Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Post your questions and we'll get started soon.
Steeltowntim@aol.com: Ray do you think that rookies starting is a sign that we are much weaker on defense than in the past. I remember when Troy was drafted he did not even start or does it have to do with being cap heavy in 3-4 positions and having to start less expensive players.
Ray Fittipaldo: You have a point. In addition to Polamalu waiting, Cam Heyward had to wait his turn, too. But I also think it's a sign of the times in the salary cap era of the NFL. When you spend draft assets on a player like Devin Bush you're going to play him because you want to find out about him sooner rather than later. The Steelers have to find out about these guys sooner because of the 2011 CBA and the fifth-year option. You don't want to wait a year or two to find out if you want to re-sign someone.
Steelers2019: Love your chats. I may be in the minority here but, I love Mike Tomlin. Have you heard anything on a contract extention this year?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers usually sign Tomlin to a contract extension early in camp when he has two years left on his contract. So the first week of camp will be important to watch in terms of his future. And no, I haven't heard anything about an extension. Tomlin and Art II usually have that conversation this week after they return from vacations.
Ron: Hi Ray, appreciate your chats. I'm mystified why Ben takes very few snaps during the preseason. It seems to take him 2 or 3 games into the season to find himself against opposing defenses other than his own. I understand the injury risk, but a couple of handoffs is not getting him ready.
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: I know the opener last season was a disaster for the offense. But I'm not sure if extended reps in preseason games would be all that helpful. Maybe a few more might be a good idea, but you don't want to get the most important player on the team injured in a meaningless game. There are a lot of factors that go into September football. The Patriots and Tom Brady have been notorious slow starters in the past. It's about getting a feel for personnel, opponents and game planning.
John in Florida : Good morning, and thanks for the chats. I feel this is the year we will see just how good of a coach Mike Tomlin is. A good coach needs to be able to make adjustments to get the most from his players. Don Shula and Bill Belichick are examples of coaches who could adjust their style to fit their personnel. With no Bell or Brown, the Steelers will have to better utilize all their players and not just a few stars. The defense needs to utilize their new players to counter the young offensive stars they will face, including two athletic quarterbacks in their division. Do you feel Tomlin will be up for this challenge?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm sure the 2018 season won't go down as one of his best for a variety of reasons so I think he knows the pressure is on. That might be a good thing. Sometimes it's good to have to tension ratcheted up a few notches. Being comfortable can be a dangerous thing in the NFL, and I definitely think the head coach and players are a bit uncomfortable after what happened in 2018.
Stinkpot: Love your chats. What is your opinion of recent discussions about eliminating 2 preseason games and adding 2 games to the regular season?
Ray Fittipaldo: The players don't want it. I think the owners are doing it because the CBA will be up in 2021. They'll want to use it as a bargaining chip. Head injuries are already a concern for the sport. I'm not sure it's wise for the owners to put the idea out there even if they have no intentions of following through on it.
Jon Snow: I believe the defense will make a major step this year. Due to the record last year many of the things they improved on were lost in the losses. The addition of Bush, Barron and Steven Nelson are upgrades. This is a show me year for Dupree. I predict 10 sacks or more. Davis should settle in at safety and the D line is healthy. This will be a top five defense. Hoping they sigh Haden so he is happy.
Ray Fittipaldo: That's a positive outlook, and I agree with you on many points. The Steelers are better on paper. But the coaches have to put the new players in positions to make an impact and those new players have to perform. It's not as easy as you think when you're adding new players to the mix. It's going to take some time for everything to come together.
Steeler Fan : Ray - enjoy your chats - with training camp set to start, can you explain the key attributes that distinguish guards from tackles? It seems the positions are interchangeable when a player goes down and they send in a lineman - I’ve never quite understood the distinction in positions - thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: In the NFL, your backup offensive linemen have to be position flexible because of the 53-man roster limit. So guys like BJ Finney are valuable because they can play guard and center. And guys like Matt Feiler are vaulable because he can play guard and tackle. But there are big differences in guards and tackles when it comes to putting together a starting five. Tackles generally are taller, with longer arms and tend to be more athletic because they have to deal with better athletes rushing off the edge. Guards tend to be more stout and stronger because they have to deal with bigger interior defensive linemen.
Mike in PA: Why don't teams try to find one guy as their Kicker-Punter. This used to be common in the NFL. It would save a roster spot. It's about the leg. There must be guys who can do BOTH.
Ray Fittipaldo: Both positions have become specialized to the point where it's difficult to find one player to perform both jobs adequately. Obviously, that's good because good punters can help the defense and good kickers can help the offense, but as you point out it does take up an extra roster spot.
SMF: Hi Ray: Do you think Tomlin has learned that over using the running back with 30 touches per game shortens their season? They have 2 if not 3 to use now, especially since they can catch short pass routes.
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin has always liked to use one back as his main guy. He has been fortunate to have players like Le'Veon Bell and James Conner that can handle all downs -- running, catching and picking up the blitz. He does have Jaylen Samuels and Benny Snell as options this season. Maybe he'll switch things up, but it would be a big change for him if he did divide the playing time more evenly.
SaltyRon: Ray - what is the most intriguing position battle going into this year's training camp amongst WR, K, OT, ILB or S positions?
Ray Fittipaldo: I guess I'd have to go with receiver just because it's a high-profile position on this team. I think they'll be fine with James Washington, Dionate Johnson and Donte Moncrief to complement juJu Smith-Schuster. Who will be the No. 2 will be a topic during camp because people pay attention to who is "starting" but I cann envision a scenario where all three have key roles.

Derek Carr: After AB left I noticed him and DC at our high school here in Cali. there were trying to get some chemistry going I suppose. They were there everyday doing things,..I work at the school. What I noticed most was AB doing all the talking and directing, and it got me thinking, is it possible that AB tried to control a lot of things and Ben just kinda got sick of it, and so did the coaches? So now with the Steelers having a new OC and JuJu and this group, if it's possible this group will be even better without AB having so much say?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know if this group will be "better" without Antonio Brown, but the Steelers are certainly capable of winning more games without him. That's the beauty of football. It's a team sport that takes 11 players contributing toward the same goal. I'm not sure the Steelers had that when Antonio Brown was on the team. Obviously, Antonio Brown wasn't a great team player. He was selfish and had his own best interests at heart. So in that sense, having receivers that are committed to the team and buy into the team concept can be something that propels this team forward in 2018. Of course, they have to produce, but as I mentioned earlier I think the talent is there. They just have to go out there and prove it.
ALB: Ray, in your opinion what position has the least amount of depth, where an injury or two could be a major problem?
Ray Fittipaldo: Definitely tight end and safety. Don't be surprised if the Steelers make a move during camp to address the lack of depth.
Steeler in Houston : Don’t you think we should renew contracts of Conner back Joe Haden? Let him finish this season and will offer for back up position if they needed!
Ray Fittipaldo: Haden is priority No. 1 in my opinion. He is their top CB and his contract is up after the season. To complicate matters they don't have a lot of proven depth behind him. Conner's rookie contract does not expire until after the 2020 season so there is no need to extend him now. Others that are up for extensions this summer are safety Sean Davis and nose tackle Javon Hargrave.
Steeler Joe: What on earth will the Steelers do if the Vanimal goes down to an injury. That particular position is thinner than AB's skin.
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree! See above answer about depth at certain positions.
Steeler Joe: Do you think Juju handles the No. 1 role well this year? Can he beat double- and triple-coverage?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think he's capable of doing it, but he has to prove it. And don't forget the way GM Kevin Colbert has stockpiled receivers. Diontae Johnson, James Washington or Donte Moncrief could emerge as the next star if teams want to concentrate on JuJu.
AK: I think the 18 game schedule is a horrible idea. Do you? Wouldn’t the NFL rosters need to be expanded for an 18 game schedule? How many roster spots?
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree. There is a lot to work out. And I am certainly not a fan of that idea of players only being eligible to play in 16 of the games.
coach15: Why wouldn't it be beneficial for Steelers to work out their cap situation, so that they could make an ATTRACTIVE offer, even for one year, for a free safety, such as Darian Stewart or Tre Boston, or strong safety Eric Berry--heavy on incentives---their depth would be devastating, if one goes down early on.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know if they need a starter. I just think they might need better and/or more experienced players behind Sean Davis and Terrell Edmunds.
mrbig: what was THE biggest reason they missed the playoffs last year... drama? coaching? kicking? I feel it was that the defense couldn't close out games-
Ray Fittipaldo: If I had to pick on reason it would be the defense. They couldn't hold a lot of late leads late in the season. But as you mentioned there were other factors in those losses. Chris Boswell was a huge factor. Ben Roethlisberger's untimely INTs were another factor. I can point to Xavier Grimble's fumble and many others gaffes that also contributed to the collapse. Good teams find ways to overcome mistakes like that. Obviously, the Steelers weren't good enough to overcome all of them last season.
Ryno: What do you think the Steelers record would have been last season had Boswell had a normal season like he had the previous year? Two more wins? Three more wins?
Ray Fittipaldo: Hard to say but 11-5 sounds about right. They were 13-3 when he made those clutch kicks in those four games in the middle of the 2017 season.
Jud: Your thoughts on who will be QB2?
Ray Fittipaldo: I expect Mason Rudolph to have a strong camp and to wrestle the job away from Josh Dobbs.
Jud: If a deal doesn't get done for Tomlin, does that indicate he's on the hot seat or that he's thinking about stepping away for now?
Ray Fittipaldo: It might not be either. It could just be the Steelers want to see how he handles the team after what happened last season.
Jud: Would/could we get trade value for Dobbs?
Ray Fittipaldo: Some believed Landry Jones had some value around this time last year. He's not even in the league. I'm not saying Dobbs is Jones, but it's not like he has a track record of success.
Hate heat and crabs: Ray when a player is on the practice squad for the entire year does that count as a year accrued toward their potential pension for playing five years in the NFL?
Ray Fittipaldo: No, but they'd make over $100,000 if they were on the p squad all season.
VANINAL FAN: do you see justin layne getting significant playing time in the regular season if Nelson and Haden stay healthy?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not unless he finds a role in sub-packages. And I don't see him finding a "significant" role unless there are injuries.
coach15: Why would Steelers think that DuPree will catch fire at this point of his career? Steelers agreeing to current financial offer with Bud, is not going to make him an outstanding pass rusher--
Ray Fittipaldo: It's not like the Steelers had options to replace Dupree. They decided to pick up his fifth-year option because they believe he'll continue to get better and because they don't have a player waiting in the wings to take over for him. Big year for obviously and he'll have to produce double-digit sacks and be better as a run defender in order to earn his big pay day.
Utah Jim: The players will agree to an 18-game schedule in return for guaranteed contracts. The owners will agree to the guaranteed contracts because it’s inevitable anyway and they get their 2 more games of revenue. It always comes down to money. Am I wrong?
Ray Fittipaldo: There are other ways to generate more revenue than going to an 18-game schedule.
James from Philly : Hey Ray-- Thanks for the chats. In your opinion, where does Mark Barron fit in this defense? I am sensing another Burnett situation, but with a player who has a lot more to offer. Hope he is utilized correctly!
Ray Fittipaldo: The nice thing is Barron is a versatile player. He can start as an ILB if needed or he can play the dime linebacker role in sub-packages. The wild card is how he handles a reduced role if it comes to that. That was a huge issue with Burnett. He was signed to be a starter and he started to cause problems when Edmunds became the starter and he was just the dime linebacker. Barron was signed to start at ILB, but then the Steelers landed Devin Bush in the draft. So that will be something to watch as the summer goes on. I specifically asked Barron about his role when he signed. He said he was signed to be a "three-down linebacker". That might not be his role now so I'll watch closely to see how he handles another role if it comes to that.
arrowhead63: Do you think it is a bit early to extend Tomlin ?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's not early because the Steelers operate a certain way. They've always extended their head coaches with two years left on their contract. But this is a special circumstance with Tomlin coming off what many consider to be his worst season. There are plenty of good reasons to wait and let the season play out, but only Art Rooney II knows for sure what will happen.
TC in Big D: I really think the defense will step up this year given the new pieces at ILB and CB. The talent is there but will we still be plagued by the ongoing "communication issues" that are blamed but never fixed?
Ray Fittipaldo: Good question, but how many of those communication issues happened because Artie Burns was in the game and didn't do his job? I know they've had issues for years with that type of thing, but I think having Nelson and Haden as the starters will eliminate some of those issues.
fredward: Of all the late round picks and undrafted free agents the Steelers got this year, who you feel is most likely to stick and make an impact?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Sutton Smith will find his way onto the 53-man roster, and I can see him developing into a special teams demon.
Craig: Good Afternoon Ray, What is your opinion on holding camp away from a teams home facility. Do you see any advantage or disadvantage?
Ray Fittipaldo: I know Tomlin loves it. He believes being away from distractions brings his team closer together. So there are the obvious advantages that come along with being together for nearly a month before the season begins. I don't see any disadvantages in going away.
AA: Which WR would you keep, Rogers or Switzer?
Ray Fittipaldo: That will be a good camp battle. I think both know only one will be on the 53. I suppose I'd go with Switzer, but there's not a lot of difference between him and Eli. They're pretty much the same player.
OldSchool: I think Tomlin having a bad year was very overrated. They clearly didn't expect Bell to sit out the year or Boswell to fall apart. Either of those things being different equals a few more wins and no one's talking. People will miss being in the hunt every year when it ends. Thank God Twitter wasn't around for Cowher's bad years, which were a lot worse. do you really think in game coaching makes that big of a difference in a lot of games?
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, maybe they should have anticipated Bell skipping the season because he was on the record saying he might do it in 2017. So shame on them if they were not prepared for that. And believe me, there was much more to the collapse than Boswell's failings.
APK: Switzer is a better returner than Rogers, wouldn’t you say?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure about being better. I'd say the same, but he does return kickoffs and Eli doesn't do that.
John Strange: Hi Ray, If players could only play in 16 out of an 18 game season why not just start your best available for the first 16 and let injuries dictate who might miss a game or two? BTW I think this has zero chance of actually happening.
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree. I don't think it will ever happen. But what if your QB stays healthy and plays the first 16 games and you need one win in the final two games to secure a playoff berth? That would make for some interesting game planning.
Duke: Hi Ray...I have been out of town and have not heard if K Chris Blewitt has been signed since he was released. If not, could the Steelers bring him in to compete with Boswell? Thanks .
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers signed former UCF kicker Matthew Wright to compete with Boswell.
Frank: In your opinion what are the top 3 position battles to watch during training camp & the preseason?
Ray Fittipaldo: 1. No. 2 receiver
Ray Fittipaldo: No. 2 Backup TE
Ray Fittipaldo: No. 3 Backup safeties
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe right tackle, but I think Feiler has the inside track on the starting job
SaltyRon: With all of the new defensive additions this off-season, who do you expect to be on the field defensively for passing downs in addition to the starting 4 in the secondary?
Ray Fittipaldo: Mike Hilton will be the starting slot CB. And Mark Barron is likely going to be the dime LB. Hilton usually replaces the nose tackle and the dime linebacker is usually taking the place of a two-down ILB.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK that will do it for this week. Next chat is Monday July 29. Now it's off to Latrobe...






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.