Throw him right into the fire? Or make him sit and wait his turn behind veterans?
Those are the two contrasting approaches teams can take to playing their newcomers. Steelers first-round draft pick Devin Bush knows about both.
As a freshman at Michigan in 2016, the Wolverines coaching staff knew Bush’s pedigree, explosive speed and instincts could turn him into a unique player at linebacker … eventually. But first, he’d have to prove himself on special teams, playing only sparingly at linebacker in a reserve role.
Steelers defensive first-round picks
2019: Devin Bush, LB, Michigan, pick No. 10 overall
2018:Terrell Edmunds, S, Virginia Tech, pick No. 28 overall; Started Week 1 at Cleveland in part because the presumptive starter, Morgan Burnett, was injured. … Went on to start 15 of 16 games … Recorded 78 tackles, one sack and one interception… Played 966 snaps on defense, second only to Sean Davis (979), plus 223 on special teams.
Read More
2017: T.J. Watt, LB, Wisconsin, pick No. 30 overall; Started all 15 games he was healthy… recorded an interception and a pair of sacks in his debut game vs. Browns… Recorded 52 tackles and seven sacks… Played 751 snaps (76.55 percent), plus 149 on special teams.
2016: Artie Burns, CB, Miami, pick No. 25 overall; Started the final nine games…. Recorded 64 tackles, three interceptions and 13 passes defended… Played 810 snaps on defense (77.44 percent), plus 196 on special teams.
2015: Bud Dupree, LB, Kentucky, pick No. 22 overall; Started five games/ played in 16, recording four sacks and 26 tackles … Played 563 defensive snaps (50.77 percent), plus 95 on special teams.
2014:Ryan Shazier, LB, Ohio State, pick No. 15 overall; Started five games…. Recorded 40 tackles and one QB hit… Played 258 defensive snaps (26.06 percent), plus 58 on special teams.
2013:Jarvis Jones, LB, Georgia, pick No. 17 overall; Started in eight games, played in 14 … Recorded 41 tackles and one sack… Played 630 defensive snaps (58.88 percent), plus 121 on special teams.
2011: Cameron Heyward, DE, Ohio State, pick No. 31 overall; Zero starts as a rookie… recorded 11 tackles, one sack, one forced fumble.
2009: Ziggy Hood, DT, Missouri, No. 32 overall; Zero starts as a rookie… recorded eight tackles and one fumble recovery.
2007:Lawrence Timmons, LB, Florida State, pick No. 15 overall; Zero starts as a rookie… recorded 13 tackles, recovered two fumbles and no sacks.
2003: Troy Polamalu, S, Southern Cal, pick No. 16 overall; Zero starts as a rookie … recorded 48 tackles, two sacks and four interceptions
“It was a lesson learned,” Bush said. “It definitely kept me hungry. It kept me motivated. It kept me focused.”
Now, as Bush prepares for the first preseason game of his rookie year on Friday against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and his regular season debut inches closer, the question is which approach do the Steelers choose to take with a player they moved up 10 spots to select? And which is better long-term?
“Everyone is different,” said safety Terrell Edmunds, who led all NFL rookies in snap count last season. “Some people, if you throw them into the fire too early, that can lead to a lot of negative exposure. Some people can’t handle that. … You’ve got to be in the right situation.”
Years ago, it would be unheard of for a Steelers first-round pick to start on defense.
From 2003 through 2011 — a stretch that included three Super Bowl appearances and two rings — the Steelers drafted four defensive players in the first round: Troy Polamalu (2003), Lawrence Timmons (2007), Ziggy Hood (2009) and Cameron Heyward (2011).
Not a single one started a single game in his rookie season. Zero.
Heyward is perhaps the best, and last, example of this sit-and-learn methodology. He started zero games as a rookie in 2011, zero as a second-year player in 2012 and finally earned his first start in the third game of his third season. After a slow start to his career, Heyward has become an All-Pro and one of the faces of the Steelers defense.
But times change. And so, too, has the Steelers’ approach when it comes to playing first-round picks on defense.
As the dominant defenses of the mid-2000s got old, got slow and got replaced, the Steelers drafted seven consecutive defensive players in the first round from 2013 to 2019 when they selected Bush.
All of the previous six have earned starting roles at some point during their rookie seasons, including Jarvis Jones (eight starts as a rookie in 2013), Ryan Shazier (five starts as a rookie in 2014), Bud Dupree (five starts as a rookie in 2015) and Artie Burns (nine starts as a rookie in 2016).
The last two years, the Steelers have ramped up their expectations for rookies even more. T.J. Watt and Edmunds have been picked, plugged in and played from Game 1, Snap 1 of their rookie seasons.
Maybe it’s a change in philosophy. Maybe it’s just out of necessity. Or maybe it’s both. But this approach is polar opposite to the way the Steelers used to ease their defensive first-round picks into the action.
“Going from college to the NFL is a big task,” Watt said. “I think a lot of guys take that transition a lot differently. You have to know who you are and know how you learn. Know if you learn better off the board or on the field.”
Results, for the most part, have been positive. In 2017, Watt made a historic debut against the Cleveland Browns. He became just the third player in NFL history to record two sacks and an interception in his debut.
But Watt admits the wear and tear of a long season — coupled with the unique nature of going straight from college to the NFL — caused him to hit the dreaded “rookie wall.”
“I heard about the rookie wall a lot,” Watt said. “You don’t want to believe it at the time. But looking back, definitely hit a wall at some point, just because it’s such a long offseason heading into the season.
“You go from playing in a bowl game to prepping for the combine to getting a few weeks off, nothing like the vets get off. Then, you go into four preseason games and a full season and then you get to playoffs. It’s definitely a grind.”
Last year, it looked like the Steelers had the safety depth to ease rookie first-round pick Edmunds into the action. But when Morgan Burnett, the splashy free-agent signing of the offseason, was hampered by injuries, the rookie got elevated to the starting role. He went on to play 966 snaps on defense, second only to Sean Davis (979), plus an additional 223 on special teams. No rookie played more snaps across all three phases than Edmunds.
“Getting that rookie start, you’ve got a lot of weight on your shoulders, a lot of people looking at you,” Edmunds said. “You’ve got to go out there and play similar to a vet, because when you’re out there on the field, they’re not going to look at you like (a rookie). They need you to be at your 100% percent the same way you need them to be at their 100%.”
So what’s it all mean for Bush?
The Steelers have been rotating a trio of players at their inside backer positions. Veteran Vince Williams, free-agent addition Mark Barron and Bush have all been taking reps with the first-team defense.
For what it’s worth, Bush is listed behind Barron on the depth chart. But if recent history is any indication, he should earn some role with the starting unit this year — or more.
“Coming in here, I’ve been thrown into the fire,” Bush said. “I get the concept of both. But I don’t prefer either. Whichever path grabs me, I go along with it.”
Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mikedefabo





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.