Welcome to Brian Batko’s weekly Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds. Let’s get started, and don’t forget to join our Steelers experts at the free Punt, Pass & Chat event Aug. 27 on the North Shore. Register here:
@CharDeeMacDen12: Any thoughts on the Steelers keeping only 2 QBs to bolster another position, maybe keep an extra WR? I would keep Rudolph as back-up and let Dobbs/Hodges battle for practice squad.
Brian: To me, you only keep three quarterbacks if you think all three have value to you — not just because it’s tradition — and in this case, the Steelers might believe that. Not keeping three means that you’re cutting Josh Dobbs and Devlin Hodges after the final preseason game, thus opening them up to be signed to another team’s active roster (did you know the Cowboys backup is something called a Cooper Rush?) — which could happen, especially for Dobbs.
Imagine this scenario: Ben Roethlisberger gets hurt, Mason Rudolph takes over and plays poorly in his first exposure to regular-season football, or perhaps even gets injured himself. Now what do you do? You’ll have to try to make a trade or sign someone off another team’s practice squad. Neither of those options are as solid as simply turning to Dobbs, who knows the offense already.
Certainly, I can see the argument for scrapping a third quarterback and rolling with two. Roethlisberger is that good and mostly has stayed healthy the past two seasons, while Rudolph should have enough talent to keep things afloat if No. 7 goes down. About half the league went that way last season. It all comes down to the Steelers weighing whether they’d rather play it super safe at the most important position or weaken the depth there to make a relatively minor upgrade elsewhere, most likely special teams. Speaking of which …
Franklin Family: A personal pet peeve is seemingly ‘always’ seeing a flag on punts and kickoff returns for holding or a block in the back. Do you know what the Steelers penalty average is on their returns (meaning they get flagged on the play) compared with the NFL average?
Read More
Brian: For the sake of simplicity and time, let’s limit this inquiry to the 2018 season. According to NFLPenalties.com, the Steelers were called for offensive holding or illegal blocks 17 times on special teams. That was tied with the Kansas City Chiefs for the highest total in the NFL last year, but the Steelers had 14 more yards (142 to 128). The league average is right around 10, so yes, your pet peeve is probably appropriate here.
It makes sense that the Steelers finished second-to-last in the NFL in average yards per kick return (19.3) and 17th in average yards per punt return (8.1), and they were one of eight teams to not break a return of longer than 40.
While people often point to the need for a more dynamic return man — could that be Diontae Spencer if he makes this team? — it’s true the Steelers need to clean up other aspects of their return game, too. So far this preseason, on nine punt returns and five kickoff returns, the Steelers have been penalized twice, both for holding, on the very first kick and punt returns of the year against Tampa Bay. But none since then. Maybe they’re already making progress.
@tbsone: Why are some not satisfied with Rudolph’s performance so far? Who thinks Moncrief > Washington? Is Bush OK?
Brian: 1. I don’t know, because I think he’s been pretty impressive. If you want to nitpick, he might look a little unsure in the pocket at times, and he held the ball too long when he got sacked against the Chiefs. 2. A lot of people, especially those who are putting more stock into five years of NFL work than a couple good preseason games back-to-back. Don’t get me wrong, James Washington might yet prove to be this team’s No. 2 receiver rather than Donte Moncrief. But Moncrief was brought in to play a major role, seems to have fit in nicely with the first-team offense going back to the spring and has barely had a chance to show what he can do so far. He fumbled in his Steelers pseudo-debut, but you should see more of him Sunday night at Tennessee (he played just eight snaps last week). 3. Yes, he’s fine.
@DCWSAUCE: Pros and cons you’ve noticed so far about the Steelers beat vs your time covering Pitt?
Brian: It’s definitely a pro to have the baseline-level access that the NFL provides, from open locker rooms (during the week and after games) to viewable practices. For me, personally, I’m covering a team that’s new to me and vice versa, do I don’t have as many individual relationships with players as I managed to form through a couple seasons over at Pitt.
Back to the pros, literally, the NFL is much more of a 24-hour news cycle. Maybe that’s more of a con. But, in theory, a player can be traded or released at any time. In college, sure, a guy can transfer or get kicked off the team, but you aren’t making roster swaps with anyone. There are no cuts prior to the season starting. Both jobs have their ups and downs, whether it’s media policies or readership or work schedule, but I’ve found them both enjoyable. Not exactly working in the mines here. But hey, thanks for asking.

Be sure to compliment Joe Starkey. Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.