competition. Not that he sounds the least bit bitter about it.
“I always liked Mason,” said Jones, who spent 2018 spring workouts, training camp and preseason with Rudolph. “He came in, he worked hard, was easy to get to know, had a good personality. He was always a good dude. I really hope he does well.”
For Rudolph, the scrutiny and criticism will only intensify from here. This week, the whole country can see whether or not he improves on his first shot to spell Roethlisberger. If it feels like the weight of a season, the stress of an 0-3 start and the eyes of a city are on his back, he won’t admit it. If he feels like he has to “be Ben,” he isn't saying.
“No,” Rudolph shook his head Friday. “The goal is to win wherever you’re at. That’s what I’ve always done. I’m a winner. That’s how I feel, and that’s what we’re going to do.”
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.