Welcome to Brian Batko’s weekly Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds. Let’s get started:

ALB: [Maurkice] Pouncey has said when Ben hangs it up, so will he. Have a QB and center who played their careers together ever entered the HOF together?

Brian: As I predicted I would do Tuesday, I pilfered this query from my weekly chat. Partly because you all should send in more mailbag questions, but also because I couldn’t answer it off the top of my head.

What I can tell you now is that no, a quarterback and his center never have entered the Hall of Fame in the same induction class. There are only nine tandems of that sort even in the Hall currently, and the closest would be Warren Moon (2006) and Bruce Matthews (2007). But that’s hardly a good comparison to Roethlisberger-Pouncey, considering Moon went on to play for other teams and Matthews also played other positions on the offensive line.

Advertise with us

Mike Webster and Terry Bradshaw undoubtedly are the best combination in Steelers history, but Bradshaw got to the NFL sooner and left sooner. By the time Bradshaw became a first-ballot Hall of Famer in 1989, Webster was still playing, albeit in Kansas City.

For Pouncey and Roethlisberger to make it work, the center will almost certainly have to adhere to his no-Ben-no-me promise, which is no guarantee considering he’s more than seven years younger. Five seasons after Roethlisberger hangs up his cleats, he’ll have an excellent chance of being inducted in his first year of eligibility. You probably can’t say the same for Pouncey, who likely needs to bolster his credentials in order to get a bronze bust at all. Through nine seasons, two of which were lost to injury, Pouncey has two first-team All-Pro nods (as good a gauge as any to evaluate offensive linemen). He’s also been chosen to the Pro Bowl all seven of his healthy seasons, which is quite impressive, but he doesn’t have a Super Bowl and the longevity bullet on his resume won’t wow anyone at this point.

Now, say Pouncey stays on the field, and Roethlisberger plays out the new deal that takes him through 2021 — or longer? If those two can help the Steelers win another Super Bowl or two, and Pouncey gets his first All-Pro selection since 2014 … well, even then, seven-time All-Pro center Kevin Mawae isn’t getting in until this year, after retiring in 2009. Seeing Roethlisberger and Pouncey together in Canton might be a long shot, and in the same year, a longer one.

Alan in Nashville: For so many years, all the way back to the Chief, some “fans” have always insinuated that the Steelers are cheapskates. It always frustrated me because they’re always at the cap, always classy and regularly took all franchise employees to SB’s even when it wasn’t common to do so. Most importantly, they never let their own superstar guys get to free agency unless they overvalued themselves. I think most of it came from their culture of drafting and development vs. big free agents signings.

My question/concern is that I’m detecting a little bit of cheapness from Art II that I haven’t seen before. They needed a QB coach when they had Ben, Landry, Batch and so on but not when they have Dobbs and Rudolph? Butler taking over the OLBs instead of hiring a new coach? Not having a quality guy to work with Coach Tomlin until this year? And most disturbing, waiting for contracts to expire before terminating coaches that probably could’ve or should’ve been let go earlier such as Haley and Porter. It’s not my money and I’m not the boss, but if a coach seems to be on the way out, they should move on and hire coaches that they want. Certain players only have so much of a window and waiting for people’s contracts to expire seems like wasting valuable years. I know they have their own respectable rules for honoring commitments to players and coaches but I hope it’s not turning into a Mike Brown (Bengals) scenario in Pittsburgh. Thanks and welcome aboard!

Advertise with us

Brian: No, thank you, Alan, for setting perhaps an unbreakable record for longest mailbag prompt. But you don’t do this thing as long as the Rooney family has without having to make plenty of tough decisions, the kind that lend themselves to a “you can’t please everyone” type of outlook. And the Steelers have indeed taken criticism for some of those difficult calls over the years, as you acknowledge.

At the root of your question, though, is that I don’t think the coaching staff situation has anything to do with “cheapness.” It’s probably more of an organizational preference that intertwines with the emphasis the Steelers place on stability. Let’s look at your No. 1 coaching staff concern first.

Yes, the Steelers are one of just five NFL teams going into 2019 without an assistant whose title includes only quarterback duties. And yes, three of those five — Oakland, New York and, incidentally, New York — have head coaches who were once quarterback coaches themselves. But one other thing three of those five have in common? Three of the five most experienced quarterbacks in the NFL: Tom Brady, Eli Manning and Ben Roethlisberger. Sure, even guys like Drew Brees and Philip Rivers have quarterback coaches who probably are much more useful to the backups, but hey, Randy Fichtner might be just fine handling both his coordinator and quarterback duties in Pittsburgh.

Keith Butler is doing the same thing on the defensive side, assuming outside linebacker coach duties since Joey Porter wasn’t brought back. Not even half the league even has a dedicated assistant for that subset of players. You won’t get any pushback from me on the idea that a “quality control” type of assistant for Mike Tomlin, as new secondary coach Teryl Austin seemingly will be, was overdue.

But to your last question, about letting the contracts of assistants such as Todd Haley and Porter expire, doesn’t this essentially mirror how the Steelers handle their coaching situation at large? They’re loyal and hesitant to change, more often than not, and from 10,000 feet it’s one of the aspects for which the franchise is most often praised. To that end, here’s another factor to consider in the Steelers having a relatively tight coaching circle: Tomlin is the third longest tenured coach in the NFL, and guess who keeps even fewer traditional assistant coaches than Tomlin? Bill Belichick, whose New England staff was the only one smaller than Tomlin’s in 2018, according to headcoachranking.com.

Advertise with us

Staff expansion in the league has been a growing trend, literally, over the past decade or so. Tomlin has been entrenched for even longer than that, so it probably shouldn’t be too surprising that the Steelers take more of an old school, head-coach-hands-on approach with him still at the top.

John S.: The Steelers have been very slooooowwwww starters the last couple of seasons. Tying the Browns last year and needing a blocked punt touchdown to beat them the year before. How many points will Big Ben hang against the Patriots?

Brian: Well, they should’ve had at least a few more points in last year’s opener, when you consider Chris Boswell’s missed field goal that would’ve won it in overtime, the strip-sack on Roethlisberger as the Steelers were nearing midfield and James Conner’s fourth-quarter fumble.

But, in an attempt to use #math to give a reasonable projection to your question, over the past five seasons the Steelers have averaged 26.2 points per game in their season opener, and the Patriots have averaged 27.4 points allowed in their season opener. Deduct a few points for an offense playing its first real game without Antonio Brown, consider the Vegas odds of New England minus-6 with an over/under of 51.5 and let’s say Roethlisberger’s crew “hangs” 23 on New England Sept. 8. Will that be enough?

Be sure to compliment Joe Starkey and also send me questions for next week. Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.