
Brian Batko: I’m here, everyone. Steelers start up another week of practice, a preseason week!, in about an hour. Until then, let’s chat.
Utah Jim: Why do the Steelers keep players for special teams that have no chance at being anything more such as Matakevich, Dangerfield, DHB, etc.? Why not keep players with potential to do more? It’s not like special teams have been much of team strength anyway. Try a different philosophy.
Brian Batko: That's probably subjective on your part to say those guys don't have potential to do more. Now, I don't think anyone sees Matakevich or Dangerfield as starter-caliber players, but perhaps the front office sees them as capable backups. Every team usually has at least a couple of those special teams demons. Maybe some new blood could unseat the veterans you're down on, ideally giving you a good piece on ST who's also projectable down the road in the offense or defense.
Jeff Stal: What do you think the chances are of Diontae Spencer to make the 53-man roster as PR/KR? Based on his track record from the CFL and his speed and elusiveness, I think he could be a dynamic returner.
Brian Batko: Not great, mostly because it's a crowded room, more so than I doubt Spencer's talent. I think he's been hot and cold in camp, making some great plays but also dealing with some drops. Preseason will be a time for him to shine, both offensively and in the return game.
Scl: Love the chats Brian, which player on offense and defense have been the most pleasant surprises for you? From what I’ve read, seems like cam Sutton has been all over the ball. Could we actually have some decent corner depth this year???
Read More
Brian Batko: Thanks. On offense, it's gonna be tough to crack a spot in the backfield, but second-year undrafted running back Ralph Webb is kinda nice. He's small, probably not the 5-10 he's listed, but was awfully productive in college at Vanderbilt and had a nice preseason last year with New England. Defensively, Cam Sutton is a good one. Didn't think a whole lot of him coming into camp, but he's looking versatile and opportunistic so far.
ALB: Are you surprised there isn't more concern voiced about the O line? They're reputation was better than their play much of last year and they've lost Munchak.
Brian Batko: Not really. I think it's a stout, veteran group that already has found an answer this summer at RT in Matt Feiler. Sure, there's always something an OL unit can do better (in this case, run-blocking) but I'm not too worried about them.
FloridaSteelers: Brian, will Haden & Hargrove get extensions before the seasons starts? I feel these 2 are the most critical to get done. Sean Davis can go as far as I'm concerned, Your thoughts please.
Brian Batko: Joe Haden seems like a near-lock for it to get done. Javon Hargrave I'm less certain about, but he'd be next in line. I'm with you on Sean Davis, he has much more to prove this year, and I think Haden is considerably more important than Hargrave just based on how many snaps you need each guy for. And that's why Haden will get paid accordingly.
412: Do you think Kam Kelly is set to be the 3rd safety? Have you been impressed with his range/center field ability?
Brian Batko: Not particularly. I've seen some ups, some downs from him. If anything, I'd say he's set to be the backup free safety. Just not a lot of depth there, and it's clear that the staff likes him given that he keeps getting the starter reps without Sean Davis. But that doesn't mean things can't change if he starts to slip.
JerseySteel: Hi Brian - is anyone taking charge of backup safety so far in camp?
Brian Batko: As stated above, Kelly has had flashes. Jordan Dangerfield has been great against the run here and there. And I've seen some nice things out of undrafted FAs PJ Locke (who's playing deep) and Dravon Askew-Henry (who's playing strong). Still, not the most inspiring competition. Maybe a spot for a camp-cut signing or trade? https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/08/06/Steelers-GM-Ke...
Gregg: How are Ulysses Gilbert and Tuzar Skipper doing? Figured in Gilbert’s case being a draft pick we’d have heard more about him.
Brian Batko: Not a ton to write home about. Both guys running second team, Skipper more consistently there. Gilbert usually rotates in behind Tyler Matakevich and Robert Spillane at ILB. He's still raw, but Gilbert gets to the ball and uses his "wiggle" pretty well. Skipper's an imposing body, but a tweener. I think Gilbert probably has a better shot at making it.
Trou: Brian, how is Isaiah Buggs doing?
Brian Batko: I haven't noticed him a ton, but I still think he's in decent shape to be one of the six DL (assuming they keep six).
Luigi: browns/Steelers - Your thoughts?
Brian Batko: Should be two great games. Should be two teams right in the thick of the playoff hunt. It's funny to me how a lot of fans and even some media types around here seem personally offended that the Browns might be good. Maybe they will be, maybe they won't be, but I don't think the buzz around them is unfounded.
JuJu 2017: Brian, what are your thoughts on Mike Hilton and Rookie Justin Layne?
Brian Batko: Mike Hilton will still be the No. 1 slot corner, the way I see it. Justin Layne has had good and bad reps, just like most rookies. He's not ready to come out of the oven yet, to use a Tomlin-ism.
Dbush fan: Hey Brian, what are your biggest takeaways from watching Devin bush so far? Do you think he can step up and be a real difference maker for this defense? His speed is impressive
Brian Batko: He better be. I'm not pegging him to be rookie of the year or anything, but I do believe the Steelers like how he's progressing. He's all first-team reps, all the time, and has been better against the pass, from what I've seen. Short-area quickness is off the charts, and his upper-body strength is apparent in backs-on-backers drill which simulates a pass-rush.
Wisconsin Winters: For years I disliked the secondary's approach of "let them catch in front of you then tackle"..Will we see more "Ball Hawking?"
Brian Batko: Sure, but teams say that about their secondary every year. No one says "you're gonna see more of us letting them catch the pass and then us trying to bring them down quickly."
Carlo: Hi Brian, do you see the Steelers making a move to add a TE and/or a Safety before the start of the season?
Brian Batko: Nothing (or no one) that really jumps out at me, but it wouldn't be surprising given the history there.
BlawnoxBill: Looks like Steelers and Joe Haden will get deal done sooner rather than later. That is great news. My question is what do they do with Steven Nelson in a year or so if Justin Layne shows he is ready..
Brian Batko: It'd be a good problem to have. Let's see how Nelson fares this year in a new defense with a nice contract paid to him over the offseason.
412: Does James Washington look comfortable/ready to make a big contribution this year? I am still a little worried about the overall receiver depth...
Brian Batko: Ehhh jury's still out. He looks fine, but not exactly exploding onto the scene, in my view.
CtSteelersfan: Brian, if Ola has clearly outperformed Bud Dupree during camp would the team rotate them during the season to get Ola involved more? Thank you.
Brian Batko: Possibly, but i think there's a long way to go before we get to that crossroads. Ola has stood out more in his second-team reps, which makes sense. Dupree has gotten a veteran's off day or two. I don't even think a huge preseason (again) from Ola would necessarily have a huge bearing on the OLB situation right out of the gate. It's time for Bud to be "a gamer," if I may break out a coach cliche.
Krugerrand: Brian, can we safely presume from your column yesterday that you feel Switzer has the inside track in the roster battle?
Brian Batko: No, I wouldn't presume that. I just thought it was an interesting story/anecdote from him, and perhaps insightful information as far as that receiver competition goes. He still needs to prove himself like most other guys in that bunch.
Steel Yinz: Brian, I know you did not cover the Steelers last year, but does it look like the defense is ready to take a collective leap? Seems like we are set on the Dline, and if Dupree and be more consistent our linebackers seem exponentially better than last year. That pressure with an improved secondary seems like a good combination for a defense that finished 6th overall
Brian Batko: Yeah, I'd say there are fewer holes on paper than this time a year ago. But there are also question marks. Dupree, Bud. Davis, Sean. Barron, Mark. Bush, Devin. But given each guy's pedigree, there's absolutely potential for it all to come together and click.
Jacque Strap: Brian, big night for you Friday...have you done any reporting walk-throughs? Stand in front of a mirror asking mock post-game questions? Getting proper hydration?
Brian Batko: I've been waking up at 6 a.m. each morning to do a dry run down to Heinz Field. Locate the parking lot, walk up to the media entrance, then get in my car and drive back. Then head to Latrobe for camp.
BigAL456: Hey Brian, from everything I’ve been reading, it seems that Cam Sutton is having a heck of a camp. Do you see any high probability that he might beat out Hilton for the starting NB role? Thanks
Brian Batko: I don't know about high probability. I think the blitzing ability that we've seen there from Mike Hilton is second to none on this roster. But Sutton could be a really nice "utility man" sort of piece to keep in your back pocket in case of injury, lack of performance, sub-packages, etc.
Black and yellow: Which player have you had the most fun watching? Hope you’ve been enjoying yourself at Latrobe!
Brian Batko: I have been, thank you. Can I say Chris Boswell and Matthew Wright? It's the one position where I can definitely say how each player is performing!
Wisconsin Winters: Why must NFL players wear certain numbers for positions? I like to see single digit numbers playing WR and DB in collage. I remember a player wearing 00.
Brian Batko: I'm not sure about that one, but they have loosened up those restrictions a bit in recent years. Bud Dupree wears No. 48 as a linebacker. Mark Barron is strictly listed as a linebacker, but still wears the No. 26 from his safety days. You'll see some bizarre numbers on wideouts in the preseason. The Steelers don't have any, but you'll see some single-digit guys out there across the league.
Mark: Brian, how much will the starters play Friday night when Bruce Arians brings the Bucs to town?
Brian Batko: Probably very little. Don't expect to see Ben Roethlisberger at all, but other skills guys might get a series or two.
BB: Brian - have not seen much about Marcus Allen so far this camp....good or bad. Does he make the team this year? Thanks.
Brian Batko: I think he'll have to hold off Kameron Kelly, Dravon Askew-Henry and PJ Locke. Could go either way. Haven't loved him in coverage thus far.
Scl: Any update on if Diontae Johnson’s hip injury is serious?
Brian Batko: Don't think so. According to Mike Tomlin, the hip issue was actually Friday night, and then he was back practicing Sunday after missing Saturday. But Tomlin said he left Sunday with a groin. Could be the same thing, but regardless, there's no indication that it's bad.
iowasteelersfan: I think I'm in the minority that feels Conner is already as good of a back as Bells was, but with a desire to at least act like the team is more important than the individual. Am I wrong?
Brian Batko: On the first part, I'd say yeah. It's hard for me to get the best Bell years out of my brain. On the second part, no, not at all. I'll be curious to see if Bell is a problem at all this year for the Jets. I don't think he was as me-first as Antonio Brown, in retrospect.
Dr. Mike: I was cut off before I finished my question. I would like one of the PG sports writers to investigate just who signed off on AB being allowed to live in Latrobe during last year's camp at St. Vincent College. I can only imagine what that move had on the whole team's morale. If I were told that last year before camp I would have called it fake news.
Brian Batko: That's water under the bridge, if you will.
Kool-Aid: I think you have a good jump on the Tomlinisms.
Brian Batko: Thank you.
JerseySteel: Hi Brian - any players on the roster last year whose roster spot is vulnerable and any late round or UDFA who have a good chance to make the 53 man roster?
Brian Batko: Hi, JerseySteel. Probably Zach Banner and/or Jerald Hawkins on the OL. Seventh-round draft pick (Derwin Gray) isn't really trending up, but UDFA Fred Johnson is coming on strong. Eli Rogers could yet end up being a wide receiver casualty. Someone up there mentioned Marcus Allen, maybe him too.
Jon in Oregon: Has their long snapper returned from injury?
Brian Batko: Yes, Kam Canaday is in camp today
ALB: Brian, the Steelers are placing a lot hope on McDonald staying healthy. Has he ever made it through an entire season without missing time?
Brian Batko: He has never played 16 games in a season, no.
Kryder: Arent Haden’s skills starting to decline with age? We saw some dropoff last year. I worry about paying for 2 years based on performance we might not see again. Unless the thought is to move him to safety?
Brian Batko: I don't think so. Not sure they need to go the Rod Woodson route with him just yet. He claims he had as healthy and useful an offseason as ever.
Goldstar: Can you name 2 camp standouts - one performing better than expected and one performing worse than expected?
Brian Batko: Matt Feiler to the good, Josh Dobbs to the not-so-good. I think it'll be tough for him to hold off Mason Rudolph, but "stadium ball" will matter a lot.
John Strange: Which is the more likely realistic expectation for Big Ben's final seasons with the Steelers? Zero playoff wins? At least one deep playoff run? A Super Bowl win?
Brian Batko: The expectation is deep playoff run(s) and a Super Bowl win. I don't know what will happen.
BlawnoxBill: Did you look at the pics of Bens house online that he recently put up for sale? Does the PG pay enough for you to move your family in?
Brian Batko: My newspaper salary already affords me a mansion in the Hamptons, what do I want with a mansion in Hampton?
Jud: What's the word on our punter situation? Camp leg or legit tryout?
Brian Batko: I don't know that Ian Berryman will take the job, but I think it's a legit tryout. Could always look around the league at others, too. Lots of camp competitions out there but only two punters here.
paullochrane@yahoo.com: suppose the steelers start out 0-4, does ben get replaced? throws a ton of int's every year, steelers and ben start the seasons out slowly because he doesn't play in pre season, does that change? i predict 7-9
Brian Batko: No and no.
Utah Jim: Diontae Johnson has had a number of injuries going back to OTAs. Is it a concern?
Brian Batko: To me, it is a little bit. I just think you have to wonder a little bit about a smallish rookie who's been a bit fragile so far. Has looked dynamite at times though when he has practiced.
Tony: How good do you think Bush will be in the NFL? Pre pre season opinion.
Brian Batko: I'll stop short of predicting pro bowls like some did in the pre-draft. But of course, I think he'll be a starter, probably a good one. He was a top-10 pick, after all. Maybe it's because I'm new to this, but I'm just a little hesitant to drive the hype train.
Jon in Oregon: Steelers' first six games are NE, Seattle, SF, Cincy, Ravens and Chargers. What is your prediction of their record at the end of this run and more specifically, if you're willing, who will they beat and lose to?
Brian Batko: I'll predict 2-4, with wins at SF and Cincy, but I reserve the right to revise. Could just as easily say 4-2.
ALB: Brian, Ed B. always maintained that he was a reporter who covered the Steelers, not a Steelers fan. Where do you stand on that?
Brian Batko: I stand in the exact same spot.
Guest: Hi Brian - which backup OL are having a good camp?
Brian Batko: Not gonna claim to be an OL connoisseur but I think Zach Banner (now slimmer) has looked good at times with the second team. He's just so massive that it's tough to get around him a lot of the time. BJ Finney and Chuks Okorafor are the ones who most often get promoted to "varsity work" though, so any conversation of the backups should probably start with them. The UDFA Fred Johnson has looked the part, too, as a big boy (6-7, 326) who plays inside.
OC stiller fan: How has Artie B. Looked in camp? Any signs of improvement? Any buzz from the coaches on him.
Brian Batko: He can look like first-round pick Artie and no-option Artie on back-to-back plays. I asked Mike Tomlin about him Saturday and he didn't have much to say. Probably not a great sign, but I still see him being the No. 3 outside corner.
Greg: Who will have more receiving yards this year: James Washington, DJ, or Moncrief?
Brian Batko: At this point, on Aug. 6, I'll say Donte Moncrief. But I think all three could be fairly close, especially Moncrief and Washington.
iowasteelersfan: Can we really expect a contract for Hargrave? For a player who only plays in 40% of the D snaps - it will be hard to establish fair market value for him - when compared to other team's DT who play more often, thus may be valued and paid a higher amount.
Brian Batko: Former Steeler Steve McLendon played around the same percentage of snaps last year for the Jets and makes 2.5 million deal this offseason. That's just one reference point.
seferg: Do defensive players get taught to wrap up anymore? Seems too many times last year they went for the big collision, the target bounced off and continued his merry way.
Brian Batko: I don't know, but I am going to wrap up this chat. Sorry if I couldn't get to your questions, folks, but maybe you'll see it in this week's mailbag or, better yet, in our Skinny Post newsletter! Only way to find out is if you subscribe https://t.co/NfEhqKqxVX?amp=1
Heading out to practice in a jiffy, enjoy the rest of your Tuesdays.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.