Brian Batko: Afternoon, folks *hat tip*

My first chat in two weeks, and last before Steelers fever hits Saint Vincent College. Here we go...

John Strange: 3 playoff wins in the past 8 years. How many years will it take for the Steelers to get their next 3 playoff wins?

Brian Batko: Two

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Hey, let's do a poll

NH Steelers fan: Hi Brian. Does chemistry or communication suffer if Tomlin and Butler decide to start Bush and Barron as ILBs? Williams is a thumper with improved coverage skills but he still presents as a glaring liability when QBs audible to take advantage of his lack of speed.

Brian Batko: I definitely think you could see those two guys as the Week 1 starters, and then maybe Vince Williams is the one used more in sub-packages, on obvious blitzing downs, etc. Communication will be one of the talking points - pun intended - from Day 1 of camp when it comes to Devin Bush and his development.

John Strange: Your prediction for the Steelers Rookie of the Year .... if not Bush.

Brian Batko: Hmmm well I suppose Bush is the obvious choice, and I'm not sure there's a close second but if not him, I'll go with Diontae Johnson. Best combination of pedigree and opportunity.

Advertise with us

FloridaSteelers: Brian, who do you feel is going to be the training camp star this year?

Brian Batko: Training camp star, eh? Well, that's a label that probably lends itself most to the skill positions, so I'll use that to narrow down my answer. How about Mason Rudolph? If he looks good, he can probably put to rest the questions of whether it's him or Josh Dobbs as this team's backup QB. Everyone loves to evaluate QB play, so if he's dropping dimes, fans and media will notice.

John Strange: Of the 3 QBs taken in the same draft who would most likely play for a different team before the end of their career? Big Ben, Rivers or Manning?

Brian Batko: J.P. Losman!

OK, OK, I'll field the actual question as phrased. Maybe Eli Manning? If only because Daniel Jones is there now, and if Eli isn't ready to hang 'em up, perhaps someone else would throw him a bone. I don't think it's a particularly likely scenario for any of that trio though.

Advertise with us

PITTOCLT: Brian, what are you looking forward to the most about covering your first Steelers camp?

Brian Batko: Injecting my opinion on the debate between Sharky's and Dino's as the go-to spot for good grub in Latrobe. But honestly, I'm definitely looking forward to covering what could be the first days of a future star in Devin Bush. Being in the general orbit of JuJu Smith-Schuster is probably something that a lot of non-journalists would think is really cool. And, of course, the fans!

'Double Divot Dewey: This is the time of the year when I am tempted to turn off any and all connections to football, fearing that the next scroll on the bottom of the screen is an injury update concerning the Steeler's......Do you have any such concerns during the next 3-4 week period? There is so much promise this year and season ending injury at the wrong position could be telling....your thoughts.

Brian Batko: I'm also looking forward to getting back to covering actual things that are happening, rather than reacting to random listicles and "reaching" for ideas this time of year. Unfortunately, that will include injuries, but hey, the Steelers got out of the spring unscathed. So, consider yourself lucky, maybe. And knock on wood.

Ryno: 84 had 15 touchdowns last season. Do you think the Steelers will make up those 15 touchdowns by what their 2019 offense scores, AND by what their 2019 defense does NOT give up?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I think that's the plan. No one's expecting Donte Moncrief or Diontae Johnson to hit pay dirt 15 times and be the second coming of AB. Probably can't even expect that from JuJu Smith-Schuster, though he might come close. Defense needs to be better, not just at keeping points off the scoreboard, but also creating takeaways, which go hand-in-hand.

Rayray: How does the pittsburgh post gazettes coverage of the steelers differ from bob labriollas coverage of the team?

Brian Batko: Bob covers the Steelers for Steelers.com, which is an arm of the organization, but he does a great job, is extremely knowledgeable and remains objective despite that, at least from what I can tell so far. Reporters for the team site are probably going to have better and more access a lot of the time, but that doesn't mean we can't still make our coverage at the P-G valuable in other ways. The way I see it, we're in Pittsburgh: A lot of people and outlets are covering this franchise from wall to wall.

Eric L: Good afternoon Brian! Hope you had a good week off! Q1: are you nervous going into your first training camp with the team? Q2: There is 1 year left (I believe) left on Def Coordinators contract. I would love to see some periodic articles written this year on 1st what he needs to do to accomplish getting a new contact? 2nd: the dynamics between DC, HC and new defensive assistant (who previously was a DC) will or will not allow him to be successful in getting that new contract or is Austin “in the wings” for a reason? Thank you!

Brian Batko: Oh, I enjoyed my time off, for sure. Although I was supposed to go to New Orleans and chickened out because of the tropical storm/hurricane threat. Probably would've been fine.

Advertise with us

I'm always nervous trying to live up to the standard set by P-G sports boss Tyler Batiste. But the standard is the standard. As for Keith Butler, Teryl Austin and the dynamic there with Mike Tomlin, I think we'll see how that all plays out depending on the performance of the defense this year. If it doesn't improve, and as a result the overall record doesn't improve, have to imagine someone's going to need to answer for that. Austin is absolutely a capable hand there, and it shows in his resume.

Kool-Aid: Any truth to a rumor the Steelers are involved in talks to acquire Jalen Ramsey?

Brian Batko: Hadn't seen that until just now when you mentioned it, but uh, I highly doubt it.

Tampa Too: I think this could be Mike Tomlin's most challenging year as a head coach. With both losing star players and coming off a non playoff year. This could be a year in which he can show how good (or not so good) of a coach he is. Your thoughts?

Brian Batko: I agree. The guys who created the most distractions for this group are gone, so that can no longer be an excuse. But to add to your point, it's not an easy schedule, by any means. Kind of reminds me of a couple years ago when Pat Narduzzi and Pitt were coming off their 5-7 season. It was a crucial year for him, I thought then, and he responded by coaching them to a divisional title.

Advertise with us

Doug from Raleigh: Poll aside, what do YOU think will happen concerning a possible Tomlin extension?

Doug from Raleigh: PS I think NOT extending him would create it's own distraction

Brian Batko: Looks like the poll is veering toward "No" at the moment. I think he'll get one, but I also won't be shocked if he doesn't. But you took the thought(s) from my head a little bit there, Doug. We know the Rooney family has always valued stability.

John Strange: Do you expect dramatically improved OL play in Denver now that Munch is there?

Brian Batko: No idea, but they're already writing about that/him in Denver. Reportedly, he's working wonders with some guy I'd never heard of https://t.co/ruvGMOEroy

Advertise with us

Neilson : Talking about the polls, how many yards AB in Oaktown? +/- 1250 yards with 10 TDs?

Brian Batko: I think Antonio Brown will have another great season individually, but with that defense, a lot of it might come while trailing late in games. So, I'll go over on the yards, under on the TDs. I'm still a little bit of a believer in Derek Carr, too, at least enough for him to get the ball to Tony.

Jeff: Hey Brian great chats. why over the last few years we hear about these great special teams guys (big Red and others) yet our special teams suck (for the most part)?

Rayray: Brian, what is the legacy of former Steelers quarterback Tee Martin?

Brian Batko: Paved the way for Brian St. Pierre, Omar Jacobs and Dennis Dixon

Advertise with us

John Strange: Was the terrible play in the playoffs just a bad game for Lamar Jackson e.g. Big Ben in his 1st Super Bowl, or did the Ravens make a monumental mistake in getting rid of Flacco?

Brian Batko: You don't have to look high and low to find a bunch of Lamar Jackson doubters. They'll tell you he's more of a running back than a QB, and he'll never be a good enough passer at this level. HOWEVER .... no, I don't think the Ravens made a mistake, both by taking a chance on him and by moving on from Joe Flacco. Mr. Elite is in Denver now, and I don't think the Broncos will be very good this year with him under center.

Brian Batko: Breaking:

kemo: How much will Snell and Samuels see the ball in this offense? Any chance either of them can play sort of a H back TE hybrid? I would like to see the ball spread around a bit more than in the past.

Brian Batko: Chris Kemoeatu, is that you? That's a question that a lot of folks have entering this season concering Mike Tomlin and if he intends to run the wheels off James Conner. I'm actually not sure how much that matters, though. I mean, yeah, you want a Pro Bowl-caliber back like Conner to stay healthy (or as healthy as possible playing running back in the NFL) but I think Samuels showed a year ago he's plenty capable, and Snell could be, too. Love Samuels' versatility, though I'm not sure I can envision a role like that as much for Snell. To me, you just have to get Samuels involved somehow, and Snell can at least be a short-yardage thumper from the get-go, based on his tape.

Advertise with us

John Strange: "Brian, what is the legacy of former Steelers quarterback Tee Martin?" ---- Drafted ahead of Tom Brady

Brian Batko: As was Giovanni Carmazzi

Robert Frisby : The loss of Brown is big, it seemed that Ben was starting to have trouble pushing it down field. Was also missing JuJu as well as Brown do you think he just needs adjusting.

Brian Batko: Does Ben Roethlisberger need adjusting? I don't know about that. I think he needs to make better decisions with the ball from time to time, and I don't think even he would argue that after an NFL-high 16 picks. But generally speaking, I think Ben's style of play still gives the Steelers a great chance of winning. We'll see if he can develop the same kind of scramble-drill, broken-play chemistry he had with AB with JuJu or one of the new guys.

PITTOCLT: Brian, if you could add 1 past Steeler to this team to help them get to the Super Bowl, who would it be? My sleeper pick is Gary Anderson.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: That's a darn good question and darn good sleeper pick. Anyone else wanna chime in? I'll open this one up to the roomn.

'Double Divot Dewey: Troy P....................

Brian Batko: You could go with a transcendent all-timer like Joe Greene or Jack Lambert or Jack Ham, or someone at more of a need position, like a Heath Miller or Greg Lloyd. But yeah, Troy Polamalu is probably a good combination of both those ideas. Heck, even if you want to stick with a kicker, how about Jeff Reed? He was really good before he wasn't.

Brian Batko: Or, if you really wanted to troll, Antonio Brown...

Guest: Hey Brian. When the Steelers play the Jets, do you think some of the defensive players will want to hit Bell a little bit harder than other players?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I don't know, dear Guest. I'm not sure how much that type of hostility really exists in the NFL these days, or any of the pro leagues. Guys are friends through social media a lot of times before they even meet in real life. Joe Haden just said yesterday on a radio show that LB is his favorite running back. Maybe deep down, some former teammates feel that vitriol toward Bell and/or Brown, but I think being a player in this league is more of a brotherhood than anything.

Neilson : Why do Steelers struggle so much on the west coast? Third of the stadium are Steeler fans!

Brian Batko: It ain't easy dealing with time changes and unfamiliar terrain, Neilson. We did a whole episode of our Field Study podcast on this very topic, so you should check it out if you haven't already https://newsinteractive.post-gazette.com/field-study-podcast/sleep-opt...

Brian Batko: Speaking of podcasts and new features and stuff like that, keep your eyes - or ears? - peeled for our soon-to-be all-sports one from the P-G scribes like myself, Ray Fittipaldo, Jason Mackey, Nubjyas Wilborn, Matt Vensel, Craig Meyer. And if you just have a need for more Steelers content in your life, consider subscribing to our latest newsletter, The Skinny Post, put together each week by none other than your faithful chat moderator today. First one drops tomorrow! https://t.co/0F1uXGuEU1

bbrian: Rudolph/Dobbs...who's #2 on opening day?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I'm going with Mason Rudolph. But a better question might be whether it even matters, right? One could argue that if something happens to Ben Roethlisberger, this team isn't going anywhere anyway. But that's enough nihilism for this chat in one day. There will be plenty more of that with me on the keyboard.

And hey, look at that, a nearly deadlocked finish in today's Mike Tomlin poll. Boy if that ain't a poll-arizing conversation. That's all the time I have - see everyone in Latrobe.