Brian Batko: Hello, everyone. The Steelers are one of five 0-3 teams in the NFL, all in the AFC, but the Redskins might join them tonight. The players are off today after traveling back from the West Coast. Gerry Dulac and Ray Fittipaldo are still making their way back, too, but I watched from home, so I'm here for the vent session. Away we go...
Doug from Raleigh: The O line doesn't seem as effective as in the recent past. I see people on all the usual chat sites and forums are blaming the loss of Munch, but I don't think you forget all your techniques over the off season. But you can get older and slower: so has age gotten its hooks in this group?
Brian Batko: Possibly. They were getting blown off the ball toward the end of the game, just as the defensive line was on the other side. Matt Feiler and Al VIllanueva gave up a couple bad pressures and sacks late. Still not a lot of push there for James Conner, either. To be fair, they have played three excellent fronts in three weeks.
tom: Is it just me or is the steelers offense way too predictable? Lining up in the shotgun almost every play seems very limiting. Shotgun runs are ineffective. Is the personnel not fitting a better scheme or is this just bush league coaching?
Brian Batko: I agree Tom, I was left scratching my head on why they kept going back to running out of the shotgun. Diontae Johnson motioning into the backfield pre-snap didn't seem to be fooling anyone. From a personnel standpoint, I do think they finally have some clarity in their receiving corps for the first time in their post-AB world. Didn't seem like a great game plan from OC Randy Fichtner though.
Nick: Brian, I had heard that for home games, some teams spend Sat night together in a local hotel. Do Steelers do that? if so what would be the purpose in it?
Read More
Brian Batko: Hey Nick, I don't believe so. I could be wrong, but I think you see that more in college football. Pitt definitely does it on the Friday night before Saturday home games, just to stay focused and locked in. Shouldn't need that sort of thing for a pro football team, in my opinion.
Mike: The troubling thing to me about yesterday was not just the fact that the Steelers forced 5 turnovers and STILL lost, but think about how bad it could have been if they weren't gifted some of those mistakes. With supposed abundance of talent on that side of the ball, at what point can we finally say the coaching, scheme, and lack of ability to make adjustments is the culprit, or at least a high percentage of the problem? (although I agree that offensive failures yesterday didn't help things). In crunch time though, defense for Steelers just hasn't gotten it done in recent years.
Brian Batko: When can we finally say it? Chatters have been saying it for weeks, months, years probably. But hey, both of the Steelers turnovers were gifts, too. Mason Rudolph's pick struck me as one you can throw when you're in a 52-45 game with Texas Tech in the Big 12, but not so much in an NFL slugfest on the road. And, obviously, James Conner's fumble was just inexcusable. Defense had its moments yesterday but again fizzled in the second half and couldn't get the job done late.
Steven: How many losses before Tomlin has to start worrying about his job security?
Brian Batko: I can't see the Steelers firing him midseason, but yeah, a second year in a row missing the playoffs would be bad. Doing it with your first losing record would be worse. Bottoming out in a year that you traded your first-round pick would be, well, nightmare scenario for a coach's job security.
Kyle: Does Fichtner have any any plays with the qb under center? The handoffs from the shotgun make it appear the Conner is slow getting to the line.
Brian Batko: Perhaps a majority of those plays are 21 personnel with Rosie Nix in at fullback. He's hurt, and while he barely factored in on offense in Week 1 this year and even last season, you have to imagine he'd be getting some run right now as a potential spark plug for the ground game. Also the TE situation went from bad to worse with Vance McDonald's injury. After the game, he was the only one Mike Tomlin made it sound like could be more than a day-to-day thing.
Chris Boswell: I'm back...hey, where did everyone go?
Steeler in Virginia: With an early pick in the second round of the 2020 draft, the Pittsburgh Steelers select: A: OLB B: WR C:TE? D: OL?
Brian Batko: I'm gonna go edge rusher. If the past couple drafts are any indication, there's a little more depth at that position these days, probably because of the flexibility of going with a college OLB or DE depending on scheme. Can't imagine Bud Dupree will be back, and not sure Ola Adeniyi will be counted on to fill that very important position in this defense.
Mean Jose: Brian, why can't the defense shut down the intermediate and crossing routes? The D can't get a stop because those routes are eating them alive. Are the coaches not good enough to figure out a scheme, is the personnel not able to perform, or is is some of both? By the way... If Minkah plays that well every game -- and he only had five days to prepare -- he is worth that #1 pick. I don't care if the Steelers pick 3rd overall, that's worth it.
Brian Batko: They're high-percentage throws for a reason. Sometimes it's not a bad play by a defense to give up something relatively short underneath. Scheming it up is a significant part, but to me, at some point, players have to do their job and execute. Not enough plays made yesterday. Take for instance the winning TD by the 49ers. That was just an instance of Dante Pettis beating two guys to the ball. No reason why Steve Nelson or Mark Barron shouldn't be able to break that up. They were in position.
Coachjpat : Third straight week that we have had extremely conservative play calls on offense during the first half. The offense is not doing our defense any favors. Time to open things up and allow Rudolf throw down the field?
Brian Batko: Yes. You saw what the offense was capable of once they did that. It helped that the 49ers had to throw in a cornerback who was a step slow and coming in cold, but still, Rudolph's at his best in the vertical passing game, I think. Right now you're 0-3, what do you have to lose? Go out and try to find an identity for your new-look offense and QB.
BIG TEX: Conner is a known fumbler and has cost us at least 3 games over the past 2 seasons. Is it time to admit he's not a premier back?
Brian Batko: I don't think those two things are mutually exclusive, Big Tex. Premier backs are gonna have the ball a lot, which means they're gonna rack up more fumbles. The guys with the most career fumbles in NFL history among running backs are Tony Dorsett, Franco Harris and Walter Payton. They were all pretty good. The discussions of Conner's ball security and Conner's effectiveness as a rusher are slightly different, to me.
Optimist: Am I the only one who thinks the Steelers can still make the playoffs? I'm calling it now 9 and 7 and a wildcard birth.
Brian Batko: As of right now, at least 22 people in this very chat agree with you.
Brian: Better quarterback in your opinion, Mason Rudolph or Baker Mayfield ?
Brian Batko: Still going Baker Mayfield, but it has not been a nice start to the season for him or the Browns. I'm starting to worry about my pick to win the AFC North.
Barry J.: Would Craig Meyer be a better choice for offensive coordinator?
Brian Batko: Oh, heck yeah. Craig would only call the good plays and get rid of the bad plays. No doubt.
ShouldadraftedSaquon: Is it safe to finally say that James Connor is NOT a feature NFL back? The Steelers don't need his feel good story to cost them any more games.
Brian Batko: OK, I'll say it: I've seen zero indication that James Connor can play in the NFL, let alone be a featured back.
PITTOCLT: Did anyone ask Tomlin if considered putting Hodges in at half time? I think 2 had around 40 yards passing at the half.
Brian Batko: No. But also, Rudolph got better in the second half. No one asked me either, but I think keeping Duck on the bench was a smart move.
Steven: Why isn't Jalen Samuels seeing the field? He is a better natural runner than Conner and doesn't have fumbilitis like JC. He is also a far superior pass catcher.
Brian Batko: Jaylen Samuels is seeing the field, he's just not seeing the ball, Steven. He played 14 snaps on offense, still a low number, but didn't touch it once. For whatever reason, I just don't think he was a big part of the plan coming into this one. That might have to change.
Steeler fan in MA: Should I be shunned because I think they might have a chance to turn this around? My optimism is with the defense, I think it could become pretty solid as the season progresses. Am I nuts?
Brian Batko: We're up to 26 who have your back.
dougp: Hi Brian, Thom Yorke is playing a solo show this week in PGH. Is Radiohead over-rated or under-rated?
Brian Batko: Not sure, I don't listen to them and never have.
Jake : I’m not saying Mason Rudolph played like a stud but I don’t think the blame of not getting in the end zone after all those turnovers should be placed on him. The offensive gameplay was way too conservative in the 1st half. They didn’t even attempt to let him throw the ball downfield. Sure hope that changes next Monday night.
Brian Batko: He looked way too indecisive to me early on, but hey, that's probably natural for a guy in his first NFL start. His decision-making improved from there, other than the pick. It should also be noted that throwing the ball downfield requires separation from your receivers. I haven't been able to watch the all-22 coach's film yet or anything, but it did seem to me there were a few times early on that he had JuJu in one-on-one coverage and it might've been smart to target him and let him make a play.
JerseySteel: Hi Brian - with all of the good DB's we now have on defense - why are there receivers open on virtually every play?
Brian Batko: I wouldn't say virtually every play, but on the plays you speak of, you need to have a pass rush. Stephon Tuitt has been a monster the past two games, but he's fading away in the second half. On San Fran's first go-ahead touchdown, he wasn't even on the field for that drive (or the next one when the 49ers went 3-and-out). Terrell Edmunds also hasn't been great, especially in the first half yesterday, he was noticeably a step behind on a few completions.
kevin in Punxsy: Hi Brian. Seems that Randy Fitchner isn't really a OC, he is just a guy who's best friend is a HOF QB. He, not Rudolph is responsible for the lack of 1st half scoring. Your thoughts???
Brian Batko: He's had a game and a half so far to adjust without said HOF QB. I'm not gonna crush the guy just yet.
CanadianSteelersFan : Hi Brian! No one should be blaming the defense for this loss. We all know that 6 points off 5 turnovers is unacceptable, but the time of possession would wear down ANY defense. Possession times of 2:00, 1:26, 2:40, and 3 and outs. No wonder the defense was tired in the 4th quarter! What can Randy do to increase possession time?
Brian Batko: Ha, this is a funny question given the line of thinking we've been on for much of this exercise. So many saying that the Steelers offense was far too conservative, but guess what? Running the ball is how you try to control the clock and a game. Can't have it both ways, folks. Therein lies the challenge of winning in the NFL. The other guys are trying too.
tcalantc: It seems so easy to beat the Steelers over the last 3-4 years. Throw over middle, to the TE, run the ball in the middle and don't let the Steelers throw mid-range over the middle. I've always liked coach Tomlin and want him to stick around as long as he wants, but it's getting to the point where you do have to look at scheme and coaching, don't you think? It's a bit absurd that every game is almost the same.
Brian Batko: Of course. You look at scheme and coaching after every game, win or loss. There's more heat on those guys right now than there's been in a while. If any team misses the postseason two seasons in a row, you likely won't see them take the same exact masthead into Year 3.
Paul: I say the Steelers win next 3 games your thoughts?
Brian Batko: Bengals, Ravens, at Chargers? My thoughts boil down to: No.
Kennewick: I think the turnovers keep the Steelers from being blown out by 3 or more TDs. Thoughts?
Brian Batko: Ehh not necessarily. They also turned it over twice themselves. It was a weird game all around.
HBCTP: Can you point to any observer who believes the Steelers are a well-coached team?
Brian Batko: Paul up there, I guess.
Bob from the Poconos: Any word on Vance's injury and availability? Not having a viable back up was a huge gamble.
Brian Batko: Nope, Tomlin said his shoulder's being evaluated. Xavier Grimble didn't do much for me yesterday. Zach Gentry took some of his snaps late in passing situations. Grimble kinda strikes me as that fifth guy in basketball the defense doesn't bother guarding because he mostly just sets screens and passes the ball.

Craig in CA: I'm so frustrated watching 3rd and long get completed time after time with a wide open receiver or the wide open TE. Why can't they limit this???? Its crazy!!
Brian Batko: Remember that time they limited it only to have it erased by an obvious defensive holding penalty on a veteran linebacker away from the play? That was pretty crazy.
Guest: Worse free agent signing this year; Baron or Moncrief? We all know Moncrief's struggles but Baron has done nothing and looked terrible yesterday.
Brian Batko: I mean, it's still Moncrief, for sure. Didn't even get a "hat" in Week 3. But yeah, Barron was just really, really bad from my point of view. I don't think that'll be a fun film session for him. He looked slow most of the time in coverage, almost always trailing pass-catchers, and was washed out against the run, too. But who else are you gonna throw in there?
Chicken Little: Brian, The Steeler sky is really falling? What to you think is ahead? Sunshine or Rain?
Brian Batko: It's raining at my house for the first time in a couple weeks, it seems. What a run of weather we enjoyed, though.
bRiAn BaTkO: Hey, Brian! Love the name. Where is James Washington? Why is he not putting up huge numbers!? Now, he's got his college QB throwing to him. Thanks, Brian!
Brian Batko: He drew a very useful pass interference penalty yesterday. Might've been a TD for him and his old buddy old pal if not for that. He needs to get himself more involved, though.
Jimbo: To me it seemed like our middle linebackers aren't performing like many expected. Barron seemed to be a step behind on pass coverage and gets blown up on run plays. Also looks like he gives up on plays. How do you feel Bush has played so far? Worth everything we gave up for him?
Brian Batko: Devin Bush hasn't been as good as I expected so far. Definitely has a nose for the ball, as you saw on the fumble recoveries, but still looks lost too often in coverage.
James from Philly : Brian not a question.. You just said that you would not crush the guy just yet of Fichtner, please as a fan, crush this guy with difficult questions during his availability. If a casual fan can watch that game and see a pathetic game plan, an NFL OC should answer up to it.
Brian Batko: I can't imagine it will be a fun interview for him after practice Friday. But it wasn't after the Foxborough blowout, either. And he owned up to it, saying he got spooked away from running the ball.
Roger: Tomlin 2-7 over last 9 games.
Brian Batko: Roger that
Whoha: I didn't get to see the game in Florida but try to follow it on my app. Two questions: 1) on defense, is it out scheme or talent that's in question for not being to stop the other team when it counts? 2) Did the OC keep Ruldoph under wraps in 1st half with all the short passes?
Brian Batko: 1) Both 2) Rudolph was also getting flushed out of the pocket way too often. Not sure if receivers weren't getting open downfield or what.
Winning: How has Nelson done so far this season, in your opinion? You don't hear him mentioned much, and maybe that's good thing for a DB (?)
Brian Batko: Yeah I was just thinking that yesterday before the game. That is a good sign for a corner. He probably blew a couple assignments in Week 1 at New England, but who didn't? Lost a couple battles with rookie DK Metcalf against Seattle, but you can't win em all. I think he's been fairly steady. Good, not great.
Brian: How nice is it to see JP Holtz sign with the Bears ? It looks like he may have finally found a home with a defined role with this team.
Brian Batko: You love to see it. He was inactive last week, but hopefully will get a helmet tonight on MNF. Would be a great cherry on top of the football weekend for my Shaler Titans.
Gerry Dulac and Ray Fittipaldo break down the Steelers' loss at San Francisco
Steeler in Virginia: Rudolph hit Vance a couple times in that Seahawks second half, then went to him early before the injury. How important is the big TE for the offense to get going?
Brian Batko: Very important. I think yesterday's outcome might be different if they don't lose McDonald in the first half. That was another monkey wrench that Randy Fichtner had to adjust to on the fly. Tough with a second-year guy under center.
Kadel: Tomlin is a good CEO, but needs to be told hes been awful rebuilding this defense. He would need new coordinators moving forward.
Brian Batko: Well it's not really his job to rebuild the defense. That's up to Kevin Colbert. He put a lot of faith in Devin Bush and Mark Barron at the second level, and has put a lot of money into the D-line of a 3-4 team, not to mention bringing back Bud Dupree for his option year. All questionable decisions, more or less.
Todd: Defense gave up 168 yards rushing! Is that, below the line?
Brian Batko: yes, Todd
Thenamesdalton: Why do we continue to run WR screens when the defensive backs have no threat of getting beat over top and are therefore giving no cushion? Like running your head into a brick wall (which ironically is how I feel watching this offense).
Brian Batko: Better than TE screens
NonStandard: It seems this team just isn't good enough. They can't overcome their mistakes and those of the coaching staff like previous teams. Bad time to have given up a top 10 pick, even for Minkah, no?
Brian Batko: I still don't think so. That was gonna be one of, if not the biggest, positions of need in the 2020 draft regardless. And I really don't think they would've drafted a QB anyway.
WhoNu: Can Ben serve as interim OC? Couldn’t do worse could he?
Brian Batko: Now that'd be interesting.
Vastiller: What’s Fitzpatrick doing on the line not Edmonds?
Brian Batko: The safety spot is more interchangeable than a lot of people realize, I think.
Zack: Why not play Gilbert instead of Barron?
Brian Batko: Well, obviously they don't believe the rookie sixth-rounder Ulysees Gilbert is ready for that kind of role. He's been playing exclusively on special teams.
Pat: Do you see Keith Butler making it through the season?
Brian Batko: Yeah, this isn't the Browns we're talking about.
BB - Big Ben or Brian Batko? : Brian, is the world about to end? Or is this feeling just the result of an 0-3 start? Also, are you a Seinfeld and/or The Office fan?
Brian Batko: I woke up today. Still had all my faculties. My house was still standing. All good things. Never watched Seinfeld, but I'm sure I'd enjoy it. Haven't seen The Office all the way through, but I like it.
Le'Veon: Remember when you guys said Conner was good enough to replace me.....
Guest: Loved your Grimble hoops analogy. I would add: and when he does get to take the ball to the hoop he clangs the slam dunk off the rim. Thanks for the chats!
Brian Batko: Appreciate you, Guest.
rcc prof: Brian, I am under the impression that a lot of the steelers' problems on defense comes from not having a legitimate run stopper who can also push the middle. The run defense has not been good since Hampton retired and Tomlin and even Colbert have reasoned the game is changing. Is the game changing only for the steelers or is Tomlin and Colbert doing a Huntington spin on the fans?
Brian Batko: Javon Hargrave might not be making himself any money with the Steelers this season. Stephon Tuitt is finally starting to justify the big contract he got in some ways. But Cam Heyward? He hasn't been good enough these first three games. Has not been disruptive. And this D-line's depth isn't showing itself, either.
Juice: O-line was getting pushed around most of the game. Would it kill Finctner to roll Rudolph out of the pocket? Also, yet another game with limited half-time adjustments made by the coaching staff. Thoughts?
Brian Batko: I thought we'd see some more play-action, Juice. Or maybe some RPO stuff like Rudolph did in college? They need to get more creative, for sure. Especially if McDonald is gonna be down for any length of time.
Kryder: Second week in a row bud played against backup lineman and did little to nothing. Cant believe they shelled out 9 mill for him this year. You?
Brian Batko: Agreed. He couldn't take advantage of the dude filling in for Joe Staley at all. Been a disappointing start for him so far.
NonStandard: I think they're getting around $30M in cap space next year between Brown and Bud. Have to be big players in FA for once - not much on this team worth resigning to big $$
Brian Batko: They're gonna want to lock up TJ Watt and JuJu now, as they should. The Conner situation gets murkier by the game, for sure. Steelers spent some money this offseason in free agency, but uh, look where they are with it.
Tom: Brain, Is is time to give Buggs a shot? Thanks.
Brian Batko: I wouldn't say that. Maybe it couldn't hurt, but obviously he hasn't been showing enough in practice to warrant a hat.
this guy: Mason is young and he's going to make some mistakes. However, I think he has shown enough to think he can be a legit starter in the NFL. thoughts?
Brian Batko: Yeah I'm kind of with this guy. Way too early to write him off. He's faced a couple solid defenses.
Steven: Who is having the last laugh? Bell? AB? Ben? or the Steelers?
Brian Batko: No one's laughing right now, Steven. Bell is 0-3, AB is 0-9,00,000 and Ben is out for the year as his team languishes with a winless start. What's that phrase, mutually assured destruction? And now, this chat will self-destruct. Thanks, everyone!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.