Third in an offseason series breaking down the Steelers by position:
With his ability to run in the open field and the strength to shove defensive backs to the ground like rag dolls, Vance McDonald has given the Steelers the type of tight end they’ve desired since the retirement of Heath Miller.
Big, strong and fast, McDonald is something of a modern-day Mark Bavaro — tough enough to bully defenders, athletic enough to run around them.
The Steelers hit it big with McDonald, bigger than they did with Ladarius Green, whom they brought in via free agency from the then-San Diego Chargers and quickly discovered he was damaged goods.
Green was going to be the pass-catching replacement for the retired Miller, a down-the-seams tight end who could stretch the field like a wide receiver. But recurring concussions kept him from making any kind of significant impact with the Steelers, appearing in only six games and catching just 18 passes for 304 yards.
McDonald had a history of injuries with the San Francisco 49ers, and he’s been nagged by several since the Steelers acquired him and a fifth-round draft choice in a trade for a fourth-round pick. After missing six games with ankle and shoulder injuries in 2017, he missed the entire preseason and was inactive for the opening game in Cleveland in 2018.
Read More
But when he returned, McDonald showed the Steelers and the rest of the NFL the type of tight end he can be.
In the first quarter of a nationally televised game in Tampa, McDonald took a short pass along the sideline, turned upfield and ran over Buccaneers safety Chris Conte by shoving him backwards to the ground with one hand en route to a 75-yard touchdown.
It was the highlight play of the year for the Steelers, and it started a season for McDonald in which he caught 50 passes for 610 yards and four TDs. It was the most receptions and yards in a season by a tight end since Miller, and it reminded the Steelers of the type of production they could get from the position.
“We all saw what can happen when you get the ball in his hands quick enough,” quarterback Ben Roethlisberger said of his new target.
But McDonald wasn’t alone.
Jesse James added 30 catches for 423 yards and two touchdowns and stretched his streak of consecutive regular-season games played to 56, third longest among active tight ends. Between them, McDonald and James combined for 80 catches, 1,033 yards and six touchdowns — Miller-type numbers, even if it was among two players.
While the Steelers are expecting McDonald to have an even bigger impact this season and help ease the expected loss of Pro Bowl receiver Antonio Brown, the same cannot be said for James.
He is an unrestricted free agent, and the Steelers expect him to both receive and accept an offer on the open market greater than what they would pay to retain him. While James is a dependable receiver — he caught 30 of his 39 intended targets, a catch rate of 76.9 percent — his blocking leaves something to be desired.
What’s more, James isn’t the only tight end whose contract is up.
Xavier Grimble, the No. 3 tight end, is a restricted free agent, and Jake McGee, who spent the season on injured reserve, is an exclusive rights free agent.
Grimble is an athletic tight end who can run, but he did not endear himself to the coaches with his ill-advised decision in Denver to try to run over a defensive back at the goal line instead of going in for an easy touchdown. The gaffe resulted in a fumble and a touchback and was one of the defining plays of the loss to the Broncos, if not the season.
The Steelers think McGee, a sure-handed, pass-catching tight end, could be a surprise. He is one of those players who makes coaches take notice in practice with his consistency and uncanny ability to catch everything thrown in his direction.
If James leaves in free agency, the Steelers could look for a backup to McDonald in the draft, where it is considered a good year for tight ends. Early projections have as many as three potentially going in the first round.
The Steelers wouldn’t think about a tight end until at least the fourth round, possibly even the fifth, which is where they drafted James.
Either way, it looks as though they will have a new one to the roster.
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac
STEELERS TIGHT ENDS
Vance McDonald — Year acquired: 2017 trade (SF 49ers); School: Rice; Contract status: Signed through 2021
Jesse James — Year acquired: 2015 draft, fifth round; School: Penn State; Contract status: Unrestricted FA
Xavier Grimble — Year acquired: 2015 FA; School: USC; Contract status: Restricted FA
Jake McGee — Year acquired: 2017 undrafted FA; School: Florida; Contract status: Exclusive rights FA





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.