Brian Batko: Good afternoon. As an homage to NFL roster cut-down time, I will be answering the 53 best questions today. If you get left out, you might just have to join us for tonight's free Punt, Pass and Chat event at Tequila Cowboy

Let's begin.

ssa76: Rumor has it that Indy is interested in Dobbs. Shouldn't we get whatever we can for a guy who will be cut eventually?

Brian Batko: He might not get cut, but yes. Even a late-round pick would probably be worth it, in my opinion.

Advertise with us

kevin in Punxsy: Hi Brian. Of these four LBs (Gilbert, Smith, Skiper, Spillane) either drafted or signed this year, which do you see making the 53 man roster.

Brian Batko: If it were me, I would keep Ulysees Gilbert (for special teams) and Tuzar Skipper (as a potential third pass-rusher). Two all-name team guys, as well. As for what I think the team WILL do, I think it might just be one of those guys who make it, and in that case, Gilbert (for special teams).

BB: Brian - Thanks for the chats. Does Hawkins make the team or is he odd man out? Looks like Marcus Allen will also be looking for work elsewhere?

Brian Batko: I think the affable Jerald Hawkins, a proud LSU man like my boss Tyler Batiste, is out. Marcus Allen probably competing for one spot with fellow safety and similar player Jordan Dangerfield.

Wisconsin Winters: Tampa is overloaded at TE...CAMERON

Advertise with us

BRATE could be a possibility for the Steelers eh?

Brian Batko: Eh!

rambler66: Does it really matter whether the backup QB is Dobbs or Rudolph? Last year there was all kinds of worry over Landry Jones vs Josh Dobbs. It never really mattered then either. Now Jones is out of the NFL

Brian Batko: Yes. Ben Roethlisberger isn't getting any younger, and Nick Foles leading the Eagles to a Super Bowl should've quelled any talk of backup QBs not mattering.

Jay: Hola Brian.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Not a question, but I like to be greeted every now and again.

FloridaSteelers: Hi Brian, How did you feel about the Colts fan's booing Andrew Luck? Luck is a outstanding young man with options & I applaud him.

Brian Batko: I think it's lame. Very lame. On one hand, you might argue that these guys get paid handsomely to do what they do, and that for that reason, why feel bad for them when they take some fan abuse? But to that, I would say: that must be why I always see people treating minimum wage workers with the utmost respect. Sarcasm, of course.

kevin in Punxsy: Brian, which receivers make the 53 and why? Thanks

Brian Batko: If I were calling the shots, I'd keep JuJu, James Washington, Crief, Diontae Johnson, Ryan Switzer and Diontae Spencer. Because to me, each of those guys fill a specific role. I think I like Switzer as a Switz Army Knife for the offense, and Spencer has at least some value as a returner.

Advertise with us

Who WILL make it? I don't know, other than that I'm probably wrong!

paul: Our back up qb mattered in Oakland last year!

Brian Batko: Another slam dunk for the active roster

Jay: Hows the steelers cap situation to allow them flexibility to pursuit other vet cuts?

Brian Batko: Not a ton of room, fourth from the bottom in the NFL, but they can almost always make things work if need be.

Advertise with us

Rupert Pupkin: What do you make of James Washington not getting a lot of playing time w Ben? And how will they use him this year?

Brian Batko: Just that Donte Moncrief is ahead of him in the overall pecking order. I still think Washington can and will push for plenty of snaps and production, at least given the way he's played in preseason. I just don't believe that Moncrief was ever brought in here to play behind him. Otherwise, why go get him in free agency?

TC in Charlotte: Hi Brian! Does the Luck retirement help the Steeler's in the win column and do we now see a wild card team coming out of the AFC North this year?

Brian Batko: Ohhhhh I think it does, TC. In the great prognostication game of preseason pontification, I pinned Pittsburgh for a loss to Indy. Now, I see that as a win. And now, I see a surefire playoff team as one fewer postseason contender. To me, the six will come from this group: Chiefs, Chargers, Patriots, Texans, Browns, Steelers, Ravens.

Upon further reflection, I guess I felt like Andrew Luck is pretty good.

Advertise with us

Mike: There has been a lot made of the increase in team speed on defense. What are your thoughts about the increase in position flexibility at both the second and third levels on D? A lot more movement and shifting right before the snap than I’ve ever seen out of this defense. Confusion for Brady!

Brian Batko: I'm quite certain that's the goal, Mike, to be more flexible. Keep an eye on what Ray Fittipaldo and I write about in the lead-up to that Week 1 matchup in Foxborough. Mark Barron, Kam Kelly, Cam Sutton, Mike Hilton all moving parts for a defense that figures to keep playing a lot of sub-packages.

Guest: We have an usual amount of players from Toledo on our roster. With the former head coach of Toledo now coaching at Iowa State, do you feel we should pay attention to ISU players come draft time?

Brian Batko: Not particularly, no.

Retire21: If Indy called and offered a No. 2 for Mason Rudolph, do you take it?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Yes, I would.

Ryan : Hi Brian, last man in / last man out as of right now? As it Relates to the 53

Brian Batko: I feel like Joe Lunardi! I'll say last man in is Jordan Dangerfield. I'll say last man out is Diontae Spencer. BUBBLE WATCH, baby.

Stash: Brain, Would you not agree Edmunds is the better RB than Snell? Just keeping cause he is a 4th rd pick is a bit lame?

Brian Batko: No, I'm definitely not willing to write off Benny Snell this fast. He's got three years of college tape that say he's better than what he has showed in *counts fingers, does mental math, carries the one* two preseason games. Don't look at it as keeping him just because he's a fourth-round pick. Look at it as he was a fourth-round pick for a reason.

Advertise with us

K dot: You think the team is waiting for that 21m cap hit from AB to wane a bit before renegotiating players like Hargrave and Hilton, or are they just waiting to see their productivity? Or is it something completely different?

Brian Batko: Tough to say, K dot. But good question, which is why it made the roster. Javon Hargrave and Mike Hilton, for as solid and productive as they've been, still probably aren't every-down players. Hilton more so, but even now, this team might have big plans for a bigger-bodied, versatile safety in Kam Kelly. Not to mention the development of another slot corner type in Cam Sutton.

Cburg Stiller: Do you see a scenario where they keep U. Gilbert and T. Skipper on the 53-man roster?

Brian Batko: Yeah, I think it could happen. And not just if Toledo drops the bag on the South Side facility doorstep. It would be especially likely if Tyler Matakevich doesn't make the cut (though I think he does) and Ola Adeniyi starts out on the IR. Speaking of which ...

FoolBack: Brian, has their been any updates on Ola Adeniyi? At this time of the year, 2-4 weeks is huge difference.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: No, Mike Tomlin has not offered any sort of formal or official update on that. With the spark Bud Dupree has shown in preseason, and with what you think you might have in Great Warrior Tuzar Skipper, maybe just keep Adeniyi on ice for a bit. Again.

Felix Unger: We will have a punter with Berry in his name, correct?

Brian Batko: The guess here is yes, Felix. But what if it's this guy? http://www.nfl.com/player/zacatterberry/2508728/profile

Stash: Brian, Impressed with your intelligent reply! Who wrote it for you...

Brian Batko: Two for you, Stash. You go, Stash.

Advertise with us

Larry from Punxy: The coaches and players keep denying that there is more of an upbeat, focused, and overall better body of work this preseaon than in the past...but my eyes tell me something different. Do you notice a better product on the field this season so far? They've been a lot more exciting to watch!

Brian Batko: Nah.

36 bus!!!: Did you see Tuzar skipper seem to take a couple plays off? Just seemed like he didn't try some plays compared to others. Just curious on his want to on every down.

Brian Batko: I didn't, but if he had Sutton Smith's motor coming out of college, he probably would've been considered a better prospect. Not sure there's any need to question his desire, though. Skipper has been through a lot, on and off the field https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/08/20/Tuzar-Skipper-...

Sharon: It seems to me that Vance McDonald hasn’t looked good this preseason. Is there an injury we don’t know about?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Not that I'm aware, no.

Colin: What tight ends do you think we may look to trade for?

Brian Batko: I think Tampa has a surplus. Indy and Oakland, too.

Alt: Do you see Marcus Allen as being on the fringe of the 53 or more of a practice squad guy to start the season? Would hate to lose him on waivers. He's still young and seems to have good upside and could adequately fill a special teams spot.

Brian Batko: Probably the fringe. He and Jordan Dangerfield are both strong safeties with special teams abilities. Not sure you need 'em both.

Advertise with us

livinthedream: Brian, I really enjoyed the 2nd NSD podcast (didn't hear the 1st one). You and Ray did an excellent job assessing the team talent and gave us good insite on how they may be used. My ?, has the Fullback position become enough of a unicorn in the NFL that Rosy may lose out to Edmonds as the 4th RB?

Brian Batko: *gasps* This is the greatest chat comment I've ever seen! Yes, OF COURSE you should listen to someone by the name of "livinthedream" and ESPECIALLY when he/she shouts out the North Shore Drive podcast. Listen online here or download it wherever you get your pods

Now, on to your question. I still think Rosie Nix is a lock to make this team, not just because of his short-yardage utility as a lead blocker but also because of his willingness on special teams. Those traits are more valuable than what Edmunds brings, from where I sit.

UK Yinzer: Hi Brian, welcome to the Steelers team, your views are very refreshing and insightful. I don't think we should trade Eli Rogers unless we get a good TE in return or a 5th round pick. There are always injuries so we could loose one of the WRs at any time, so why not keep 17 on the roster and stash one or two of the promising WRs on the Practice squad

Brian Batko: Thanks, old sport. I don't think anyone is trading a fifth-round pick for Eli Rogers. Or really any of the fringe Steelers wideouts. Pretty much every team has guys like that, with every beat writer discussing with every fan base who should and should not be kept. You can't risk losing Diontae Johnson to the P squad, so that's out of the question.

Advertise with us

John D: How many AAF players are still on the Steelers' 90 man roster and how many realistically have a chance to make the 53 outside of Kelly?

Brian Batko: Winston Craig, Casey Sayles, Greg Gilmore on the D line. JC Hassenauer on the O line. I don't think any of those four are making it.

PrimantiBro1: What up, BB? Is it ridiculous to think Dobbs has trade value. And do you think Rudolph has QB2 locked ... and is there any good reason to think Dobbs would be a less talented pro than Duckie? WWBBD about the QB order for now and in the foreseeable future?

Brian Batko: BB would only keep two QBs and roll with that. I've talked myself into that strategy since answering a question about it in last week's mailbag (you can always tweet or email me questions for that too, by the way) https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/08/22/steelers-roste...

But the Steelers don't do that under Mike Tomlin. And so, I don't envision Josh Dobbs getting traded but I do envision him sticking around as the No. 3 behind No. 2 the No. 2.

Advertise with us

Paul: It seems like everyone is thinking Switzer is safer than Rogers in terms of making the 53. Just wondering what it is that makes Switzer better positioned? Route running? Return duties? Relationship with Big Ben?

Brian Batko: Some combination of all of that, Paul. They like to use him in the backfield at times, whether you agree with that look or not. He's crafty, he's tough, great locker room guy. Add it all up and I think you have the clear-cut 5th receiver.

PVB: Malik Williams (RB) has looked pretty good in limited action, albeit against 3rd stringers but he hasn't had a good line either. Any chance he makes it to the practice squad?

Brian Batko: Suppose there is. He's shown better than I expected.

DaquidoBazzini: I'm not huge on camp phenoms, but Tuzar Skipper seems like he's done enough to make this team. Has he been on ST's at all? I have a feeling if it comes down to the practice squad, he might be scooped up. As you know, outside pass rushers are highly sought after in the NFL.

Brian Batko: He has not. I'm not sure the coaches see him as a viable option there. He's put-together and powerful, but is he going to be able to make plays in space or pursue a return man from behind? Keep in mind he was a college DE. Still like him a lot in his day job, though.

Jacque Strap: Reading a lot that Rudolph has obviously outplayed Dobbs in this preseason. Is it really that obvious? Seems pretty even between the two of them.

Brian Batko: Yeah, count me in the Rudolph camp, for sure. Just think he's made more big-time throws and fewer mistakes. Tie goes to the higher-drafted guy anyway, and I don't even see this one as being very close to a tie. He's looked good.

Herewego: What's your practice squad thoughts? Who makes it in your opinion and who won't get past waivers?

Brian Batko: Former rugby player Christian Scotland-Williamson, the big TE, is an exempt so I'd say count him in again. Patrick Morris, the third-string center. Sutton Smith, Tuzar Skipper or both. Ulysees Gilbert, Robert Spillane or both. Tevin Jones or Trey Griffey as a bigger body at receiver. I like what I've seen from Pine-Richland grad Kevin Rader as a deep cut at TE. Those are just some names and thoughts rather than a full-scale prediction.

Bubby Brister: I'm not sure that I see a lot of value in keeping Anthony Chickillo. He's not a liability but seems to have limited upside. Your thoughts?

Brian Batko: I agree with you, Bubby. But he signed on for two more years for $8 million over the offseason, so I think he'll certainly be back in special teams and backup OLB capacity.

Harrisburger: Question related to Steeler history: I recently saw a list of officially and unofficially retired jersey numbers, and understandably, there are a bunch. Any idea why 82 and 88 are not among the unofficially retired numbers?

Brian Batko: Maybe just because this time a year, you've got a lot of WRs and TEs you have to suit up. And while they can occasionally dip into the teens (for wideouts) and 40s (for TEs) those numbers are also used by QBs, kickers, punters, linebackers, RBs, DBs, etc.

John Strange: Hey B.B. Is Snell destined to get stashed away on the IR? (if this B.B. thing isn't catching on with anyone else I will go back to calling you Brian or the more formal Mr. Batko)

Brian Batko: I prefer Monsieur Batko, actually. Snell seems to be healthy and ready to go for preseason Week 4. Mike Tomlin gave an uncharacteristically loquacious answer about what 24 needs to do Thursday night.

Chris: Do you concur that Eli Rogers may on his way out barring injury? I think Switzer and Spencer could be the punt and kickoff specialists.

Brian Batko: I'm willing to concur at this juncture but I wouldn't bet on it, either.

Steeltowntim@aol.com: Cameron Brake is best TE all around in Tampa yes better than OJ they wont cut him but he be a big up grade over our 2

Brian Batko: Cameron Brake is good, but the problem is he just keeps stopping on all his routes.

Need7rings: How much of a difference is it reporting big leagues vs. College

Brian Batko: I get a lot more questions in these here chats, that's for dang sure.

Cg: Who is the biggest Steeler name that get cut?

Brian Batko: Christian Scotland-Williamson. Not only is he 6-9, 274, but that's 27 letters, if I added correctly. I'm not a math major.

Dontgetit: Why hold on to Dobbs? because he can run and throw interceptions??? Hodges looks like he might have the goods. Trade Dobbs if we can get anything for him.

Brian Batko: No, I don't think that would be why.

Wisconsin Winters: Does Boswell win the kicking spot?

Brian Batko: Yes

Val: Could you evaluate Spencer’s receiving skills? If they are sufficient, it may be the deciding factor as to whether he makes the team. Thanks.

Brian Batko: I don't think they're on par with Eli Rogers or Ryan Switzer. Maybe not even Johnny Holton. But I like the idea of keeping him as a return man and occasional gadget guy on offense. Even if you aren't using him to tote the rock, he can be a factor in that way.

denver: with mcdonald always hurt or nursing something what are they going to do at te

Brian Batko: Mike Tomlin bluntly said today after practice that he has not seen enough out of the TEs. Ipso facto, they'll make a move!

Cg: What is the first play the Steelers run vs. the Patriots?

Guest: More like badko...u feel me?

Brian Batko: THREE MORE QUESTIONS MAKE THIS ROSTER

Emmanuel: Have you seen discipline instilled by MT that could have a positive impact throughout the season?

Brian Batko: Sure

SteelerMayn: Brian, how do they determine who is capable of contributing on special teams? Is it based off college experience? Athleticism? I ask because I really like what I've seen from Gilbert but they keep saying he doesn't contribute on special teams so Sutton Smith might get his spot. Gilbert seems plenty athletic, fast, strong enough to contribute if he is taught a role that suits his skills, no?

Brian Batko: Yeah, I think they definitely saw that out of Gilbert and Smith when they selected them. Even said so on draft night, as I recall.

Paul: Who has a better season: Juju or AB?

Brian Batko: JuJu will finish with more fantasy points.

Brian Batko: OK OK OK that's all the time we have for today. If it were up to me, I'd spend all eight hours of my shift chatting with you all. But occasionally, they want me to write things. Sometimes that's The Skinny Post newsletter, which I'd love for you to sign up for here https://t.co/NfEhqK8Wxn?amp=1

Brian Batko: And of course, there's still time to register for tonight's get-together where you can hang out with me, Ray Fittipaldo and Gene Collier, plus our editor Tyler Batiste. Do so here https://t.co/gKGxssJaDo?amp=1

Hope to see some of you tonight. Don't hesitate to say hello. Thanks for chatting by,.