Kevin Colbert, an avowed hockey fan, is starting to take on some of the same qualities as general managers in the National Hockey League. Maybe his friendship with cross-town peer, Jim Rutherford, is starting to rub off.

Or maybe it’s just what’s happening in the NFL.

Whatever the reason, Colbert has swapped his button-down approach to team building for a gambler’s mindset, being willing to wheel and deal and make trades to strengthen the Steelers, sometimes out of necessity. Usually those reasons are injuries, lack of depth or just plain lack of talent.

And how has he done since joining the Steelers nearly 20 years ago?

Advertise with us

Well, one thing is apparent: Colbert has never been shy about making deals and maneuvering picks on draft day. His willingness to do so has resulted in the Steelers being able to draft some of their biggest stars — Troy Polamalu, Casey Hampton, Santonio Holmes and now Devin Bush.

But, lately, the deal-making hasn’t stopped there​.

Since the beginning of the 2017 season, not counting draft-day maneuvering, Colbert has engineered 11 trades involving a player and a draft choice and one involving a player for a player, another NFL rarity.

Four of those have occurred in the past month, including the latest — acquiring backup tight end Nick Vannett from the Seattle Seahawks for a fifth-round choice in 2020. That is the same pick the Steelers acquired when they sent quarterback Josh Dobbs to the Jacksonville Jaguars three weeks ago.

Of those 11, six involved the Steelers sending one of their own players for draft choices, none more significant than when he shipped wide receiver Antonio Brown to the Oakland Raiders for a third- and fifth-round pick six months ago.

Advertise with us

The other five involved the Steelers using a future draft choice to acquire a player, the most notable being when they gave up a No. 1 pick in the 2020 draft to the Miami Dolphins for safety Minkah Fitzpatrick last week. Other draft choices were involved in the deal.

By my count, using the Steelers’ documented history of transactions and other sources, Colbert has made 26 trades involving players for draft picks since joining the franchise in 2000. Of that, 15 were players the Steelers acquired in the trade. Only four of those lasted longer than one year — Vance McDonald (3), Byron Leftwich (3), Ryan Switzer (2) and Bryant McFadden (2). Fitzpatrick will be five, but it remains to be seen what happens with Vannett, who is a free agent at the end of the season.

The nine players who were one-and-done were wide receiver Freddie Milons from Philadelphia (2003), running back Patrick Cobbs from New England (2006), kick returner Allen Rossum from Atlanta (2007), guard Levi Brown from Arizona (2013), cornerback Brandon Boykin from the Eagles (2015), kicker Josh Scobee from Jacksonville (2015), cornerback Justin Gilbert from Cleveland (2016), cornerback DaShaun Phillips from Washington and safety J.J. Wilcox from Tampa Bay (2017).

The worst of those deals was Boykin because the Steelers gave up a fifth-round pick to get him and had trouble getting him on the field. None of the others involved anything higher than a sixth-round pick. But for sheer disasters, Scobee, who was acquired along with his $3.425 million salary for a sixth-round pick, lasted just four games after missing two late field goals in a prime-time loss to the Baltimore Ravens.

But the Steelers have also been able to use draft picks acquired in trades to their benefit. When the Steelers reacquired McFadden in 2010 for a fifth-round pick (a pick they acquired from the New York Jets in a trade for Santonio Holmes), they also received a sixth-round pick as part of the deal with the Cardinals. They used that choice to draft Antonio Brown.

Advertise with us

When they traded punter Brad Wing to the New York Giants in 2015, they used the seventh-round pick they received to draft linebacker Tyler Matakevich, one of their special-teams stars.

When they traded receiver Martavis Bryant to the Raiders for a third-round pick on draft day, that acquisition allowed them to trade with Seattle and move up to take Mason Rudolph.

The third-round pick they received in the Brown deal was used to take wide receiver Diontae Johnson, who could be a rising star. It remains to be seen what becomes of tight end Zach Gentry, who was drafted with the fifth-round pick the Steelers received from the Raiders.

Through the years, Colbert has dealt just three fifth-round picks to acquire a player. Is that risky? Well, consider: Since 2010, only five of the 17 fifth-round picks taken by the Steelers have lasted more than one season. The only time Colbert gave up something higher than a fourth-round selection was in the trade for Fitzpatrick.

That deal will likely go a long way toward evaluating Colbert’s history of trade-making and whether or not he was a successful wheeler-dealer. It could rank right up there with the 1996 draft-day trade that happened before his arrival — getting Jerome Bettis in what is considered the greatest deal in franchise history. Or he will continue to get criticized for doing something Dan Rooney would never do — trading away a future No. 1 pick.

Advertise with us

The trade for Vannett could be just another one-and-done acquisition, like the nine before it. Or it could work out like it did with McDonald.

In the financial world, 90% to 95% of day traders lose money. The success rate is between 3.5% to 4.5%. OK, Colbert’s commodities are not as volatile as the stock market. But his success rate is much better than that, even if you can’t shake the memory of Brandon Boykin and Josh Scobee.

The name game

In case anyone has forgotten or didn’t even know, Mason Rudolph was an accomplished player on the PGA Tour who won five times between 1959 and 1970 and once played on the U.S. Ryder Cup team.

Rudolph is no relation to the Steelers quarterback, but they do share a connection.

Advertise with us

Mason Rudolph the quarterback said he shares the same name because his dad, Brett, a former linebacker at North Carolina, was given the middle name “Mason” after the golfer. Like his dad and grandfather, Rudolph’s given first name is actually Brett, but he goes by Mason.

“I’m actually a ‘second,’ ” Rudolph said, referring to his proper suffix, Mason Rudolph II.

Oddly, Rudolph the golfer’s first name was actually “Edgar.” But he went by his middle name “Mason.”

Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac