The Steelers offensive line misses Mike Munchak.
They’re old.
They’re overrated.
These are some of the theories when it comes to the puzzling problems that face new offensive line coach Shaun Sarrett as his unit struggles to find its footing early in the season.
This is a line that produced three Pro Bowlers last season — right guard David DeCastro, center Maurkice Pouncey and left tackle Alejandro Villanueva. Under Munchak’s tutelage, it had been ranked among the top lines in the NFL in recent years by almost every website that tracks offensive line play. Pro Football Focus, for instance, ranked the Steelers No. 1 at the end of last season.
That’s why it’s so difficult to figure out why they’re struggling so much.
Read More
The running game is a mess. The Steelers are tied for the fewest rushing attempts in the league through three games. They are averaging 64 yards per game and just 3.8 yards-per-carry.
They’ve had one run of 20 yards or more — a 23-yard run by rookie Benny Snell in Week 2 against Seattle. The Ravens, who are the top rushing team in the league, had five runs of 20 yards or more. The Vikings, who are second in rushing, have eight for 20 or more.
So what’s wrong?
“I don’t know,” DeCastro said Thursday.
The normally affable DeCastro wasn’t in much of a mood to discuss on what’s ailing the line.
“Just be better, I guess,” he said. “There’s no fine science to it. It’s kind of a broken record to this point — run the ball, protect him.
“It just sucks being 0-3, to be honest.”
Steelers offensive line play needs to improve, Mike Tomlin says
Here’s one reality for Steelers fans to digest as they get ready to watch the Steelers play the Bengals on Monday night:, the offense isn’t going to drastically change.
There have been calls for the Steelers to adapt their offense in the wake of Ben Roethlisberger’s season-ending elbow injury. Running the ball, or so the theory goes, will help take the pressure of second-year quarterback Mason Rudolph, who will be making his second career start.
Put Rudolph under center.
Put in a fullback.
Let the linemen play from 3-point stances — with one hand in the ground — and play with a downhill demeanor.
All of it sounds good in theory, but the Steelers have been a predominant shotgun, pass-first team for the past five seasons or more. It would be nearly impossible for offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner to make wholesale changes in the middle of the season.
In Rudolph’s first start, he took five snaps from under center. Forty-eight of the 53 snaps were from the shotgun formation, including the first 15. The Steelers did not have Rudolph under center until 11:35 remained in the second quarter. Twenty-six of the 29 snaps in first half were from the shotgun.
“Yeah that sounds good, but it’s a new NFL. It really is,” Villanueva said. “Whether we like it or not, we drop back and pass all the time. That’s not a deal for offensive linemen because the winning rate is going to drop [if you pass protect from a 3-point stance]. When you get in a two-point stance, you’re going to help yourself a little bit. We’ve been a gun team for so long even if we run. If you throw the ball out of a formation and your hand is on the ground, it’s very difficult to get up and do what we do with our vertical sets, the new techniques that we’ve been doing for a very long time.
“When I watch other offenses I think, ‘How cool would it be to put your hand down and just run misdirection passing plays all day, play-action, blah, blah, blah.’ But you can’t look outside at what everyone else is doing. As a team, we have to come up with a better plan, play better, execute better.”
On the subject of missing Munchak, Villanueva dismissed the speculation. Sarrett coached under Munchak for five seasons. Most of what the Steelers are doing now is the same as when Munchak was the coach.
“That’s a tough question to answer because you can’t compare, the what ifs,” Villanueva said. “I’m not missing anything as a player from Coach Sarrett or Randy. The plays are very similar in many ways. We are missing some personnel. [Fullback] Rosie [Nix] hasn’t played, and he’s a huge part of our offense. But in the end, there are a lot of factors, a lot of variables, trying to pinpoint and look for one specific reason is very difficult. I don’t look at anything outside of my control. All I can control is to play better.”
Steelers looking to bounce back against the Bengals
The Steelers better hope the problems are fixable and rooted in game situation failures more than scheme and personnel. Four of the five starters are under contract through at least the 2020 season. And the Steelers control the rights of right tackle Matt Feiler, who will be an restricted free agent in the spring.
The Steelers have $37 million allocated to their offensive linemen this season and $40 million next season. Only six teams currently have more money invested in their lines.
Where the Steelers might have some concern is the age of their starters. Foster is 33, Villanueva 31, Pouncey 30. DeCastro turns 30 in January. DeCastro and Pouncey are signed through 2021.
Roethlisberger told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in January that the Steelers had to re-sign Pouncey before he would sign his new contract. The Steelers signed Pouncey to a three-year contract that pays him an average of $11 million a season. They also — in somewhat of a surprise move — signed Foster to a two-year contract worth $8 million.
Due to the long-term contracts and the salary cap, big changes, even if they were deemed necessary, likely won’t happen. The best hope is the line can rediscover what made it one of the best lines in the league in recent years — and for it to happen soon.
“A lot of it falls on our shoulders, but it’s still a team sport,” DeCastro said. “I think everyone in this league takes pride in what they do. Up front, we’ve been doing it a long time together. We definitely hold each other accountable.”
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.