The Steelers are going to get an early glimpse of the future when Mason Rudolph makes his first NFL start Sunday afternoon in San Francisco. By the time the Steelers get to the West Coast, they might want to figure out their offensive identity.
After two games, they don’t have one, and that’s been one of the biggest problems in their 0-2 start.
• The offensive line, which returns three Pro Bowlers, has underperformed. The run blocking is spotty and the pass protection, which has been terrific in recent seasons, hasn’t been nearly as good. The Seahawks were able to pressure Ben Roethlisberger and Rudolph consistently with three- and four-man rushes.
• Starting running back James Conner hasn’t been decisive on his runs or his runs after catches, and it’s costing the Steelers yards.
• But perhaps most importantly, with Rudolph as the new starter, the Steelers have to find a consistent receiver rotation. One week Ryan Switzer is playing two-thirds of the offensive snaps and the next week he’s playing less than a quarter of them. One week Donte Moncrief is a starter and playing 90% of the snaps and the next week he’s playing less than a third of them.
Mike Tomlin and Randy Fichtner should game plan around the team’s most reliable receivers and let Rudolph go to work with them.
Read More
Rudolph played well in his professional debut, and the offense actually improved after he replaced Roethlisberger. In 29 snaps, Roethlisberger led the Steelers to 10 points. The Steelers had three three-and-outs on his six drives and averaged 3.55 yards per play. In 28 snaps, Rudolph led the Steelers to 16 points and the Steelers averaged 5.6 yards per play.
When asked what he likes most about Rudolph, second-year running back Jaylen Samuels said: “He gets fired up. He has something about him when he’s doing something good. He gets everyone going.”
Tomlin and Conner also talked this week about “rallying” behind Rudolph, but it’s going to take much more than enthusiasm for the Steelers to work their way out of their current offensive funk. It’s going to take execution over the long haul.
More improvement is needed from the players surrounding Rudolph. The Steelers are converting just 26% of their third downs. That’s 26th in the league and way down from the 44% clip they converted last season.
The Steelers did a better job on first down against the Seahawks, but they failed miserably on second downs and once again failed to sustain drives.
Conner believes the inability to convert third downs on a consistent basis is what’s at the root of the problems in the run game.
“We just have to convert on third downs,” said Conner, who is averaging an anemic 2.6 yards-per-carry through the first two games. “There have been a lot of three-and-outs. It’s hard to get the run game going when you’re not converting on third downs. We’re not worried.”
Conner might not be worried, but some troublesome issues are bogging down the offense. Here are some examples:
On their first drive of the game Vance McDonald caught a pass for a 5-yard gain. But on second down, Conner was stopped for no gain after nose tackle Al Woods made a nice read and ran down the line of scrimmage to stop him before he could turn up field. On third-and-5, Alejandro Villanueva allowed Branden Jackson to go around him for a sack.
It was more of the same on the second drive. This time, McDonald caught a first down pass for a 7-yard gain, but Roethlisberger lost his footing on second down and threw an incomplete pass. On third down, Ryan Switzer was open, but Roethlisberger’s attempt was batted down by Jadaveon Clowney.
After picking up one first down on their third drive of the game, Clowney shed a Villanueva block and stopped Conner for a 2-yard gain on first down. On second down, with a three-man pressure, the Seahawks hurried Roethlisberger, whose pass fell incomplete. (These types of breakdowns — allowing heavy pressure on a three-man rush — are things that never used to happen to the Steelers’ offensive line. They can’t continue to let this happen with Rudolph under center.) On third-and-8, Roethlisberger overthrew Johnny Holton by inches on a deep ball.
For the Steelers, it’s not complete ineptitude but rather little mistakes and just-misses that are crippling their efforts. As Tomlin is fond of saying, it’s popcorn. Right now they’re an offense that’s prone to operating in fits and starts.
It wasn’t until Roethlisberger capitalized on a short field and led the Steelers to a touchdown on his fourth drive and a field goal on his final drive of the season that the offense showed any signs of life.
When Rudolph entered the game in the second half, it was more of the same. A disastrous first series ended with an interception that bounced off Moncrief’s hands. Seattle capitalized on the mistake and took the lead for good.
But the bounce-back from Rudolph was impressive. Three of his final four drives ended with points — a field goal and two touchdowns.
Gerry Dulac and Ray Fittipaldo look ahead to Week 3
How did it turn around?
The running game was a bit better with 57 of the 81 yards coming in the second half even though they trailed for most of the final two quarters. Fichtner can use play-action if the running game can find some traction in San Francisco.
It was a play-action pass — a 45-yard flea-flicker to Smith-Schuster — that caught the Seattle secondary off guard before some familiar Steelers breakdowns stalled Rudolph’s second drive. Pouncey could not hold his block on first down and Conner was stopped for no gain. On second down, Conner was tackled for minus-4 yards after catching a pass in the flat. On third down, Rudolph played for the field goal and threw short to JuJu Smith-Schuster.
Rudolph’s third drive was his best effort, and he got some help from his playmakers. Rookie receiver Diontae Johnson made an acrobatic catch to convert one third down. A short time later, Rudolph had a long scramble on a third-and-5 to keep the drive alive. Those two plays accounted for two of their three third-down conversions in the game. The 75-yard drive ended with another touchdown pass to McDonald.
Tomlin said the personality of the Steelers offense won’t change with Rudolph as the new quarterback, but the play selection will be curtailed.
“When you’re in there with Ben he can give you the whole playbook,” Samuels said. “There could be stuff you haven’t even run. It wasn’t even in the game plan, but he came up with it because he saw something in the defense. You get more variety of the playbook.”
It will be a long time before Rudolph will have that type of command of this offense. It’s only natural. Roethlisberger had 15 years of experience in it. Rudolph barely has one year.
For now, simpler might be better for the Steelers. A return to a different era of Steelers football — a strong running game, play-action passing and a good defense — could help Rudolph lead the Steelers to victories just as Roethlisberger did when he unexpectedly took over the reins of the offense as a rookie in 2004.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.