Gerry Dulac and Ray Fittipaldo look ahead to Week 3

Gerry Dulac: OK kids, sorry for the delay....locker room was open later than usual. Let's get started...go!!

Jeff M: Why did the Steelers choose now to do in all in type trade like the Fitzpatrick deal? Never seemed to consider them when Ben was healthy and you could almost guarantee the pick would be at least in the 20s.

Gerry Dulac: I'm not sure, but the big reason is the GM and the coach really liked Fitzpatrick. They also knew they probably weren't going to re-sign Sean Davis after the season and they would be drafting a safety in the first or second round anyway. That being said, while I really like the player, I don't ever like trading away a future No. 1. I can tell you this, Dan Rooney never believed in it and would never do it.

AugustWest: Minkah Fitzpatrick will play safety for the Steelers, but he reportedly prefers slot corner. Do you think there's a chance he moves to corner when/if Davis returns from injury, or do the Steelers have their safeties for the next decade?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: He will play safety, and with the injury to Sean Davis, I imagine he will stay there when they play their nickel and dime defenses as well. If he moves to the slot, which they might prefer instead of Mike Hilton, that means Kam Kelly has to come in at safety. And they don't prefer that

AugustWest: If Keith Butler can't carve a legitimate top-5 or 10 defense with this many first-round picks at his disposal (most of them young), should he still be the coordinator in 2020?

Gerry Dulac: Good question, but you should direct the question in terms of Mike Tomlin running the defense.

Kol Diamond: I don’t understand why the Steelers didn’t sign a veteran QB as a backup.

Gerry Dulac: They did, but they put him on the practice squad. But I think you will see Paxton Lynch move up to No. 2 fairly soon

Advertise with us

Jason: Morning Gerry! Do you foresee any schematic changes with the addition of Minka? Anything we should watch for in the coming weeks?

Gerry Dulac: Not anything right away because Mike Tomlin said they are going to keep him anchored at free safety for now until he learns them and they learn him.

seawolf: The Seattle QB is known for both his running ability and for "holding" the ball late in a game. Why wasn't a Steeler defensive player assigned to cover or "spy" on him, especially after his first run late in the game?

Gerry Dulac: I wondered the same darn thing. And why wasn't that Devin Bush, who is faster then Russell Wilson??

elcid97: Tomlin had LeBeau imposed on him and then Haley. Since last year, he's had his friends from his college coaching days as his coordinators. It seems like the more the Steelers are Tomlin's team, the less well-coached they look on the side of he's taken control of. It's now both sides. And it looks awful. Coincidence?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: It just might be!!

Maryann: The Ravens are finally playing someone this week. KC at KC. I’m not thinking they are running away with the division and I’m not thinking we are done. I’m liking our chances and actually excited to see Mason Rudolph’s takeover. What do you think Mr. Dulac? (Kept Cleveland out of conversation because not all that impressed with the hype)

Gerry Dulac: I'm curious to see how Mason Rudolph performs. Based on what I see and how he handles himself, I think he will do well.

AugustWest: The addition of Devin Bush was supposed to stop the plague of slot receivers and tight ends exploiting the soft middle of the Steelers secondary. So far the same problem hasn't been fixed. Why not?

Gerry Dulac: Well, I think that's part of the learning process of a rookie. You're going to live with his mistakes while he develops. And there were several against the TE versus Seattle. Give him time, more than 2 games.

Advertise with us

Mike: Not a basher of Tomlin, but in trying to understand the issue with the defense, is it the evaluation of talent or coaching? Prior to Fitzpatrick, there are 7 first rounders, 2 seconds, and 2 thirds (Hargrave and Nelson) (Hilton undrafted). Seems it leans to coaching because of the consistent "mis-communication" refrain over the past 2-3 years.

Gerry Dulac: I turn a deaf ear when I hear the "miscommunication" excuse. That's another word for saying the player didn't understand the call or his role in it. And, yes, that's a lot of first-rounders.

Gerry Dulac: Note to some people who wonder why I don't use their questions: Don't use unflattering adjectives to describe a player. Got it?

kevin in Punxsy: Good morning Gerry. What is your estimation re: Mason Rudolph's abilities to do enough at QB to keep the Steelers afloat? (Along with an improved(?) defense.)

Gerry Dulac: I think MR is going to surprise some people. Good teams respond to adverse situations. Don't be surprised if the Steelers do. I've seen it before.

Advertise with us

Steve in OH: The Seahawks mentioned the D Line wearing down in the game. I would agree that it seems like they are far less disruptive in the second half of games and that could be why we give up so many leads. Thoughts?

Gerry Dulac: I'm not saying that was the case, but I will say that's one of the reasons D-line coach Karl Dunbar implemented a rotation system with the line last season. I think it's easy for the Seahawks to make that comment after winning the game. They wouldn't have said that if they lost

Tbone: Do the Steelers see Minkah as their FS of the future or more as a slot guy?

Gerry Dulac: They see him as a free safety who is a big-time playmaker capable of playing several ppositions. We will see if that happens

tcalantc: Hi Gerry, love your chats! Is it true that Moncrief has a dislocated finger? That would explain the troubles he's having closing on the ball, wouldn't it? Seems everyone is down on him, but not sure he can help it if he's hurt, right? Sammie Coates all over again. Thx

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: He has had a dislocated finger since training camp. But, if it's that bothersome, he shouldn't be playing, which I think you will see with decreasing regularity in SF

KN: Hello. Thank you for the chat. I am not a Tomlin hater but why is Tomlin not getting more heat for the defensive woes of the Steelers ? From everything I have heard, he has more and more fingerprints over the defense. We have communication issues every year . We do not have a spy on Wilson , as per Dupree admission. Are clichés enough to be head coach? Thank you very much.

Gerry Dulac: I don't think people realize how much of the defensive calls (and game plan) Tomlin makes.

STEEL72: Hi, Gerry. Ben is coming back next year-- at least that's the plan-- and Mason looked solid. Do you feel that giving up a 1st rounder for a 1st round talent was too much? Fitz is added defensive firepower for a defense that is going to be asked to carry a big load. I, for one, think that Colbert and Tomlin are doing the right thing. Looking at the QBs coming out next year, it doesn't feel like there is an unquestionable star-in-the-making anyway.

Gerry Dulac: Like I said earlier, I like the player, I don't like giving up a future No. 1. But I get the logic behind the deal and am not professionally offended by the move.

Advertise with us

'Double Divot Dewey: Hi Gerry - I awoke in the middle of the night with the thought that Mason Rudolph is going to 'Shock the World' come Sunday in San Francisco, and further lead the Steelers into the playoffs. Am I still sleeping or could this really be coming?

Gerry Dulac: Zzzzzzzzz

Gene: Do you have any information on what type of surgery Ben is having on his elbow?

Gerry Dulac: None. Have not heard, nor have we been told. There is confidentially, you know (HIPAA laws), with doctors and patients.

AugustWest: How does the loss of the franchise quarterback affect Tomlin's hot seat (if there is a hot seat)? How many games would the Rudolph-led Steelers have to lose before the front office considers changes in coaches and/or upper management?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: First of all, the only hot seat on which he sits is the one the public has created for him. But, if anything, he will get a pass on this season because of the loss of Ben. If anything, he will get more cerdit than ever for steering the Steelers through this if they finish, say, 10-6. Even 9-7 maybe

Blake : Gerry - Big fan of yours, always appreciate your insight!

Gerry Dulac: Thanx. Check's in the mail.

Tampa Too: Gerry. Your thoughts on cutting Moncrief and resigning Eli? Thanks

Gerry Dulac: I don't think they're going to cut Moncrief, not after the contract they gave him. But I have advocated bringing Eli back since the NE game

Advertise with us

Scott in Dallas: Good Morning Sir!

If the Steelers "earn" a top 10 pick in the 2020 draft does GM Colbert land on the hot seat since the reason for the trade is his groups inability to identify/draft/sign defensive players in recent times other than Watt?

Gerry Dulac: You will be able to hear the critics all the way down in Dallas

Bob in Canada: Hi Gerry. So we see big big changes. Injuries suck. I wish Ben well in his recovery but we could be witnessing the start of new era in Steelers football. With Ben out, Connor injured, and a new DB, what is the strength of this team going forward?

Gerry Dulac: That's what we're going to find out, but I will tell you to go easy on the negativity and pessimism. Let's see what happens

Advertise with us

Scott in Dallas: Ben showed up this year looking like he was already one foot into retirement so any thoughts the Steelers would really be interested in bringing him back as long as he passes a medical to negate the injury guarantee next year?

Gerry Dulac: No he didn't. He showed up in great shape and with the same great attitude, even more so.

NYCSkeptic: I've been a Tomlin die-hard for years now and think most of the negativity directed at him is overblown and weirdly obsessive, but I'm finally coming around to the idea of a fresh start with a new coach. They look lifeless right now. Thoughts? Also, can you ask Ben to retire?

Gerry Dulac: That's what Tampa Bay did when they fired Tony Dungy years ago. All he did was win games but never get past the first round of the playoffs

Close But No cigar: This team is not far from being really good. Lots of new (many young) players on both sides of the ball and still learning. One play made in Seattle (Moncrief catches it or McCullers PF penalty avoided), Steelers win. New England game if either of the two 3rd and one situations are converted in first half and it is different game; perhaps only 10-0 or 10-3 at half-time. Second half of NE game there were 3 drives when the Steelers had the ball first and 10 at NE 42, 46, and 41 only to stall. Make first downs there and you are looking at least at field goal tries but most importantly, Brady kept off field and Steelers defense gets more rest. With the addition of Fitzpatrick, this team's arrow is pointing up!!! What say you?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: You, sir, win the Most Positive Award. Give him a cigar!! No....wait..

Goldstar: If Mason comes in and plays well enough to look like a long term starter, what do they do if Ben recovers and is ready to go next year?

Gerry Dulac: Mason goes back to No. 2

Scott in Dallas: Some pretty poor timing on big contract extensions for Ben/Tomlin? Been much cheaper to "reset" after the season...

Gerry Dulac: They have had some bad luck/timing with those new contracts over the years. See Stephon Tuitt...

Advertise with us

guest: Hi Gerry, Couple questions rolled into one here. 1 - have you heard any update as to what the specific injury to Ben was/is? 2 - IF this happens to be the end for BR where do you rate him on the all time QB list? Personal opinion I put him within the top 10. what say you :)

Gerry Dulac: 1. No. 2. Top 15

Scott in Dallas: I can see the value in adding MF since the Dolphins paid the $13mil bonus and he is under team control for 3.5 more years. But was it too much of an all the chips in the pot for a season with a backup QB?

Gerry Dulac: No, I just don't like the idea of trading away a future No. 1. But it's hard not to like MF in your defense.

Durkins Bar: Are the Steelers finally changing the way they do business in regards to the draft and free agent signings moving forward ? The draft has produced a few hits but more misses lately . If the Fitzpatrick signing proves to be a hit , do we see a change in philosophy ?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I think we've already seen it.

Gerry Dulac: OK, just a couple more quick hits....

Scott in Dallas: Did the Steelers really turn down a 1st for Brown from the Patriots? Can you imagine how fun that would have been to watch...

Gerry Dulac: No AB to NE on their watch

GjSteel: Hi Gerry..I don't believe we are so sunk as everyone believes we are..a little comparison...2004..Ben was a rookie...look at his numbers the first 2 years...yikes...the defense...biggest issue..even the running game..both Olines..are very good..the WR's..are the biggest question and coaching..(Ward,Burress, Randel El..Cowher let his coordinators coridinate)...what is your assestment..don't forget the competition..Baltimore was way better...so were the Bengals

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: We'll see

Goldstar: if the Steelers finish way under .500 (say 5-11) which of the following are back next year Tomlin/Butler/Colbert?

Gerry Dulac: Two of the 3

Gerry Twolac: Chances Ben/Rudolph is Peyton/Luck 2 and we have to watch Ben in a different uniform?

Gerry Dulac: Slim

Port Vue VA: I say Steelers make the playoffs. Hallucination from bad Halushki? Ravens win division we get a WC

Gerry Dulac: Possible, but...

Blake : Ok let’s redirect the D questions to Tomlin; whatever they’re doing isn’t working. For an organization that prides itself on defense, why is he still allowed to run the show? If it really isn’t Butler - what purpose does he serve?

Gerry Dulac: Pay the man

Gerry Dulac: OK kids, that's all the time we have. Thanx for the questions.