When the Steelers made Cameron Heyward their highest-paid defensive player in 2015, he quickly blossomed into one of the NFL’s elite players. He has registered 30 of his 45 career sacks in the past four seasons, was named All-Pro in 2017 and earned Pro Bowl nods in 2017 and 2018.
Heyward was bypassed on the Steelers’ pay scale in September 2017 when fellow defensive end Stephon Tuitt signed a five-year, $60 million contract that pays him an average of $12 million a season, $1.5 million more per season than Heyward.
The Steelers still are waiting for Tuitt to blossom into the player they believe he can be. Injuries were a factor in 2017, but he has produced just 8½ sacks since signing his big contract. In his five-year NFL career, he has 20 sacks, with his career-high 6½ coming in the 2015 season.
Tuitt isn’t just the Steelers’ highest-paid defensive player. According to overthecap.com, Tuitt is 10th in average salary among interior defensive linemen behind Aaron Donald, Fletcher Cox, J.J. Watt, Geno Atkins, Kawann Short, Grady Jarrett, Marcel Dareus, Linval Joseph and Sheldon Richardson.
Six of those players recorded more sacks than Tuitt last season and a few on the list, including Dareus, excel as run-stoppers. One question the Steelers face as they prepare for the 2019 season: Are they receiving good return on their investment?
Watt, who makes $16.6 million per season, is coming off a 16-sack season and is averaging 11½ sacks a season during his eight-year NFL career. The Steelers don’t count on Tuitt to produce sacks the way the Texans rely on Watt, but they have allowed their ends to have more freedom to rush the passer in recent years. Heyward’s sack numbers reflect this change.
Read More
Tuitt has missed six games the past two seasons, and he was bothered by elbow and back injuries for most of the 2017 season. He injured his elbow on the second play of the opener in Cleveland and came back to contribute at less than 100 percent.
Nonetheless, Tuitt knows he can be more productive. He mentioned a few “slip-offs” from last season, when quarterbacks escaped his pressure and were able to elude sacks. He’s focusing on completing plays next season.
“I have to be a better finisher,” said Tuitt, a second-round pick out of Notre Dame in 2014. “Once I become a better finisher, I’ll be more dominant, making more plays for the defense.”
Tuitt’s 5½ sacks last season were one fewer than third-year nose tackle Javon Hargrave, who got his 6½ sacks in 237 fewer snaps. Hargrave is entering the final season of his rookie contract and is a candidate to get an extension.
Outside linebacker T.J. Watt (13) and Heyward (8) led the Steelers in sacks while Tuitt tied for fourth along with outside linebacker Bud Dupree.
Tuitt remains a very strong run defender and annually ranks among the top-rated defensive linemen in the league by Pro Football Focus. He just missed being ranked among PFF’s top 101 players for a second consecutive season.
There could come a time when the Steelers must decide if Tuitt is playing up to his contract, but it’s not now. He has four years remaining on the deal he signed in 2017. He is only 26, and he has demonstrated a willingness to play through injuries. There also is the tantalizing thought that he could become an All-Pro if he ever finds a way to stay injury-free and put it all together.
The Steelers don’t make a habit of releasing players with multiple years remaining on their contracts, but a month before Tuitt was drafted they cut outside linebacker LaMarr Woodley with three years remaining on a six-year, $61.5 million contract. Woodley struggled with injuries during his final few years with the team, his production dipped, and he also was criticized by teammates for not staying in shape year-round.
Tuitt has struggled with injuries, but no one in the organization believes Tuitt’s work ethic has anything to do with it. He took part in the third week of OTAs last week after sitting out most of the first two weeks with an injury. The Steelers clearly are taking their time with him this spring in hopes of keeping him healthy for the regular season.
The Steelers are hoping the cautious approach will lead to a full season. Tuitt hasn’t played in all 16 games since his rookie year. He has missed at least two games in each of the past four seasons.
The Steelers, who gave up several late leads last season en route to missing the playoffs, could use a healthy and disruptive Tuitt in the middle of their defense.

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.