Analytics can often be a source of hope for struggling teams. They can identify strengths that can be masked by simple observation and highlight trends that hint at the possibility of a breakthrough.

Unfortunately for the Steelers, there’s not a whole lot of underlying good news hiding in their performance through three games. Some key advanced metrics suggest their play has been as lackluster across the board as their winless record suggests.

Among those metrics: Football Outsiders’ defense-adjusted yards above replacement (DYAR) and defense-adjusted value over average (DVOA.)

DYAR is popular because it quantifies the yards above or below what an easily-acquired replacement could produce in a similar team environment, with consideration given to the quality of competition. Think of it as football’s WAR, just expressed in terms of yardage. You can get a more thorough explanation of the methodology here.

Advertise with us

DVOA, meanwhile, “represents value, per play, over an average player in the same game situations,” according to the Football Outsiders website.

This one is more complicated because, as the site explains, “By definition, an average level of performance is better than that provided by half of the league and the ability to maintain that level of performance while carrying a heavy workload is very valuable indeed.” So, something to keep in mind as we look at these numbers.

Position by position, these two stats offer some grim assessments.

Quarterbacks

Bad before Ben Roethlisberger’s season-ending elbow injury. Bad after it, too. Combined, Roethlisberger and backup Mason Rudolph have produced -133 DYAR, which would put them fourth from the bottom when considered as a unit. Only Arizona’s Kyler Murray (-190) and Miami’s truly horrific duo of Ryan Fitzpatrick (-208) and Josh Rosen (-239) have been worse.

Advertise with us

By contrast, Kansas City’s Patrick Mahomes leads the league at 555 DYAR, and most of the league leaders have topped the 200 mark.

The DVOA situation isn’t much, if at all, better. Roethlisberger ranks 30th at -22.4% in the category, while Rudolph is at -38.7%, ahead of just three other signal callers.

Running backs

That “fourth from the bottom” thing is becoming a theme, because that’s where James Conner stands at his position among backs with at least 24 carries. That holds for both DYAR (-35) and DVOA (32.4%.) Only Philadelphia’s Miles Sanders (-65/-54.6%), Seattle’s Chris Carson (-57/-40.4%) and Cinncinati’s Joe Mixon (-41/37%) have been worse.

Some consolation for Steelers fans: former back Le’Veon Bell (-21/-19.3%) has not been much better with the New York Jets.

Advertise with us

Baltimore’s Mark Ingram leads the league at 124 DYAR and 56.7% DVOA.

Receivers

JuJu Smith-Schuster’s long catch and run for a touchdown Sunday in San Francisco helped him pad his counting stats, but the advanced numbers see through his boom-or-bust season to this point.

Football Outsiders has him barely above the baselines in both DYAR (33) and DVOA (5.7%.) The numbers are far from bad, relative to those of some of his teammates. He’s 33rd in each category. Still, the Steelers were probably looking for more from their newly minted top receiver who ranked in the top 20 — ahead of former teammate Antonio Brown — in both rankings a year ago.

What’s worse, most of his teammates aren’t even close to “mild disappointment” territory. James Washington has the second-best numbers of the team at a pedestrian -5 DYAR and -8.2% DVOA. He’s followed by Dionte Johnson (-27/-37.3%), Ryan Switzer (-35/53.1%) and Donte Moncrief, whose numbers are spectacularly bad at -76 and -101.7%, by far the worst among players with between four and 11 receptions.

Advertise with us

The leaders in DYAR are well over 100 with DVOA values between 23.7% and 95.7%

Tight ends

Good news! Vance McDonald’s numbers (20/16.1%) rank pretty well. He’s 13th in DYAR and 15th in DVOA at his position.

The bad news, obviously, is that his health status is up in the air, and he hasn’t been as active in the passing game as some would like, even if his numbers remain fairly solid.

Offensive line

Advertise with us

Football Outsiders grades lines using different statistics that make clear the Steelers’ blockers are just as culpable for the running game’s struggles as Conner and the running backs.

Adjusted line yards attempts to measure blockers’ effectiveness with a stat that mimics yards per carry for running backs. You can read more about the methodology here.

The Steelers rank 25th in the NFL in this category at 3.65 yards, well behind the league leaders, who are averaging more than 5 yards.

The pass blocking, at least, has been solid. The Steelers rank fifth in adjusted sack rate (3.8%), “which gives sacks (plus intentional grounding penalties) per pass attempt adjusted for down, distance, and opponent.”

Defensive line

Advertise with us

These same stats work the opposite way for fronts on the opposite side of the ball. Unfortunately for the Steelers, there are no bright spots here.

On the ground, they rank 25th — the same as their offensive peers — in adjusted line yards at 4.64, well behind the leaders who are in the 2 and 3 range. And the pass rush grades similarly. Their adjusted sack rate is 22nd at 5.6%.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.