(This will be general manager Kevin Colbert’s 20th season in charge of the Steelers player personnel department, and 20th draft under him. This is the fourth and final story in a series looking at the best and worst of those draft choices. Today, those drafted and undrafted rookies signed after the third round.)

The Steelers long have hit it big in the later rounds of the draft and beyond — those rookies who went undrafted and signed with them.

There’s too many to list, but L.C. Greenwood (10th round), Mike Wagner (11th), Ernie Holmes (8th), Donnie Shell (undrafted) and Randy Grossman (undrafted) helped pave the way for their 1970s dynasty. The tradition followed for many years, including under Colbert in this century.

Antonio Brown in the sixth round is a shining example. James Harrison would be, too, as an undrafted rookie in 2002 except he does not qualify because the Steelers cut him that year. He went on to play in NFL Europe and signed with Baltimore, who also cut him. The Steelers signed him four separate times, the final one in 2004.

Advertise with us

We only list five of the best and worst here, but our collection easily could stretch to a top 10 that would include players like William Gay, Vince Williams, Willie Colon and Jesse James. Or a bottom 10 that would add Alameda Ta'amu, Daniel Sepulveda, Orien Harris and Danny Farmer.

Nevertheless, we kept it to five of each and we present our choices here:

THE 5 BEST

1. Antonio Brown, WR (2010, 6th, 195) – Brown left the Steelers this year for Oakland with 11,207 yards in 130 games. He’s the second-fastest to 11,000 in NFL history and holds the NFL record for most catches in any six-year span with 686. A Hall of Famer to be, he’s the best sixth-round draft choice in this century after Tom Brady.

2. Ike Taylor, CB (2003, 4th, 125) – Taylor became a starter in his third season and stayed there until an injury ended his career five games into 2014. He started 140 games over a 12-year career and often covered the foe’s best receiver. Only poor hands (14 career interceptions) prevented him from making Pro Bowls.

Advertise with us

3. Ramon Foster, OT (2009, undrafted) – A college tackle, he started 12 games at guard in his first two seasons and has been a starter ever since, mostly at left guard. Has 131 starts over 10 seasons and signed for another two this year. He’s among their best undrafted players ever.

4. Brett Keisel, DE (2002, 7th, 240) – A special teamer (and one season on IR) until his fifth season, Keisel became a fixture on some great Steelers defenses at right end. He started 114 games through 2014. Only 21 players were drafted after him in 2002.

5. Larry Foote, LB (2002, 4th, 128) – Foote became a starter in his third season and started 105 games for the Steelers, 134 total in the NFL that included one season each with Lions and Cardinals. He was a starter for two Super Bowl champs.

THE 5 WORST

1. Doran Grant, CB, (2015, 4th round, 121) – Grant was cut before his rookie season, added to the practice squad and then waived for good before 2016. He signed with four other teams through 2018 and played in three NFL games.

Advertise with us

2. Fred Gibson, WR, (2005, 4th, 131) – Cut before his rookie season, Gibson signed with four other NFL teams through 2007 without ever making a roster. He tried to switch careers and played in the NBA D-League for two teams in 2008-09.

3. Thaddeus Gibson, DE (2010, 4th, 116) – Continuing the “Gibson” bad luck, he was cut as a rookie and played in a total of four NFL games. He was out of football by 2013 after winding through seven NFL teams.

4. Mathias Nkwenti, OT, (2001, 4th, 111) – A relatively high fourth-rounder, this pick was acquired in a trade with the Jets when the Steelers moved down three spots in the first round and drafted Casey Hampton. He played in two games – one each in 2001 and 2003 and never again saw the field.

5. Tee Martin, QB, (2000, 5th, 163) – They made worse picks but not considering what they passed up at the same position – Tom Brady, drafted by the Patriots in the sixth round that year (199th). Martin played one game briefly for the Steelers late in a victory, two games with Oakland, then one season in NFL Europe before becoming a college coach. Brady, of course, is still playing.