With training camp now two weeks away, the preseason opener less than a month away and Week 1 just 59 days away, one of the biggest questions looming over the Steelers is what, exactly, their offense will look like.
Not only is Antonio Brown in a new city, but so is Jesse James, leaving shoes to fill across the team’s pass-catching spectrum. If backup tight end is your most gaping hole, then your roster’s probably in pretty good shape, but that doesn’t mean offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner won’t have to tweak some plans in his second year running the show.
Let’s take a look at an article posted Wednesday in which ESPN X’s and O’s guru Matt Bowen chooses the NFL’s best offense in each offensive personnel grouping, based on 2018, combined with numbers on personnel grouping frequency from SharpFootballStats.com. The specifics vary slightly between the two sources, but for the most part, they tell us how the Steelers liked to line up a year ago, including where they were able to exploit matchups the best.
Most notable is that Bowen (a former NFL safety) singles out the Steelers as the team that most effectively utilized “22 personnel” — that’s two running backs, two tight ends and one wide receiver. Naturally, it’s more of a run-based grouping, and the Steelers used it on 6% of their snaps (double the league-wide average) according to Sharp Football Stats. But it’s also helpful for a team with a dominant wideout who can win one-on-one battles, such as an Antonio Brown.
From @NFLMatchup — Breaking down the #Steelers power run game. Gap schemes to create daylight + big play opportunities for RB James Conner. pic.twitter.com/UgFFB2yWqr
— Matt Bowen (@MattBowen41) October 28, 2018
According to Bowen’s metrics, the Steelers and Los Angeles Chargers tied for the NFL lead with 90 snaps out of 22 personnel, and the New Orleans Saints excelled in it, as well. But he writes that the Steelers get the slight edge in running it the best, citing Ben Roethlisberger completing 15 of a league-high 19 pass attempts in such scenarios.
So, if the Steelers are so (relatively) good with two backs, two tight ends and one receiver, does that mean that new backup tight end Xavier Grimble will have a more significant role than simply being insurance behind starter Vance McDonald? And if so, is it worth worrying about his capabilities there in taking over for James, now with the Detroit Lions after posting a career-high 423 yards on 30 catches with two touchdowns?
Read More
That brings us to the other Steelers mentioned in Bowen’s piece. He highlights them as the team that was heaviest in usage, and most efficient, in one set: 00 personnel. That’s a true five-wide grouping, which the Steelers ran between 30 and 32 times, depending on the source. At 6.7 yards per attempt on 24-of-30 passing, per ESPN, the Steelers were easily the most productive offense with five receivers on the field. Makes sense, with a veteran quarterback who can get rid of the ball quickly and a strong offensive line that can protect all on its own.
But the Steelers also like to line up shifty slot receiver Ryan Switzer in the backfield every once in a while, meaning they could come out in 00 personnel and not necessarily an empty formation. Either way, with a tight end corps thin on experience and a potentially crowded wide receiver bunch — JuJu Smith-Schuster, Donte Moncrief, James Washington, rookie Diontae Johnson, Switzer and perhaps even Eli Rogers — maybe the Steelers use five at a time even more than they did last season.
Of course, there are other ways around replacing the lost parts of the offense. Jaylen Samuels, anyone? He’s a hybrid type of player who could line up in the backfield, in the slot or out wide. Roosevelt Nix can be deployed as an in-line blocker at tight end, possibly increasing his usage from just 9.86% of the offensive snaps in 2018 (even fewer than Grimble when he was the third tight end).
The primary story line for the Steelers offense entering training camp still will be who’s lining up opposite Smith-Schuster as the No. 2, and how the wideout pecking order goes from there, but Fichtner has plenty of options for divvying up playing time after losing one workhorse receiver in Brown. Smith-Schuster, McDonald and James Conner will hog snaps, but beyond that, creativity could be key in scheming around Roethlisberger.
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.