Welcome to Brian Batko’s weekly Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds. Let’s get started:
steeltowntim@aol.com: Do you think the Sutton train has slowed down and how has he done in camp? Lot of hype after draft now Ulysses is passing him up?
Brian: Managed to shake this one out of the unanswered bag of questions in the queue of my chat this week, because it ended up being a fairly interesting topic the more I looked into it at Saint Vincent.
A couple of rookie sixth-round linebackers here in Sutton Smith and Ulysees Gilbert — not Ulysses Grant, as Mike Tomlin mistakenly called him Tuesday morning, which got a much-needed laugh at an otherwise somber news conference — who seem to be moving in opposite directions. Gilbert was a Week 1 preseason standout, while Smith has been sidelined for about a week and a half, and the final week and a half of training camp.
That’s not a good spot to be in for a late-round pick trying to carve out a roster spot, but Smith told me Thursday morning he’s been dealing with an abdominal issue. He said he’ll be held out of the second preseason game, too, and when Tomlin was asked if Smith has fallen behind because of his health, the coach gave a simple but harsh answer: “Yes.”
The most productive pass-rusher in Northern Illinois history isn’t looking at it that way, though. Wednesday, Smith was in uniform and still walking through special teams drills at times, working on his punt protection off to the side but in unison with the players in full pads.
Read More
“There’s a lot of stuff I really can’t do right now. … You just don’t want the risk of re-injuring it, really,” Smith said. “I’m still going through plays, just watching a little bit more film on my phone or iPad, and just trying to stay tuned-in, mentally. That’s really the big thing.”
Smith expects to return in time for the final two preseason games, at Tennessee and Carolina, but acknowledged that it’s ultimately up to Tomlin and the training staff.
“We’ll see. It’s all up to their discretion,” said Smith, who first played through his injury for about a week. “I have no idea what their plan is, and I’m just following it, really.”
Naturally, Smith added that “it stinks” to be missing valuable time in his first NFL camp. He never dealt with this injury in college, and in fact, he never missed a game once he made his debut as a redshirt freshman. There’s no denying Smith is undersized in the pros, but he’s still confident he’ll find his niche.
“This year, my role is special teams, and that’s really the thing I want to get on right now and play a lot of,” Smith said. “Just so they know that ‘this guy can cover, this guy can tackle, this guy can play’ and stuff like that. … I think there’s a lot of room to make up in there.”
Paul: Love your Steelers coverage. Quick question on the Tomlin challenge. He challenged that it was a fumble. Now it was recovered by the other team, but technically, yes, it was a fumble. Win the challenge, pad the stats, keep the timeout, and the challenge itself is like a timeout while they review it ... Is that not correct?
Brian: Well, Paul, I’m not entirely sure if I know what you’re asking here. I did think the question would be quicker. Technically, no, it wasn’t a fumble, because it wasn’t called a fumble and was not overturned to be a fumble. Not sure there are really any “stats to pad” in the preseason. Perhaps there’s a part of Mike Tomlin that just wanted to get a win on a challenge, but more likely is that he just saw a play that could be overturned to help his team close out a game in the fourth quarter.
Any challenge does sort of equate to a timeout, but this one was after a kickoff return, so you pretty much get some time to reset anyway. So, I’ll say you’re kind of correct. The challenge story line will be a lot more interesting with Tomlin and Teryl Austin once the regular season arrives. Maybe there will come a time over these next three games when they attempt to challenge a pass-interference call, if only to try out that new rule for the 2019 campaign. Tampa Bay threw the red flag on one of those penalties Friday (and it was upheld as interference) but the Steelers did not.
“Sometimes it might be to familiarize myself,” Tomlin said of his preseason challenge strategy in the postgame. “That’s kind of a hypothetical question. I tend to take the cases as they come up.”
Rick A.: I have yet to see any writer address the Steelers elephant in the room question. Will Tuitt finally play up to his contract?
Brian: There are a lot of elephants in a lot of rooms. Not sure if that’s something Tomlin has ever said, but it seems like he would.
Anyway, it’s quite inaccurate to say no writer has addresses whether Stephon Tuitt will finally play up to his contract. In June, our Ray Fittipaldo wrote an analysis piece headlined “Are Steelers getting good return on investment in Stephon Tuitt?” In July, our Gerry Dulac wrote one headlined “Steelers need Stephon Tuitt’s production to match his price.”
So, yeah, it’s a story. We’ve covered it. But Tuitt isn’t a guy you can learn much about in the camp setting. Or preseason. We’ll see where he is Week 1 in New England.

Be sure to compliment Joe Starkey. Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.