(This will be general manager Kevin Colbert’s 20th season in charge of the Steelers player personnel department, and 20th draft under him. This is the third in a series looking at the best and worst of those draft choices. Today, the third-round picks.)

The third round long was considered important because NFL teams could still get good players at a much cheaper price.

The Steelers did get some good ones, and they drafted some that weren’t so good in this century. They also ran into some bad luck. Inside linebacker Sean Spence was an example of a player who looked exceptional in his first preseason. But he blew out his knee in the final preseason game as a rookie and spent his first two seasons on injured reserve and was never the same after that. Ironically, he returned to the Steelers to try to plug the hole created late in 2017 when Ryan Shazier was hurt.

They also created some of their own tough luck, such as cutting guard Kraig Urbik before his second season in 2010. He became a four-year starter in Buffalo and played seven more seasons.

Advertise with us

Here, then, for your viewing pleasure, we selected our best and worst third-round draft picks for the Steelers under Kevin Colbert:

THE 5 BEST

1. Max Starks, OT (2004, No. 75) – Starks started every game his second season and the Steelers won the Super Bowl. He would start 96 games for them over nine seasons at both tackles. He was unique in that he received the transition tag (2008) and franchise tag (2009, although he then signed a multi-year deal). The Steelers cut him in 2011, only to sign him after four games and he started the rest of that season and the next. He earned two rings.

2. Mike Wallace, WR (2009, No. 84) – Called a “one-trick pony” by Mike Tomlin, it still was a pretty good trick. In his four seasons with the Steelers, Wallace caught 235 passes for 4,042 yards and 32 touchdowns. He averaged 17.2 yards per catch in that time. He left as a free agent and had sporadic success with Miami and Baltimore.

3. Emmanuel Sanders, WR (2010, No. 82) – A member of one of Colbert’s best drafts (Maurkice Pouncey, Jason Worilds, Antonio Brown), he, Brown and Wallace formed the Young Money crew at wide receiver. Sanders was a complementary receiver in his four years with the Steelers, then blossomed into a Pro Bowler after signing with Denver, where he earned a ring and still plays.

Advertise with us

4. Chris Hope, FS (2002, No. 94) – Hope played mostly special teams his first two seasons, then started every game at free safety over his final two, including six in the postseason. He had three interceptions in 2005, helping the Steelers on their way to a Super Bowl win. Hope signed with the Titans as a free agent in 2006 and was their starter for the next five seasons.

5. James Conner, RB (2017, No. 105) – Although having played just two seasons, he did enough in 2018 to make this list. With Le’Veon Bell’s absence leaving a potential large hole at RB, Conner replaced him and rushed for 973 yards, a 4.5-yard average, added 55 receptions for 497 and scored 13 touchdowns, even though an ankle injury cost him three games.

THE 5 WORST

1. Bruce Davis, LB (2008, No. 88) – Cast among the worst drafts under Colbert that included Limas Sweed at No. 2, Davis played in five games as a rookie, was cut before 2009 and played in 10 games for Oakland with no NFL starts and no sacks – after getting 29 sacks in his career at UCLA. He last played in 2012 in the CFL.

2. Willie Reid, WR (2006, No. 95) – Drafted as a receiver/returner, Reid did little of either. He played one game as a rookie then went on injured reserve. He played in six games his second season and had one career punt return, seven kick returns, four receptions. He never played after 2007.

Advertise with us

3. Dri Archer, WR/RB (2014, No. 97) – Then-coordinator Todd Haley wanted a good, little, quick back. He got little and quick with Archer but not good. Archer played 20 games with the Steelers over two seasons and did virtually nothing. He had 10 carries for 40 yards and 7 catches for 23, all in 2014. He had one punt return and 23 kickoff returns for a 22.4-yard average. He never played again.

4. Curtis Brown, CB (2011, No. 95) – Brown played in 34 games but not one play he ever made was memorable. He never started but did have 49 combined tackles in his career with one forced fumble and one pass defense. After playing in just seven games in his third season, he never played again in the NFL.

5. Sammie Coates, WR (2015, No. 87) – Colbert had great success drafting receivers in the second and third rounds, but this wasn’t one. He had size and speed but dropped way too many passes, perhaps the result of a broken finger in his second season when he caught just 21 of the 49 passes thrown his way. A knee injury in his third camp required surgery and the Steelers traded him to the Browns before the season for a seventh-rounder. He caught 7 passes the past two seasons for the Browns and Texans. The Chiefs signed him in February.